81,7('67$7(6',675,&7&2857 )257+(',675,&72)&2/80%,$ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  7$0(&.$0(55,&.et al.   3ODLQWLIIV    Y  &LYLO$FWLRQ1R $%-   ',675,&72)&2/80%,$   'HIHQGDQW  BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  0(025$1'8023,1,21

 3ODLQWLIIV 7DPHFND 0HUULFN DQG KHU DGXOW VRQ 5RQDOG :DVKLQJWRQ EURXJKW WKLV DFWLRQ

DJDLQVW GHIHQGDQW WKH 'LVWULFW RI &ROXPELD VHHNLQJ WR FROOHFW DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV LQFXUUHG ZKLOH

EULQJLQJDVXFFHVVIXODGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQXQGHUWKH,QGLYLGXDOVZLWK'LVDELOLWLHV(GXFDWLRQ$FW

³,'($´   86&  †  et seq  1RZ SHQGLQJ EHIRUH WKH &RXUW LV SODLQWLIIV¶ PRWLRQ IRU

DWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQGFRVWV3OV¶0RWIRU$WW¶\V¶)HHV>'NW@ ³3OV¶0RW´ 3OV¶0HPRI3

$LQ6XSSRI3OV¶0RW>'NW@ ³3OV¶0HP´ DW

 3ODLQWLIIV DUH VHHNLQJ  LQ DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV DQG  LQ FRVWV UHODWHG WR WKH

XQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQ&RPSO>'NW@ˆ 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW([WR3OV¶

0HP>'NW@ ³6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,´ DWLQDGGLWLRQWRLQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHV

DQG LQFRVWVIRUSXUVLQJWKLVDFWLRQLQIHGHUDOFRXUWSee 3OV¶0HPDW 6WDWHPHQWRI

$FFRXQW([WR3OV¶6XSSO)LOLQJ>'NW@ ³6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,,´ DW

  7KH SDUWLHV DJUHHG LQ WKHLU 5XOH  5HSRUW WKDW WKLV FDVH FDQ EH UHVROYHG WKURXJK D GLVSRVLWLYHPRWLRQIRUDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVLQVWHDGRIDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWSee 5XOH 5HSRUW>'NW@DW   )RU WKH IROORZLQJ UHDVRQV WKH PRWLRQ ZLOO EH JUDQWHG LQ SDUW  7KH &RXUW ZLOO DZDUG

 LQ DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV DQG  LQ FRVWV IRU SXUVXLQJ WKH XQGHUO\LQJ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH

SURFHHGLQJDQGLQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQG LQFRVWVIRUOLWLJDWLQJWKHIHHSHWLWLRQLQ

WKLV&RXUW

%$&.*5281'

 5RQDOG :DVKLQJWRQ LV D GHDI DGXOW VWXGHQW ZKR UHTXLUHV LQVWUXFWLRQ WR EH SURYLGHG LQ

$PHULFDQ6LJQ/DQJXDJH ³$6/´ +HDULQJ2IILFHU'HWHUPLQDWLRQ([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW

@ ³+2'´ DW see also id.ˆ+HDOVRVXIIHUVIURPLPSXOVLYHDQGDQJHUEDVHGEHKDYLRUDO

RXWEXUVWV  Id. ˆ   +H KDV DWWHQGHG PRUH WKDQ D GR]HQ SXEOLF QRQSXEOLF DQG UHVLGHQWLDO

SODFHPHQWVLQWKHODVWVHYHQ\HDUVId. ˆ 3OV¶0HPDW±

 $WWKHHQGRI1RYHPEHU0U:DVKLQJWRQZDVUHOHDVHGIURPD'&'HSDUWPHQWRI

<RXWK5HKDELOLWDWLRQ6HUYLFHV ³'<56´ VFKRRODQGZDVSODFHGLQDIRVWHUKRPHLQ0DU\ODQG

+2' DW± see also id. ˆ3ULRUWRKLVUHOHDVH6WHYLH1DERUV0U:DVKLQJWRQ¶VFRXUWDSSRLQWHG

VSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQDGYRFDWHHPDLOHGWKH'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELD3XEOLF6FKRROV¶'LUHFWRURI6SHFLDO

(GXFDWLRQ DQG UHTXHVWHG DQ ,QGLYLGXDOL]HG (GXFDWLRQ 3URJUDP ³,(3´  PHHWLQJ IRU 0U

:DVKLQJWRQ  3OV¶ 0HP DW   see also ([  WR 3OV¶ 0HP >'NW  @  0U 1DERUV KDG D

FRQIHUHQFH FDOO ZLWK VHYHUDO HPSOR\HHV DW 'LVWULFW RI &ROXPELD 3XEOLF 6FKRROV ³'&36´  EXW

'&36GLGQRWDGRSWWKHSURJUDPKHSURSRVHGDQGLWGLGQRWRIIHUWRFRQYHQHDQ,(3PHHWLQJ3OV¶

0HPDW

 )ROORZLQJ'&36¶UHIXVDOWRSURYLGHVHUYLFHVRUFRQYHQHDQ,(3PHHWLQJ0V0HUULFNILOHG

DQDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGXHSURFHVVFRPSODLQWRQKHUVRQ¶VEHKDOI&RPSOˆ 6KHDOOHJHGWKDW'&36

GHQLHGKHUVRQDIUHHDSSURSULDWHSXEOLFHGXFDWLRQ ³)$3(´ ZKHQLWIDLOHGWRSURYLGHKLPZLWK

VSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQVHUYLFHVVXFKDV$6/WXWRULQJId.ˆ 3OV¶0HPDW +2'DW±)XUWKHU

VKH UHTXHVWHG WKH IROORZLQJ IRUPV RI UHOLHI     DQ RUGHU FRPSHOOLQJ '&36 WR SURYLGH 0U   :DVKLQJWRQZLWKVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQVHUYLFHVE\DQ$/6FHUWLILHGLQVWUXFWRUWKURXJK'&36¶+RPH

DQG+RVSLWDO,QVWUXFWLRQ3URJUDP ³++,3´   DFRPSHQVDWRU\HGXFDWLRQDZDUGLQWKHIRUPRI

 KRXUV RI LQVWUXFWLRQ LQ $6/  DQG   DQ LQGHSHQGHQW HYDOXDWLRQ WR GHWHUPLQH DSSURSULDWH

FRPSHQVDWRU\HGXFDWLRQIRU0U:DVKLQJWRQ+2'DW ±

 7KH+HDULQJ2IILFHUFRQFOXGHGWKDW'&36GLGLQGHHGGHQ\0U:DVKLQJWRQD)$3(ZKHQ

LWIDLOHGWRLPSOHPHQWKLV,(3DIWHUKHZDVSODFHGLQDIRVWHUKRPHLQODWH1RYHPEHU+2'

DW$QGRQ$SULOWKH+HDULQJ2IILFHURUGHUHGWKDW0U:DVKLQJWRQUHFHLYHKRXUV

RI LQGLYLGXDO WXWRULQJ LQ $6/ HLWKHU WKURXJK '&36 RU WKURXJK DQ LQGHSHQGHQWWXWRU IXQGHG E\

'&36DWPDUNHWUDWHV+2'DW &RPSOˆˆ± 3OV¶0HPDW

 2Q2FWREHUSODLQWLIIVILOHGDFRPSODLQWLQWKLV&RXUWVHHNLQJWRFROOHFWIHHVDQG

FRVWVLQFXUUHGDVSDUWRIWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHKHDULQJSee generally &RPSO3ODLQWLIIVILOHGDPRWLRQ

IRUDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVRQ-DQXDU\see 3OV¶0RWDQGWKHPRWLRQLVIXOO\EULHIHG

67$1'$5'2)5(9,(:

8QGHUWKH,'($WKH&RXUWKDVWKHGLVFUHWLRQWR³DZDUGUHDVRQDEOHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDVSDUW

RIWKHFRVWVWRDSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\´LQDQDGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJ³ZKRLVWKHSDUHQWRIDFKLOG

ZLWKDGLVDELOLW\´86&† L  % L , ,IDFRXUWGHWHUPLQHVWKDWWKHSODLQWLIIVHHNLQJ

DWWRUQH\V¶IHHVLVDSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\LWPXVWGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHUHTXHVWHGDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDUH

