Treat v. Town Plan & Zoning Commission
Cases that cite this one
16 later published cases cite this decision.
- Franchi v. Farmholme, Inc. (Conn. 1983)
- Goulet v. Zoning Board of Appeals (Conn. App. Ct. 2009)
- Amedy v. Planning Zoning Commission, No. Cv 96 61107 S (Nov. 6, 1997) (Connecticut Superior Court 1997)
- Pignataro v. Cappiello, No. 319646 (Dec. 5, 1996) (Connecticut Superior Court 1996)
- Halpin v. South Windsor Planning Zoning, No. Cv930525552s (Jan. 18, 1995) (Connecticut Superior Court 1995)
- Helbig v. Zoning Commission of Noank Fire District (Conn. 1981)
- Daviau v. Planning Commission (Conn. 1978)
- Allard v. Thalheimer (N.H. 1976)
- Sonn v. Planning Commission (Conn. 1976)
- Finn v. Planning & Zoning Commission (Conn. 1968)
- Town of Wallingford v. Roberts (Conn. 1958)
- Greene v. Ridgefield Planing Zoning, No. Cv 90-0442131s (Jan. 6, 1993) (Connecticut Superior Court 1993)
- Indian R. Assoc. v. N. Branford Plan., No. Cv91-0392496 (May 11, 1992) (Connecticut Superior Court 1992)
- Posick v. Zoning Board, Beacon Falls, No. Cv90 033027s (Dec. 21, 1990) (Connecticut Superior Court 1990)
- Brenton v. Oxford Plan. Zon. Comm'n, No. Cv90 03 23 73s (Dec. 7, 1990) (Connecticut Superior Court 1990)
- Leech v. Gaetz (Connecticut Superior Court 1973)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
On October 16, 1956, the defendant, after proper legal notice, adopted a comprehensive town plan for the town of Orange. This plan proposed that the minimum size of residential lots be 40.000 square feet, with a minimum front footage of 160 feet at the street line. At an evening meeting on October 30, 1956, after public notice, the defendant amended the zoning regulations by increasing the minimum lot size in an AA residence zone from 30.000 to 40,000 square feet and the minimum width at the street line from 150 to 160 feet.
The basic question is whether the defendant acted arbitrarily and illegally. The unchallenged finding of the trial court is that the plaintiff failed to file any petition with his map as required by the ordinance. The form of petition prescribed sets forth a number of agreements into which the developer must enter as consideration for approval of the map. These obligations are designed to protect the town from default by the developer and to insure proper street layout, drainage and other such matters in the public interest. They cannot be considered inconsequential. The plaintiff claims that he must be excused from filing a petition because the defendant did not request him to do so and also because in a number of other instances involving developers no petition was required by the defendant. This excuse is of no avail. The defendant must insist that the legislative direction governing the filing of a final subdivision map be followed. Beach v. Planning & Zoning Commission, 141 Conn. 79, 84, 103 A.2d 814; New Haven v. Fresenius, 75 Conn. 145, 149, 52 A. 823. It cannot waive the requirements of the ordinance pertaining to the manner of
The plaintiff also assigns error in the court’s refusal to find, in accordance with his draft finding, that he failed to file a petition because the defendant did not ask him to do so. If this fact were added to the finding, it would be ineffective for the reasons stated heretofore. Furthermore, parties dealing with a public agency are bound at their peril to notice the measure of its authority. State v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co., 138 Conn. 334, 339, 84 A.2d 579.
The plaintiff has assigned error in rulings upon the admission of evidence. His offer to relate what he did to prepare his map and what was stated to him by the defendant’s members was immaterial under the rule stated in Nicholaus v. Bridgeport, supra. So also was his offer of evidence to the effect that other maps had been approved by the defendant even though they did not comply with the requirements as to lot size and were not accompanied by a proper petition. For the reasons hereinbefore stated, the plaintiff acquired no right, because the defendant had failed to comply with the provisions of the ordinance on previous occasions, to omit the filing of a proper petition with his map.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.
This amendment of the regulations was held invalid in Treat v. Town Plan & Zoning Commission, 145 Conn. 136, 139, 139 A.2d 601, but its invalidity is not involved in the instant case.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.