District Court, District of Columbia, 2014

Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission

Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
District Court, District of Columbia · Decided September 16, 2014 · Civil Action No. 2013-1916 · Judge Paul L. Friedman
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission

Opinion

UNI'(I`F.`D S'I`A'I`I;'LS DIS'I`RICT COURT F()R TI~IIE l)IS"i`RIC"l` OF COLUMBIA ) SJ:`_~ICLJRl'I`IIZIS INDU STRY AND I*`INANCI/-\Ii `) MARKI;S'I`S ASSOCIA'}`I(`)N, er ci/., ) ) Plaiiitit`t`s, ) ) v. ) Civil Action No. 13-1916 (PL]`*`) ) UNITEl) S'i`A'ii`li:fS C()MMODI'I`Y FU"!`U`RIES ) TRADING COMMISSION, ) ) De'i"eiidaiit. ) ) ()RDER For the reasons set forth in the ()pinion issued this saine day [Dkt. No. 58], it is hereby ()Rl)l§')l{l`;`ll`) that defendant’s inotion to dismiss [Dkt. No. 28] is GILANTED in part and Di§_“€Nli§*jD in part; it is FUR'if`I--IIEI{ ()RIV)IV;YRI£I) that platintiffs’ claims relating to the Process ibr a Desigiiated Coiitract Market or Swap ll€xectitioii Facility To i\/lake a Swap Avaiiable to 'l`r‘ade, Swap 'I`raiisaetioii Coiiipliaiice and innpleiiieritatioii Scheduie, and 'I`rade Exeeution Requireiiient Un.dei' the Coniniodity l?lxchaiige Act (""l"rade Exeeution Rtile"), 78 Fed. Reg. 33606 (June 4, 2()13), are DlSMlSSllil) WI'l`l'IOli'l` PR]F)JIJDICIE for lack of standing; it is i*`UR'l`i--IIY;EI{ ORDIV_~`.R!§§L) that piairitii"i"s’ motion for suinmary judgment [Dkt. No. 2}_'] is GIKAN"]`}EI) in part and Dl§iNIl§i]i) in part; it is Flll?."l`l‘il§§l{ C)RI)IFIRIT£L) that defi`<zndant’s motion for summary judgment [Dkt. No. 23] is GR/-\N"i"IED in part and DIENII`:§I) in part; it is l*`UR'l`l-ll¥`.l{ ORl)lY-£Rlf£l) thatjttdgnaeiit is entered in favor ofdefendaiit as to plaintiffs’ elainis relating to the following agency actions: l. interpretive Gtiidaiice and Policy Stateiiieiit Regarding Coriipliance with Certain Sweip Reguiatioiis ("Cross~t$ordel‘ Aetioii"), 78 Fed. Rcg. 45292 (July 26, 2()13); liarge 'l"rader Reportiiig 'for Physicai Coniinodity Swaps ("l_azirge 'l`radei' Reporting Rtile"), 76 Fed. Reg. 43851 (Juiy 22, 2011); Ctistonier Cleztring Docunieritatiori, 'l"imiiig of Acceptance for Clearing, and Clearing l\/leinbei‘ Risk Maiiageiiierit ("Straiglit-'l`lirougli Processing l{t\le"), Fed_ Reg. 21278 (April 9, 2()12)', and Ciearing Requireiiieiit l)eterniiiiatioii Under Section Q(h) of the CEA ("Clearilig Detenninatioii Rule"), 77 Fed. Reg. 74284 (Dec. 13, 2012); it is l"`lll{"l"leel!§_"ll{ C)I{`I)I`;`SRI~F`,D that the following agency actions are Rl`fiM/-\NDEI) Wi']"l`eiOlJ"l" V/-\CA’}`LFR to the United States Coinniodity l*`utures Tradiiig Conirnissioii for further proceedings consistent with the Opinion issued this same day: l.

Real-'l`iine Public Reportiiig of Swap "l`ransaction Data ("Real~'l`iiiie Reporting Rule"), 77 lied. Reg. 1182 (Jan. 9, 2012); Recordl<eeping and Reportiiig Reqtiircriieiits ("SDR Reporting Rtile"), 77 Fed. Reg. 2136 (Jan. 13, 2012); Registration of Swap l`)ealers and Major Swap Participaiits ("Swap l`;`ntity Registratioii Rtile"), 77 I~"`ed. Reg. 2613 (Jan. }9, 2012); Swap Dealer and l\/lajor Swztp Participaiit Reeordkeepiiig, Reportiiig, and l)uties Rules; l~"`tittlres Coinniissioii l\/lercliaiit and introducing Brol<er Coiillicts oflnterest Rules; and Cliiet`(.`.oiiipliaiice Ofticei‘ Rules for Swap Deetlers, Majoi' Swap l’artieipaiits, and Ftittlres Coniniission l\/lercliaiits ("Daily 'i"radiiig Records," "Risl< l\/lan'ageiiieiit," and ‘°Chietl"Coiiipliaiice Offcei' Rtiies"), 77 l*`ed. Reg. 20128 (April 3, 2012); l"`tirtliei' l_)ei'iriitioii of "Swap Dealer," "Seetirity-Based Swap l‘)ealei‘," "Majoi' Swap Participatiit," "l\/I_ajol' Security-Based Swap Participaiit," and "I‘;`,ligible Coiitract Participziiit" ("lfjiitity l`)efliiitioii Rule"), 77 Fed. Reg. 30596 (l\/lay 23, 20:2); 6. Swap Data Ruecordkeepiiag and Reportiiig Requirerneiits: Pre-li§iiactniexit and "i`raiisitiori Swaps ("l-listoricai SDR Reporting Rule"), 77 i*`ed. Reg. 35200 (June 12, 2012); 7. Coiitiniiatioii, Port'l"olio Recoziciliation, Portfolio Coiiipression, and Swap 'l"radiiig Reizitioiisliip Docuineiitatioii Requirerneiits for Swap Dealers and l\/laioi' Swap li’a:‘ticipaiits ("Portfolio Reconeiliatioii and Documentation Rule"), 77 Fed. Reg. 55904 (Sep. l l, 2012); and 8. Core Priiieiples and Other Requireiiients for Swap Execution l*`acilities ("Slz`ili` Registratioii Rule"), 78 Fed. Reg. 33476 (June 4, Z(ll 3); it is PAUL L. FIKIEDMAN United States l)istriet judge SO ORDlIZRlF`,D.

DATE; al \\¢,,\ \~.\

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.