UHDVRQDEOHReed v. District of Columbia)G '&&LU &RXUWVW\SLFDOO\

GHWHUPLQH WKH UHDVRQDEOHQHVV RI DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV EDVHG RQ WKH ³QXPEHU RI KRXUV UHDVRQDEO\

H[SHQGHGRQWKHOLWLJDWLRQPXOWLSOLHGE\DUHDVRQDEOHKRXUO\UDWH´Hensley v. Eckerhart86

   

  'HI¶V2SSWR3OV¶0RW>'NW@ ³'HI¶V2SS´ 3OV¶5HSO\WR'HI¶V2SS>'NW @ ³3OV¶5HSO\´    $SODLQWLIIEHDUVWKHEXUGHQRIHVWDEOLVKLQJERWKWKHUHDVRQDEOHQHVVRIWKHKRXUO\UDWHDQG

WKHUHDVRQDEOHQHVVRIWKHQXPEHURIKRXUVVSHQWRQDSDUWLFXODUWDVNEley v. District of Columbia

 )G  '&&LU FLWLQJCovington v. District of Columbia)G±

 '& &LU    see also In re North   )G    '& &LU     7R VKRZ WKH

UHDVRQDEOHQHVVRIWKHKRXUO\UDWHVDSODLQWLIIPXVWVXEPLWHYLGHQFHUHODWHGWR   ³WKHDWWRUQH\V¶

ELOOLQJ SUDFWLFHV´    ³WKH DWWRUQH\V¶VNLOOH[SHULHQFHDQGUHSXWDWLRQ´ DQG  ³WKHSUHYDLOLQJ

PDUNHWUDWHVLQWKHUHOHYDQWFRPPXQLW\´Covington)GDW7RVKRZWKHUHDVRQDEOHQHVV

RIKRXUVVSHQWRQDWDVNDSODLQWLIIPXVWVXEPLWD³VXIILFLHQWO\GHWDLOHG>LQYRLFH@WRSHUPLWWKH

'LVWULFW &RXUW WR PDNH DQ LQGHSHQGHQW GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ZKHWKHU RU QRW WKH KRXUV FODLPHG DUH

MXVWLILHG´Nat’l Ass’n of Concerned Veterans v. Sec’y of Def.)G  '&&LU

  

$IWHUWKHPRYLQJSDUW\KDVPHWWKLVEXUGHQWKHQXPEHURIKRXUVDQGUDWHDUHSUHVXPHG

UHDVRQDEOH DQG WKH QRQPRYLQJ SDUW\ PXVW UHEXW WKH PRYLQJ SDUW\¶V VKRZLQJ ZLWK ³HTXDOO\

VSHFLILF FRXQWHUYDLOLQJ HYLGHQFH´  Covington  )G DW  ± TXRWLQJ Nat’l Ass’n of

Concerned Veterans)GDW

$1$/<6,6

'HIHQGDQW GRHV QRW GLVSXWH WKDW SODLQWLIIV ZHUH WKH SUHYDLOLQJ SDUWLHV LQ WKH XQGHUO\LQJ

DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQZLWKLQWKHPHDQLQJRIWKH,'($DQGWKDWWKH\DUHWKHUHIRUHHQWLWOHGWRVRPH

DPRXQWRIDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVSee 'HI¶V2SSDW7KHRQO\TXHVWLRQEHIRUHWKH&RXUWLVZKHWKHU

WKHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVVRXJKWE\SODLQWLIIVDUHUHDVRQDEOH

, 7KHKRXUVH[SHQGHGE\SODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHOZHUHUHDVRQDEOH

3ODLQWLIIVDVNIRUIRU KRXUVRIZRUNSHUIRUPHGWROLWLJDWHWKHXQGHUO\LQJ

DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHHGLQJ  'HIHQGDQW GRHV QRW WDNH LVVXH ZLWK WKH GRFXPHQWDWLRQ SURYLGHG LQ

  VXSSRUWRIWKLVUHTXHVWRUZLWKDQ\VSHFLILFKRXUVELOOHG+RZHYHULWDUJXHVWKDWD³UHGXFWLRQ

LV DSSURSULDWH EHFDXVHPXFK RI WKH UHOLHI VRXJKW ZDV QRWREWDLQHG´  'HI¶V 2SS DW    $W D

PLQLPXPGHIHQGDQWDVNVWKH&RXUWWR³UHGXFHWKHLQYRLFHE\WKHKRXUVGHYRWHGH[FOXVLYHO\WRWKH

SODFHPHQWVRXJKWEXWQRWREWDLQHG´DQGLWSRLQWVWRDQHQWU\IRUKRXUVRIZRUNWKDWUHODWHG

H[FOXVLYHO\WRWKH++,3SODFHPHQWUHTXHVWId see 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,DW ³/HJDOUHVHDUFK 

UHTXLUHPHQWVIRU+RPH+RVSLWDO,QVWUXFWLRQ3URJUDP ³++,3´ DQGZKHWKHU5:ZRXOGTXDOLI\´ 

3ODLQWLIIV KDYH WKH EXUGHQ RI GHPRQVWUDWLQJ WKDW WKH QXPEHU RI KRXUV H[SHQGHG RQ

SDUWLFXODUWDVNVE\WKHLUDWWRUQH\VZHUHUHDVRQDEOHNat’l Ass’n of Concerned Veterans)G

DW   $WWRUQH\V PXVW ³PDLQWDLQ FRQWHPSRUDQHRXV FRPSOHWH DQG VWDQGDUGL]HG WLPH UHFRUGV

ZKLFKDFFXUDWHO\UHIOHFWWKHZRUNGRQHE\HDFKDWWRUQH\´Id.³:KHUHWKHGRFXPHQWDWLRQRIKRXUV

LVLQDGHTXDWHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWPD\UHGXFHWKHDZDUGDFFRUGLQJO\´Hensley86DW

&RXUWVDOVRKDYHWKHGLVFUHWLRQWRUHGXFHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDZDUGVWRDFFRXQWIRUSDUWLDORU

OLPLWHGVXFFHVVRQWKHPHULWVE\HLWKHUHOLPLQDWLQJVSHFLILFKRXUVRUUHGXFLQJWKHDZDUGDVDZKROH

Hensley86DW±)RUSXUSRVHVRIUHGXFLQJWKHDZDUGDPRXQWEDVHGRQWKHODFNRI

VXFFHVVDFRXUWVKRXOGFRQVLGHUZKHWKHU³WKHSODLQWLIIDFKLHYH>G@DOHYHORIVXFFHVVWKDWPDNHVWKH

KRXUVUHDVRQDEO\H[SHQGHGDVDWLVIDFWRU\EDVLVIRUPDNLQJDIHHDZDUG´IdDW7KLVLVD

  +RZHYHU WKH SDUWLHV DQG WKH &RXUW LGHQWLILHG FHUWDLQ W\SRJUDSKLFDO HUURUV DQG WKH IHH DZDUGZLOOEHDGMXVWHGDFFRUGLQJO\7KHILUVWPLVWDNHZDVDWLPHHQWU\PDGHRQ0DUFK WKDW ELOOHG 0U 0RUDQ¶V UHVHDUFK WLPH DW D UDWH RI  SHU KRXU LQVWHDG RI   See 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,DW7KHELOOVKRXOGUHIOHFWDFKDUJHRI  LQVWHDGRI VRWKH ELOOZLOOEHUHGXFHGE\1H[WWKHUHLVDQHQWU\IURP0DUFKLQZKLFK0U1DERUV¶ WUDYHOWLPHZDVLQDGYHUWHQWO\ELOOHGDWSHUKRXULQVWHDGRISHUKRXUSee 6WDWHPHQW RI$FFRXQW,DW 'HI¶V2SSDW 3OV¶5HSO\DW7KHELOOUHIOHFWHGDFKDUJHRIIRU WUDYHOEXWLWVKRXOGKDYHRQO\FKDUJHG7KHWRWDOELOOZLOOEHUHGXFHGE\IRUWKLV HUURU,QDGGLWLRQSODLQWLIIVKDYHZLWKGUDZQD)HEUXDU\HQWU\LQZKLFKWKHLUDWWRUQH\V DFFLGHQWDOO\FKDUJHGKRXUVRIWLPHDWDUDWHRIIRUDWRWDORI3OV¶5HSO\DW 7KLVZLOOUHGXFHWKHELOOE\$OWRJHWKHUWKHIHHDZDUGZLOOEHUHGXFHGE\   ,WLVXQFOHDULIGHIHQGDQWLVDVNLQJIRUDILIWHHQSHUFHQWUHGXFWLRQLQKRXUVRUWRWKHWRWDOIHH DZDUG   UHVXOWVRULHQWHGLQTXLU\ ³LWLVWKHdegree RIWKHSODLQWLII¶VVXFFHVVWKDWLVWKHFULWLFDOIDFWRUWRWKH

GHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHVL]HRIDUHDVRQDEOHIHH´A.S. v. District of Columbia)6XSSG

 ''& FLWLQJTex. State Teachers Ass’n v. Garland Indep. Sch. Dist. 86

   

+HUHWKHVWXGHQW¶VSDUHQWEURXJKWDQDGPLQLVWUDWLYHFRPSODLQWLQRUGHUWROLWLJDWHRQHLVVXH 

ZKHWKHU0U:DVKLQJWRQZDVGHQLHGD)$3(ZKHQ'&36IDLOHGWRLPSOHPHQWKLV,(3ZKHQKH

PRYHGLQWRDIRVWHUKRPH7KHFRPSODLQWVRXJKWWKUHHIRUPVRIUHOLHIIRUWKHDOOHJHGYLRODWLRQRI

WKH,'($   DQRUGHUFRPSHOOLQJ'&36WRSURYLGH0U:DVKLQJWRQZLWKDFHUWLILHG$6/WXWRU

WKURXJKWKH+RPHDQG+RVSLWDO,QVWUXFWLRQ3URJUDP   KRXUVRIFRPSHQVDWRU\HGXFDWLRQ 

DQG  DQLQGHSHQGHQWHGXFDWLRQHYDOXDWLRQ+2'DW ±

 )RUWKHUHDVRQVVHWRXWLQWKH+HDULQJ2IILFHU¶VGHFLVLRQWKHUHOLHIDZDUGHGZDVKRXUV

RIFRPSHQVDWRU\HGXFDWLRQLQ$6See +2'DW%XWWKH&RXUWGRHVQRWILQGLWWREHDSSURSULDWH

WRUHGXFHWKHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDZDUGE\ILIWHHQSHUFHQW³$UHGXFHGIHHDZDUGLVDSSURSULDWHLIWKH

UHOLHILVOLPLWHGLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHVFRSHRIWKHOLWLJDWLRQDVDZKROH´Hensley86DW

 see, e.g.Young v. District of Columbia )6XSSG± ''&  UHGXFLQJ

WKHIHHDZDUGE\WZHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWEHFDXVHWKHSODLQWLIIRQO\SUHYDLOHGRQRQHRIWKHWKUHHLVVXHV

SUHVHQWHG DQG WKH KHDULQJ RIILFHU GHQLHG DOO UHOLHI VRXJKW H[FHSW IRU FRPSHQVDWRU\ HGXFDWLRQ 

7KDWLVQRWWKHFDVHKHUH8OWLPDWHO\0V0HUULFNZDVVXFFHVVIXORQWKHIXQGDPHQWDOLVVXHWKDW

ZDVOLWLJDWHGEHIRUHWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHERDUGDQG0U:DVKLQJWRQUHFHLYHGWKHSULPDU\IRUPRI

UHOLHI UHTXHVWHG   FRQWLQXHG LQVWUXFWLRQ E\ D TXDOLILHG $6/ WXWRU WR PDNH XS IRU WKH KRXUV RI

HGXFDWLRQKHKDGEHHQGHQLHG See+2'DW*HQHUDOO\DQDWWRUQH\³VKRXOGUHFRYHUDIXOO\

FRPSHQVDWRU\IHH´ZKHUH³DSODLQWLIIKDVREWDLQHGH[FHOOHQWUHVXOWV´Hensley86DW

 0RUHRYHULWVHHPVDVLIWKHKRXUVRIFRPSHQVDWRU\HGXFDWLRQZDVDZDUGHGLQSODFHRI

DQLQGHSHQGHQWHGXFDWLRQHYDOXDWLRQEHFDXVHDZDUGLQJERWKZRXOGKDYHEHHQGXSOLFDWLYHSee   'HI¶V 2SS DW   ³7KH DZDUG ODFNHG DQ >LQGHSHQGHQW HGXFDWLRQ HYDOXDWLRQ@ EXW GLG SURYLGH

FRPSHQVDWRU\ HGXFDWLRQ ZKLFK ZDV WKH SXUSRVH EHKLQG VHHNLQJ DQ >LQGHSHQGHQW HGXFDWLRQ

HYDOXDWLRQ@´ $QGWKH+HDULQJ2IILFHUUHMHFWHG0V0HUULFN¶VUHTXHVWIRUVHUYLFHVWKURXJKWKH

++,3EHFDXVHWKDWZRXOGKDYHPDUNHGDVLJQLILFDQWFKDQJHLQWKHVWXGHQW¶VHGXFDWLRQDOSODFHPHQW

+2'DW6LQFHKLV,(3WHDPZDVVFKHGXOHGWRPHHWVRRQWKH+HDULQJ2IILFHUFRQFOXGHGWKDW

³LWZRXOGQRWEHDSSURSULDWHWRGLFWDWH>0U:DVKLQJWRQ¶V@RQJRLQJSODFHPHQW´Id.DW±

 )LQDOO\WKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHKHDULQJLQYROYHGRQHFODLPEDVHGRQRQHVHWRIIDFWVDQGOHJDO

WKHRULHVDQGWKHH[SHQGLWXUHRIDWWRUQH\WLPHZRXOGQRWKDYHFKDQJHGGUDPDWLFDOO\LIWKHKHDULQJ

RIILFHUKDGDZDUGHGWKHRWKHUIRUPVRIUHTXHVWHGUHOLHISee Hensley86DW ³>7@KH

GLVWULFW FRXUW VKRXOG IRFXV RQ WKH VLJQLILFDQFH RI WKH RYHUDOO UHOLHI REWDLQHG E\ WKH SODLQWLII LQ

UHODWLRQWRWKHKRXUVUHDVRQDEO\H[SHQGHGRQWKHOLWLJDWLRQ´ +RZHYHUWKH&RXUWGRHVUHFRJQL]H

WKDW 0U :DVKLQJWRQ ZDV QRW DZDUGHG VSHFLDO HGXFDWLRQ VHUYLFHV WKURXJK WKH ++,3 VR LW ZLOO

UHGXFHWKHWRWDOKRXUVH[SHQGHGE\WKHKRXUWLPHHQWU\LGHQWLILHGE\GHIHQGDQWSee 6WDWHPHQW

RI$FFRXQW,DW

 7KHUHIRUHWKH&RXUWILQGVWKDWSODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHOUHDVRQDEO\H[SHQGHG KRXUVRIZRUN

EXWLWZLOOUHGXFHWKHDZDUGE\ZKLFKUHIOHFWVWKHKRXUVFKDUJHGE\0U1DERUVRQ

2FWREHUIRUUHVHDUFKUHODWHGWRWKH+RPH+RVSLWDO,QVWUXFWLRQ3URJUDP 

,, 3ODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHOV¶UDWHVZHUHUHDVRQDEOH

3ODLQWLIIVEHDUWKHEXUGHQRIHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHUHDVRQDEOHQHVVRIWKHKRXUO\UDWHVFKDUJHGE\

WKHLU DWWRUQH\V IRU VHUYLFHV UHQGHUHG LQ WKH XQGHUO\LQJ SURFHHGLQJV  Eley   )G DW 

³:KHWKHU DQ KRXUO\ UDWH LV UHDVRQDEOH WXUQV RQ WKUHH VXEHOHPHQWV     µWKH DWWRUQH\¶V ELOOLQJ

SUDFWLFHV¶  µWKHDWWRUQH\¶VVNLOOH[SHULHQFHDQGUHSXWDWLRQ¶DQG  µWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHV

LQWKHUHOHYDQWFRPPXQLW\¶´Id.TXRWLQJCovington)GDW

  7RHVWDEOLVKWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHDSODLQWLIIPXVW³SURGXFHVDWLVIDFWRU\HYLGHQFH±in

addition to WKHDWWRUQH\¶VRZQDIILGDYLWV± WKDWWKHUHTXHVWHGUDWHVDUHLQOLQHZLWKWKRVHSUHYDLOLQJ

LQWKHFRPPXQLW\IRUVLPLODUVHUYLFHVE\ODZ\HUVRIUHDVRQDEO\FRPSDUDEOHVNLOOH[SHULHQFHDQG

UHSXWDWLRQ¶´Eley )GDWTXRWLQJBlum v. Stenson86 Q   )HH

PDWULFHV DUH ³RQH W\SH RI HYLGHQFH WKDW µSURYLGHV D XVHIXO VWDUWLQJ SRLQW¶ LQ FDOFXODWLQJ WKH

SUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH´Id.TXRWLQJCovington)GDW  DOWHUQDWLRQLQRULJLQDO 7KH

&RXUWRI$SSHDOVKDVQRWHGWKDWIHHPDWULFHVDUH³VRPHZKDWFUXGH´DQGFDQEHVXSSOHPHQWHGZLWK

RWKHUIRUPVRIHYLGHQFHVXFKDVVXUYH\VXSGDWLQJWKHPDWULFHV³DIILGDYLWVUHFLWLQJWKHSUHFLVHIHHV

WKDW DWWRUQH\V ZLWK VLPLODU TXDOLILFDWLRQV KDYH UHFHLYHG IURP IHHSD\LQJ FOLHQWV LQ FRPSDUDEOH

FDVHV´DQG³HYLGHQFHRIUHFHQWIHHVDZDUGHGE\WKHFRXUWVRUWKURXJKVHWWOHPHQWWRDWWRUQH\VZLWK

FRPSDUDEOHTXDOLILFDWLRQVKDQGOLQJVLPLODUFDVHV´IdDWTXRWLQJCovington)GDW 

  +HUHWKHUHLVQRGHEDWHDERXWZKHWKHUSODLQWLIIVKDYHPHWWKHLUEXUGHQDVWRWKHILUVWWZR

SURQJV DQG WKH FRQWURYHUV\ RYHU WKH UHDVRQDEOH KRXUO\ UDWH FHQWHUV VROHO\ RQ ZKDW VKRXOG EH

FRQVLGHUHGWKH³SUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH´See 'HI¶V2SSDW3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDWWKH\DUHHQWLWOHG

  3ODLQWLIIVKDYHSURYLGHGDGHTXDWHHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWLQJWKHLUDWWRUQH\V¶ELOOLQJSUDFWLFHVDQG WKHLUVNLOOH[SHULHQFHDQGUHSXWDWLRQDQGGHIHQGDQWGRHVQRWFKDOOHQJHWKHVXSSRUWLQJHYLGHQFH See 'HI¶V2SSDW± SRVLWLQJWKDWWKH³FKLHIGLVSXWH´LVDERXWWKHSURSHUSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH  3ODLQWLIIVZHUHUHSUHVHQWHGLQWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJE\6WHYLH1DERUV(VTDQG&KDUOHV 0RUDQ(VT0U1DERUVHDUQHGKLVODZGHJUHHIURP$PHULFDQ8QLYHUVLW\¶V:DVKLQJWRQ&ROOHJH RI/DZLQDQGZDVDGPLWWHGWRSUDFWLFHODZLQWKH'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELDLQZKHUHKHKDV SULPDULO\OLWLJDWHG,'($FDVHV'HFORI6WHYLH1DERUV(VT([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³1DERUV'HFO´ ˆ+HKDVVXFFHVVIXOO\OLWLJDWHGPRUHWKDQWKLUW\FDVHVLQWKH2IILFHRI'LVSXWH 5HVROXWLRQWKH'LVWULFW&RXUWIRUWKH'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELDDQGWKH'&&LUFXLWIdˆ&KDUOHV 0RUDQHDUQHGKLVODZGHJUHHIURP'XNH8QLYHUVLW\/DZ6FKRROLQ KHZDVDGPLWWHGWRWKH 'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELDEDULQ DQGKHKDVEHHQSUDFWLFLQJLQWKHILHOGRIVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQODZ IRFXVLQJRQ,'($FDVHVIRUDSSUR[LPDWHO\WZHQW\ILYH\HDUV'HFORI&KDUOHV$0RUDQ(VT ([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³0RUDQ'HFO´ ˆˆ±%RWKDWWRUQH\VDUHPHPEHUVRI0RUDQ $VVRFLDWHVDSULYDWHSXEOLFLQWHUHVWODZILUP1DERUV'HFOˆ  )XUWKHU ERWK ODZ\HUV DYHUUHG WKDW WKH ILUP DGMXVWHG UDWHV LQ WKH ODVW IHZ \HDUV WR EH LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV $WWRUQH\V¶ 2IILFH )HH 0DWUL[  0RUDQ 'HFO ˆ   1DERUV 'HFOˆˆ±7KDWFKDQJHZDVDUHIOHFWLRQRIUHFHQW'&&LUFXLWSUHFHGHQWDVZHOODVDQHIIRUW WR UHPDLQ FRPSHWLWLYH ZLWK SHHUV ZKR ZHUH FKDUJLQJ 86$2 Laffey 0DWUL[ UDWHV  0RUDQ 'HFOˆ 1DERUV'HFOˆˆ±6LQFHWKDWVKLIWWKHILUPKDV³EHHQSDLG>86$2@UDWHVE\FOLHQWV RQPDWWHUVFRQFHUQLQJHGXFDWLRQODZHPSOR\PHQWODZDQGODERUULJKWV´1DERUV'HFOˆ 0U 1DERUVDOVRVDLGWKDWEHFDXVHWKHYDVWPDMRULW\RIFDVHVWKHILUPUHFHLYHVDUHDSSRLQWHGWKURXJK WKH&RXQVHOIRU&KLOG$EXVHDQG1HJOHFW3DQHOWKHDWWRUQH\V³DUHEDUUHGE\WKH'&&RGHIURP DFFHSWLQJ SD\PHQW IURP WKH FOLHQW  $V D FRQVHTXHQFH >WKH\@ PXVW DFFHSW WKHVH FDVHV RQ D FRQWLQJHQF\EDVLVDQGFDQQRWFKDUJHWKHFOLHQWDQ\IHHV´Id. ˆ 0U1DERUVDVVHUWHGWKDW³WKH ILUP¶VELOOLQJSUDFWLFHVDUHVWUXFWXUHG´LQDZD\WRIXUWKHUWKHILUP¶VSULPDU\SXUSRVHRIDVVLVWLQJ LQGLJHQWFKLOGUHQZLWKGLVDELOLWLHVUDWKHUWKDQWRJHQHUDWH>D@SURILWId. ˆ+HDOVRDYHUUHGWKDW KH ³SHUIRUPHG DQ H[LW DXGLW WR UHPRYH GXSOLFLWRXV WLPH´ IURP WKH LQYRLFH id. ˆ  DQG ERWK DWWRUQH\VDVVHUWHGWKDWWKHUHPDLQLQJWLPHELOOHGLVUHDVRQDEOHEDVHGRQWKHUHOLHIVHFXUHGId.  0RUDQ'HFOˆ     WRFRPSHQVDWLRQEDVHGRQWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[3OV¶0HPDW'HIHQGDQWPDLQWDLQV

WKDWWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[GRHVQRWHVWDEOLVKWKH³SUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH´IRU,'($OLWLJDWLRQ

EHFDXVHWKHPDWUL[ZDVLQWHQGHGWRDSSO\WRFRPSOH[IHGHUDOOLWLJDWLRQZKLFKGHIHQGDQWLQVLVWV

GRHVQRWLQFOXGH,'($OLWLJDWLRQ'HI¶V2SSDW±,QVWHDGGHIHQGDQWSRVLWVWKDWSODLQWLIIV¶

DWWRUQH\VVKRXOGEHFRPSHQVDWHGDWVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHId. DW



  7KHLaffey 0DWUL[LV³DVFKHGXOHRIFKDUJHVEDVHGRQ\HDUVRIH[SHULHQFHGHYHORSHGLQ Laffey v. Northwest Airlines, Inc.)6XSS ''&  rev’d on other grounds )G '&&LU  cert. denied86   ´Covington)GDW 7ZRFRPSHWLQJYHUVLRQVRIWKHPDWUL[KDYHGHYHORSHGLQWKHSDVWWKLUW\\HDUV RQHGHYHORSHGE\ WKH8QLWHG6WDWHV$WWRUQH\¶V2IILFHIRUWKH'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELD ³86$2Laffey 0DWUL[´ ZKLFK DGMXVWVWKHRULJLQDOPDWUL[IRULQIODWLRQXVLQJWKH&RQVXPHU3ULFH,QGH[IRU$OO8UEDQ&RQVXPHUV DQGDVHFRQG³HQKDQFHG´IHHVFKHGXOHZKLFKDGMXVWVWKHPDWUL[UDWHVIRULQIODWLRQXVLQJWKH/HJDO 6HUYLFHV,QGH[ ³/6,Laffey 0DWUL[´ See Salazar ex rel. Salazar v. District of Columbia  )G '&&LU Eley v. District of Columbia )G ± '&&LU  7KH YHUVLRQ RI WKH 86$2 Laffey 0DWUL[ WKDW LV UHOHYDQW WR WKLV FDVH LV DYDLODEOH DW KWWSV ZZZMXVWLFHJRYXVDRGFILOH GRZQORDG ³86$2 Laffey 0DWUL[´  see ([  WR 3OV¶0HP>'NW@7KHDSSOLFDEOHUDWHXQGHUWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[IRU6WHYLH1DERUV ZKRDWWKHWLPHKDGEHHQLQSUDFWLFHEHWZHHQWZRDQGWKUHH\HDUVZDVSHUKRXUDQGWKH DSSOLFDEOHUDWHIRU&KDUOHV0RUDQZKRKDGEHHQLQSUDFWLFHIRURYHUWKLUW\RQH\HDUVZDV SHUKRXUSee 86$2Laffey 0DWUL[.   3ODLQWLIIV FRQWHQG WKDW GHIHQGDQW LV FROODWHUDOO\ HVWRSSHG IURP DUJXLQJ WKDW SODLQWLIIV¶ FRXQVHOVKRXOGRQO\UHFHLYHVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey0DWUL[3OV¶5HSO\DW±  7KH\PDLQWDLQWKDWWKLVLVVXHZDVDOUHDG\OLWLJDWHGLQDSUHYLRXVFDVHEHWZHHQWKHVDPHWZRSDUWLHV LQ WKLV &RXUW  See Merrick v. District of Columbia  ) 6XSS G   ''&   ³Merrick I´  see also 3OV¶ 5HSO\ DW ±   7KH GRFWULQH RI LVVXH SUHFOXVLRQ ³EDUV µVXFFHVVLYH OLWLJDWLRQRIDQLVVXHRIIDFWRUODZDFWXDOO\OLWLJDWHGDQGUHVROYHGLQDYDOLGFRXUWGHWHUPLQDWLRQ HVVHQWLDOWRWKHSULRUMXGJPHQW¶HYHQLIWKHLVVXHUHFXUVLQWKHFRQWH[WRIDGLIIHUHQWFODLP´Taylor v. Sturgell86   ,VVXHSUHFOXVLRQUHTXLUHVWKDW  WKHVDPHLVVXHEHLQJUDLVHG PXVWKDYHEHHQFRQWHVWHGE\WKHVDPHSDUWLHVRUSULYLHVDQGVXEPLWWHGWRMXGLFLDOGHWHUPLQDWLRQLQ D SULRU FDVH   WKH LVVXH PXVW KDYH EHHQ DFWXDOO\ DQG QHFHVVDULO\ GHWHUPLQHG E\ D FRXUW RI FRPSHWHQW MXULVGLFWLRQ LQ WKH SULRU FDVH DQG   WKH SUHFOXVLYH HIIHFW PXVW QRW ZRUN D EDVLF XQIDLUQHVVWRWKHSDUW\ERXQGE\WKHILUVWGHWHUPLQDWLRQYamaha Corp. of Am. v. United States  )G   '& &LU     ³7KH YHU\ KHDUW RI WKH FROODWHUDOHVWRSSHO GRFWULQH LV WKH UHTXLUHPHQWWKDWWKHLVVXHWREHSUHFOXGHGPXVWEHVXEVWDQWLDOO\WKHVDPHDVWKHLVVXHSUHYLRXVO\ OLWLJDWHG´Schneider v. Lockheed Aircraft Corp)G '&&LU  abrogated on other grounds by Williams Enters., Inc. v. Sherman R. Smoot Co.  )G  '& &LU   FLWLQJMontana v. United States86   >&RQWLQXHGRQQH[WSDJH@   ,Q VXSSRUW RI WKHLU SRVLWLRQ WKDW WKH 86$2 Laffey 0DWUL[ SURYLGHV WKH SURSHU UDWHV

SODLQWLIIVKDYHVXEPLWWHGDYDULHW\RIHYLGHQFHLQFOXGLQJWKHIHHPDWUL[LWVHOI$VWKH&RXUWRI

$SSHDOVKDVVDLGIHHPDWULFHVDUHDJRRGSODFHWRVWDUWLQGHWHUPLQLQJWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH

Eley )GDW

7KH '& &LUFXLW KDV GHFOLQHG WR ZHLJK LQ RQ WKH TXHVWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU ,'($ OLWLJDWLRQ

TXDOLILHVDV³FRPSOH[IHGHUDOOLWLJDWLRQ´WRZDUUDQWWKHSUHVXPSWLYHDSSOLFDWLRQRIDQ\YHUVLRQRI

WKHLaffey 0DWUL[See Reed)GDW FRQFOXGLQJWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWDEXVHLWV

GLVFUHWLRQLQGHFLGLQJQRWWRDZDUGWKHKLJKHU/6,Laffey UDWHVWRDWWRUQH\VIRUWKHLUZRUNLQ,'($

FDVHV EXW H[SUHVVO\ QRWLQJ WKDW LW GRHV ³QRW PHDQ WR UXOH RXW WKH SRVVLELOLW\ WKDW IXWXUH IHH

DSSOLFDQWVPD\EHDEOHWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKDW,'($FDVHVDUHµFRPSOH[IHGHUDOOLWLJDWLRQ¶WRZKLFK

WKH Laffey 0DWUL[ SUHVXPSWLYHO\ DSSOLHV´ Eley   )G DW  KROGLQJ WKDW WKH ORZHUFRXUW

DEXVHGLWVGLVFUHWLRQLQDZDUGLQJIHHVDWWKHKLJKHU/6,Laffey UDWHZLWKRXWUHTXLULQJWKHSODLQWLII

WRGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWWKRVHUDWHVZHUHLQOLQHZLWKWKHSUHYDLOLQJUDWH -XGJH.DYDQDJKGLGVWDWHLQ

KLV FRQFXUUHQFH LQ Eley WKDW WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV¶ $WWRUQH\¶V 2IILFH Laffey 0DWUL[ WKDW SODLQWLIIV

  >&RQWLQXHGIURPSUHYLRXVSDJH@,QMerrick IWKHSDUWLHVOLWLJDWHGIRXUVSHFLILFFODLPV EHIRUHD+HDULQJ2IILFHUUHODWLQJWRSODFLQJ0U:DVKLQJWRQLQDUHVLGHQWLDOIDFLOLW\ZKLFKWKHQ JDYHULVHWRWKHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVOLWLJDWLRQLQWKLV&RXUW)6XSSGDW±7KH&RXUW UHIXVHG WR UHGXFH WKH 86$2 Laffey UDWH E\ WZHQW\ILYH SHUFHQW DQG LQVWHDG LW DZDUGHG WKH DWWRUQH\VWKHIXOOUDWHVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLQGH[Id.DW ±+HUHWKHGHIHQVHLVDVNLQJWKH&RXUW WRDZDUGWKHDWWRUQH\VVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[ UDWHZKLFKLVWKHVDPHDV DUHTXHVWWRUHGXFHWKHUDWHE\WZHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWSee 'HI¶V2SSDW7KXVRQLWVIDFHLW DSSHDUVWKDWGHIHQGDQWLVOLWLJDWLQJWKHVDPHLVVXH  7KH&RXUWRI$SSHDOVKDVQRWH[SUHVVO\KHOGWKDW,'($OLWLJDWLRQLVFRPSOH[HQRXJKWR ZDUUDQWWKHXVHRIDVSHFLILFPDWUL[SeeReed)GDW Eley )GDW5DWKHUWKH GHWHUPLQDWLRQGHSHQGVRQWKHVSHFLILFIDFWVRIWKHFDVHA.S.)6XSSGDW ³7KLVFRXUW ILQGVWKDWWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQ>RIZKHWKHUWRUHGXFHWKHLaffeyUDWH@PXVWEHPDGHLQDFDVHE\FDVH DQDO\VLV´  see also Hensley  86 DW   ³7KH DPRXQW RI WKH IHH RI FRXUVH PXVW EH GHWHUPLQHG RQ WKH IDFWV RI HDFK FDVH´   6LQFH WKH WZR Merrick FDVHV DULVH RXW RI VHSDUDWH FRQWURYHUVLHVUHODWLQJWR0U:DVKLQJWRQ¶V,(3WKDWWRRNSODFHDWWZRGLVWLQFWWLPHVWKHLVVXHRI UHGXFLQJWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHLVFRQWLQJHQWXSRQDQHZVHWRIRSHUDWLYHIDFWVWKDWZHUH QRWSUHVHQWLQWKHILUVWFDVH:KHWKHUDSDUWLFXODUUDWHLVDSSURSULDWHGHSHQGVRQWKHIDFWVRIHDFK FDVHVRWKHUHLVQRSUHFOXVLYHHIIHFWRQWKLVFDVHIURPWKHGHFLVLRQE\WKLV&RXUWLQMerrick I   LQYRNH LQ WKLV FDVH ³LV DSSURSULDWH IRU ,'($ FDVHV´  Eley   )G DW  .DYDQDXJK -

FRQFXUULQJ 

6RPHFRXUWVKDYHDGRSWHGWKHDSSURDFKRIGLVFRXQWLQJHYHQWKHORZHU86$2LaffeyUDWHV

WRDFFRXQWIRUDODFNRIFRPSOH[LW\LQWKHXQGHUO\LQJSURFHHGLQJVseeMcAllister v. District of

Columbia)6XSSG ± ''& EXWPDQ\FRXUWVLQFOXGLQJWKLVRQHKDYH

UHMHFWHG WKH QRWLRQ WKDW ,'($ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHHGLQJV DUH ³FDWHJRULFDOO\ OHVV FRPSOH[ WKDQ

RWKHUIRUPVRIOLWLJDWLRQ´See, e.g.Bucher v. District of Columbia)6XSSG  ''&

 Jackson v. District of Columbia )6XSSG  ''& 7KRVHFRXUWV

UHFRJQL]HWKDW,'($FDVHV³WDNHDYDULHW\RIGLIIHUHQWOLWLJDWLRQSDWKV´DQG³FDQQRWEHGLVPLVVHG

DVFDWHJRULFDOO\URXWLQHRUVLPSOH´Thomas v. District of Columbia )6XSSG

''&   ,'($ FDVHV ³UHTXLUH WHVWLPRQ\ IURP HGXFDWLRQ H[SHUWV UHJDUGLQJ ZKHWKHU D

VWXGHQW KDV EHHQ GHQLHG D IUHH DQG SXEOLF HGXFDWLRQ´ Jackson   ) 6XSS G DW  DQG

SODLQWLII¶V FRXQVHO PXVW ³XQGHUVWDQG WKH EXUHDXFUDWLF ZRUNLQJV RI >'&36@ Cox v. District of

Columbia)6XSSG ''& DQG³PXVWEHFRPHFRQYHUVDQWZLWKDZLGHUDQJH

RIGLVDEOLQJFRJQLWLYHHPRWLRQDODQGODQJXDJHEDVHGGLVRUGHUVDQGWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJWKHUDSHXWLF

DQGHGXFDWLRQDODSSURDFKHV´Sweatt v. District of Columbia)6XSSG ''&

 

3ODLQWLIIVKDYHSURIIHUHGDIILGDYLWVIURPDWWRUQH\VZKRDUHIDPLOLDUZLWKDQGZKR KDYH

OLWLJDWHG,'($FDVHVDQGWKH\VSHDNWRWKHFRPSOH[LW\RIWKRVHW\SHVRIFDVHV³0HUHFRQFOXVRU\

VWDWHPHQWVWKDW,'($OLWLJDWLRQLVµDVFRPSOH[¶DVRWKHUW\SHVRIFDVHVGHHPHGE\WKLVFRXUWWREH

µFRPSOH[ IHGHUDO OLWLJDWLRQ¶ DEVHQW DQ H[SODQDWLRQ RI why WKLV LV VR FDQQRW VXIILFH WR PHHW

>SODLQWLIIV¶@EXUGHQ´Reed)GDW%XWWKHGHFODUDWLRQVVXSSOLHGE\SODLQWLIIVKHUHDUH

VXIILFLHQWO\GHWDLOHGWRVXSSRUWSODLQWLIIV¶SRVLWLRQWKDW,'($FDVHVTXDOLI\DV³FRPSOH[IHGHUDO

OLWLJDWLRQ´VRDVWRZDUUDQWWKHSUHVXPSWLYHDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKH86$2Laffey UDWHVSee 'HFORI   (OL]DEHWK-HVWHU(VT([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³-HVWHU'HFO´ ˆ H[SODLQLQJWKDWD

ODFN RI GLVFRYHU\ PDNHV ,'($ OLWLJDWLRQYHU\FRPSOH[EHFDXVHDWWRUQH\V RQO\KDYH D ILYHGD\

GLVFORVXUH SHULRG LQ ZKLFK WR SURGXFH DQG UHFHLYH DOO GRFXPHQWV WKDW FRXOG EH XWLOL]HG DW WKH

KHDULQJ DQG WR SUHSDUH WR H[DPLQH YDULRXV ZLWQHVVHV  id. ˆ  GLVFXVVLQJ WKH FRPSOH[LW\ RI

OHDUQLQJDQGXQGHUVWDQGLQJ³HYHU\GLVFLSOLQHWKDWWRXFKHVWKHGLVDELOLWLHVSUHVHQWHGE\WKHFKLOGDW

LVVXH´VRDVWRIRUH[DPSOHFURVVH[DPLQHWKH'&36³SV\FKRORJLVWRQWKHQXDQFHVRIFRJQLWLYH

DFDGHPLFEHKDYLRUDODQGHPRWLRQDOWHVWLQJ´ 9HULILHG6WDWHPHQWRI$ODQD+HFKW(VT([WR

3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³+HFKW'HFO´ ˆˆ± GLVFXVVLQJKRZ³,'($OLWLJDWLRQLQYROYHVWKH

SUHVHQWDWLRQ RI >DQ@ HQWLUH EHQFK WULDO LQFOXGLQJ WKH DGPLVVLRQ RI H[KLELWV GLUHFW DQG FURVV

H[DPLQDWLRQ RI ZLWQHVVHV RSHQLQJ DQG FORVLQJ VWDWHPHQWVDUJXPHQWV DQG D UREXVW PRWLRQV

SUDFWLFH´DVZHOODVWKHSDUWLFXODUFRPSOH[LW\EHKLQG³SXWWLQJRQDIXOOWULDOZLWKZLWQHVVHVWKDW

DUHLQWKHWRWDOFRQWURODQGHPSOR\RIWKH>U@HVSRQGHQW´ see also 9HULILHG6WDWHPHQWRI1LFKRODV

2VWUHP([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³2VWUHP'HFO´ ˆ  GHVFULELQJWLPHFRQVXPLQJIHH

OLWLJDWLRQLQ,'($FDVHV 

7KHUHIRUHWKH&RXUWFRQFOXGHVWKDWLWLVQRWDSSURSULDWHWRUHIOH[LYHO\UHGXFHWKH86$2

Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHVE\WZHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWWRDFFRXQWIRUDODFNRIFRPSOH[LW\LQWKHXQGHUO\LQJ

DGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJV)XUWKHUPRUHEHFDXVHDQDWWRUQH\¶VWRWDOIHHDZDUGLVGHWHUPLQHGE\

PXOWLSO\LQJWKHQXPEHURIKRXUVH[SHQGHGE\WKHKRXUO\UDWHUHGXFLQJWKH86$2Laffey UDWHVWR

UHIOHFWWKHEUHYLW\RIWKHFDVHLPSURSHUO\DFFRXQWVIRUWKHOHQJWKRIWKHSURFHHGLQJVWZLFHSee

Eley )6XSSGDW ³>7@KHFRPSOH[LW\RIWKHFDVHLVDFFRXQWHGIRUE\WKHQXPEHURI

KRXUVH[SHQGHGDQGVKRXOGQRWEHDFFRXQWHGIRUE\DEOXQWUHGXFWLRQRIUDWHVEHIRUHDSSO\LQJWKH

UDWHVWRWKHQXPEHURIKRXUVH[SHQGHG´ vacated and remanded on other grounds )G  

see also Flood v. District of Columbia)6XSSG  ''&  REVHUYLQJWKDW

³DQ DXWRPDWLF UHGXFWLRQ LQ WKH SODLQWLII¶V UHTXHVWHG UHLPEXUVHPHQW UDWH EDVHG RQO\ RQ WKH   VLPSOLFLW\ RI DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHHGLQJ UXQV FRXQWHU WR WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW¶V YLHZ WKDW WKH

UHODWLYHFRPSOH[LW\RIDPDWWHULVJHQHUDOO\SUHVXPHGWREHUHIOHFWHGIXOO\LQWKHQXPEHURIKRXUV

ELOOHG´ DQG WKDW ³UHGXFWLRQ RI WKH SODLQWLII¶V UHLPEXUVHPHQW UDWH LQ WKLV PDQQHU ULVNV GRXEOH

FRXQWLQJWKHUHODWLYHVLPSOLFLW\RIWKHXQGHUO\LQJSURFHHGLQJV´ accord Sweatt)6XSSGDW



0RUHRYHUSODLQWLIIVKDYHSURYLGHGWKH&RXUWZLWKDGGLWLRQDOHYLGHQFHWRFDUU\WKHLUEXUGHQ

RIHVWDEOLVKLQJWKDWWKHLUUHTXHVWHGUDWHVUHIOHFWWKH³UDWHVSUHYDLOLQJLQWKHFRPPXQLW\LQZKLFK

WKH DFWLRQ RU SURFHHGLQJ DURVH IRU WKH NLQG DQG TXDOLW\ RI VHUYLFHV IXUQLVKHG´ 

86&† L  &  HYHQ WKRXJK DGGLWLRQDO SURRI RI WKH SUHYDLOLQJ PDUNHW UDWH LV QRW

QHFHVVDULO\UHTXLUHGDIWHUDSODLQWLIIKDVVKRZQWKDWWKH,'($FDVHZDVFRPSOH[See Reed

)GDW H[SODLQLQJWKDWIHHDSSOLFDQWVLQ,'($FDVHVUHO\³RQWZRVHSDUDWHEXWLQWHU

UHODWHG DSSURDFKHV WR SURYLGLQJ HYLGHQFH RI SUHYDLOLQJ PDUNHW UDWH´    ³DWWHPSWLQJ WR

GHPRQVWUDWH WKDW ,'($ FDVHV IDOO ZLWKLQ WKH ERXQGV´ RI FRPSOH[ IHGHUDO OLWLJDWLRQ DQG  

³SURYLGLQJHYLGHQFHRIWKHIHHVFKDUJHGDQGUHFHLYHGE\,'($OLWLJDWRUV´ see also James v.

District of Columbia  ) 6XSS G   ''&   ³>7@KH &LUFXLW¶V PRUH UHFHQW

GHFLVLRQLQReed PDNHVFOHDUWKDWDSODLQWLIIPXVWRIIHUSURRIRIWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHWKDWLV

LQGHSHQGHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[DEVHQWDVKRZLQJRIFRPSOH[LW\´ Flood)6XSS

GDW FRQILUPLQJWKDWIHHDSSOLFDQWV³PD\PHHWWKHLUEXUGHQXSRQHLWKHURIWZRVKRZLQJV ´

³WKDW ,'($ SURFHHGLQJV TXDOLI\ DV µFRPSOH[ IHGHUDO OLWLJDWLRQ¶ WR ZKLFK Laffey UDWHV

SUHVXPSWLYHO\DSSO\´RU³WKDWUDWHVFXVWRPDULO\FKDUJHGE\,'($SUDFWLWLRQHUVLQWKH'LVWULFWDUH

FRPSDUDEOHWRWKRVHSURYLGHGXQGHUWKH>86$2@Laffey 0DWUL[´ 

%HVLGHV SRLQWLQJ WR WKH IHH PDWUL[ LWVHOI D SODLQWLII PD\ PHHW KHU EXUGHQ E\ SURGXFLQJ

HYLGHQFH³WKDWWKHUHTXHVWHGUDWHVDUHLQOLQHZLWKWKRVHSUHYDLOLQJLQWKHFRPPXQLW\IRUVLPLODU

VHUYLFHVE\ODZ\HUVRIUHDVRQDEO\FRPSDUDEOHVNLOOH[SHULHQFHDQGUHSXWDWLRQ´Eley )GDW     7KH HYLGHQFH UHOHYDQW WR WKLV LQTXLU\ LQFOXGHV ³DIILGDYLWV UHFLWLQJ WKH SUHFLVH IHHV WKDW

DWWRUQH\VZLWKVLPLODUTXDOLILFDWLRQVKDYHUHFHLYHGIURPIHHSD\LQJFOLHQWVLQFRPSDUDEOHFDVHV´

³HYLGHQFHRIUHFHQWIHHVDZDUGHGE\WKHFRXUWVRUWKURXJKVHWWOHPHQWWRDWWRUQH\VZLWKFRPSDUDEOH

TXDOLILFDWLRQVKDQGOLQJVLPLODUFDVHV´DQGPDUNHWVXUYH\VXSGDWLQJWKHIHHPDWULFHVId. DW

+HUH SODLQWLIIV KDYH VXEPLWWHG ILYH GHFODUDWLRQV IURP ,'($ SUDFWLWLRQHUV LQ WKLV

MXULVGLFWLRQ WKDW VXSSRUW D ILQGLQJ WKDW IXOO 86$2 Laffey UDWHV DUH WKH SUHYDLOLQJ UDWHV LQ WKH

FRPPXQLW\IRU,'($OLWLJDWLRQSee'HFORI&DURO\Q+RXFN(VT([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW

@ ³+RXFN'HFO´ ˆˆ± GHVFULELQJKRZVKHKDVSUDFWLFHGLQWKHILHOGRIVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQ

ODZ VLQFH   DQG KDV OLWLJDWHG PRUH WKDQ  FDVHV OHDGLQJ WR GXH SURFHVV KHDULQJV RU

VHWWOHPHQWDJUHHPHQWVXQGHUWKH,'($DQGFKDUJHVFOLHQWV³DWRUQHDUWKHFXUUHQWDWWRUQH\¶VIHHV

PDWUL[ UDWHV SXEOLVKHG E\ WKH 86$2´  -HVWHU 'HFO ˆˆ  ±   VWDWLQJ WKDW KHU SULPDU\

SUDFWLFHDUHDVLQFH KDVEHHQFKLOGUHQ¶VULJKWVWKDWLWLVKHU³QRUPDOSUDFWLFHWRELOOFOLHQWV

ZKRDUHQRWLQGLJHQWDWUDWHVHTXLYDOHQWWRWKHUDWHVVHWIRUWKLQWKH86$2$WWRUQH\¶V)HHV0DWUL[´

DQGGHWDLOLQJWKHQXPHURXVWLPHVVKHKDVEHHQDZDUGHGIXOO86$2Laffey UDWHVE\MXGJHVLQWKLV

GLVWULFW +HFKW'HFOˆˆ DYHUULQJWKDWKHUODZILUPVROHO\SUDFWLFHVVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQODZ

WKDWLW³FXUUHQWO\PDWFKHVLWVKRXUO\UDWHVWRWKRVHLQZKDWLVNQRZQDVWKH86$2DGMXVWHGLaffey

PDWUL[´DQGWKDWLW³KDVKDGVHYHUDOSD\LQJFOLHQWVWKDWKDYHSDLGWKHVHUDWHV´ 2VWUHP'HFOˆ

VWDWLQJWKDWKLVODZILUPZKLFKVSHFLDOL]HVLQ,'($OLWLJDWLRQ³KDVDOZD\VPDWFKHGLWVKRXUO\

UDWHVWRWKRVHLQZKDWLVFRPPRQO\NQRZQDVWKHµLaffey 0DWUL[¶´ id. ˆˆ  GHVFULELQJKRZKH

IRXQGLW³LPSRVVLEOHWRVXVWDLQ´DSUDFWLFH³IRULQGLJHQWSDUHQWVDQGVWXGHQWVE\UHO\LQJRQWKHµIHH

VKLIWLQJ¶ SURYLVLRQ RI WKH ,'($´ IRU PDQ\ UHDVRQV LQFOXGLQJ EXW QRW OLPLWHG WR ³VRPH MXGJHV

UHJXODUO\DZDUGLQJKRXUO\UDWHVDWRIWKHUDWHVLQWKH86$2IHHPDWUL[´ 9HULILHG6WDWHPHQW

RI'RXJODV7\UND([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ ³7\UND'HFO´ ˆˆ± GHFODULQJWKDWKH

KDVDOPRVWH[FOXVLYHO\SUDFWLFHGODZLQWKHILHOGRIVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQVLQFHWKDWWKHODZILUP   ³KDVDOZD\VFKDUJHGDWKRXUO\UDWHVPDWFKLQJWKRVHLQZKDWLVFRPPRQO\NQRZQDVµWKH/6,

Laffey 0DWUL[¶´WKDW³WKHILUPKDVKDGVHYHUDOFOLHQWVSD\WKHILUPDWWKH/6,Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHV

GLUHFWO\´DQGWKDW³>W@KHILUPLVFXUUHQWO\UHWDLQHGE\FOLHQWVDWWKH/6,Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHV´ 

'HIHQGDQWWDNHVLVVXHZLWKWKHVHGHFODUDWLRQVDUJXLQJWKDWWKH\PHUHO\VKRZZKDWVRPH

DWWRUQH\VFKDUJHFOLHQWVUDWKHUWKDQZKDWWKH\DFWXDOO\UHFHLYHIURPWKHP'HI¶V2SSDW± 

7KH\PDLQWDLQWKDWVXFKVWDWHPHQWVGRQRWSURYLGHFRQYLQFLQJHYLGHQFHRIWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHW

UDWHId. ,QVXSSRUWRIWKLVSRVLWLRQWKH\SRLQWWRRWKHUFRXUWVLQWKLVGLVWULFWWKDWKDYHIRXQGWKDW

GHFODUDWLRQVVLPLODUWRWKHRQHVVXEPLWWHGLQWKLVFDVHIDOOVKRUWRIZKDWLVQHFHVVDU\WRGHPRQVWUDWH

WKH IHHV WKDW DWWRUQH\V KDYH UHFHLYHG IURP IHHSD\LQJ FOLHQWV LQ FRPSDUDEOH FDVHV Id. DW ±

FLWLQJFDVHV 

,WLVWUXHWKDWWKHGHFODUDWLRQVRIIHUHGE\SODLQWLIIVLQWKLVFDVHGRQRWHVWDEOLVKWKDW,'($

DWWRUQH\VXQLIRUPO\FROOHFWIHHVFRPSDUDEOHWRWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[:KLOHWKHGHFODUDQWV

DYHUWKDWWKH\FKDUJHWKRVHUDWHVRQO\DIHZRIWKHPVWDWHWKDWFOLHQWVKDYHSDLGWKHPSee +HFKW

'HFOˆ DYHUULQJWKDWKHUODZILUP³KDVKDGVHYHUDOSD\LQJFOLHQWVWKDWKDYHSDLGWKHVHUDWHV´ 

7\UND'HFOˆˆ± GHFODULQJWKDW³WKHILUPKDVKDGVHYHUDOFOLHQWVSD\WKHILUPDWWKH/6,Laffey

0DWUL[UDWHVGLUHFWO\´DQGWKDW³>W@KHILUPLVFXUUHQWO\UHWDLQHGE\FOLHQWVDWWKH/6,Laffey 0DWUL[

UDWHV´ $QGWKRVHGHFODUDQWVGRQRWVSHFLI\ZKDWSURSRUWLRQRIWKHLUFOLHQWVDFWXDOO\SD\WKHVH

UDWHV

%XW WKH GHFODUDQWV DOVR HPSKDVL]H WKDW IHZ LI DQ\ ,'($ FODLPDQWV DUH DEOH WR DIIRUG

UHSUHVHQWDWLRQLQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKHLUDGPLQLVWUDWLYHFODLPVSee -HVWHU'HFOˆ  H[SODLQLQJ

WKDWWKHPDMRULW\RIKHUFOLHQWVDUHLQGLJHQWDQGFDQQRWDIIRUGWRSD\DWWRUQH\V¶IHHVRUFRVWVDWDQ\

OHYHO +RXFN'HFOˆ ³:KHQUHSUHVHQWLQJVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQFOLHQWVRQDFRQWLQJHQF\EDVLV

DWWRUQH\VLQWKH'LVWULFWRI&ROXPELDDFFHSWWKDWUHSUHVHQWDWLRQIRUWKHSURVSHFWRIUHFRYHULQJIHHV

EDVHG RQ WKH UHDVRQDEOH IHHVKLIWLQJ JXLGHOLQHV IRXQG LQ WKH 86$2¶V DWWRUQH\V IHHV PDWUL[´    +HFKW'HFOˆ DYHUULQJWKDWPRVWRIWKHILUP¶VFOLHQWVDUHLQGLJHQWDQGWKDWWKRVH³FOLHQWVVLJQ

UHWDLQHUDJUHHPHQWVWKDWGRQRWUHTXLUHWKHPWRSD\IHHVXSIURQWEXWGRDGYLVHWKHPWKDWWKHILUP

ZLOOEHVHHNLQJIXOOLaffey 0DWUL[UDWHVRQWKHFOLHQW¶VEHKDOI´ 

:KLOH VRPH FRXUWV LQ WKLV GLVWULFW KDYH IRXQG WKDW VWDWHPHQWV OLNH WKH RQHV PDGH LQ WKH

GHFODUDWLRQVLQWKLVFDVHDUHXQFRQYLQFLQJsee Cox v. District of Columbia)6XSSG

 ''& DWOHDVWRQHFRXUWKDVEHHQ³RIWKHYLHZ´WKDWVXFKVWDWHPHQWVUHIOHFW³µSUHFLVH

IHHV¶ WKDW DQ DWWRUQH\ KDV µUHFHLYHG IURP IHHSD\LQJ FOLHQWV¶ IRU ,'($ OLWLJDWLRQ´  Wimbish v.

District of Columbia)6XSSG  ''& TXRWLQJEley )GDW

$QGDVDQRWKHUFRXUWKDVREVHUYHG³>D@WWKHHQGRIWKHGD\WKH&RXUWLVOHIWZLWKFDVHVRQERWK

VLGHVRIWKHLaffey GLYLGH´ZKHQLWFRPHVWRGHWHUPLQLQJWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHCopeland v.

District of Columbia)6XSSG ''&  DZDUGLQJDWWRUQH\VDWIXOO86$2

Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHV 

*LYHQ WKH H[LVWHQFH RI WKH IHHVKLIWLQJ VWDWXWH LQ ,'($ FDVHV DQG WKH UHODWLYH UDULW\ RI

SD\LQJVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQFOLHQWVWKH&RXUWILQGVWKDWLWZRXOGEHXQUHDOLVWLFWRH[SHFWDJUHDWHU

  OHYHORIVSHFLILFLW\WKDQZKDWZDVVXEPLWWHGLQWKLVFDVH:KLOHWKHDIILGDYLWVPD\QRWVXSSO\

FRQFOXVLYHHYLGHQFHRIWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHVLQWKHUHOHYDQWFRPPXQLW\WKH&RXUWILQGVWKDW

WKH VWDWHPHQWV SURYLGHG E\ WKH ,'($ DWWRUQH\V LQ WKHLU GHFODUDWLRQV VXIILFLHQWO\ ³UHFLW>H@ WKH

SUHFLVH IHHV WKDW DWWRUQH\V ZLWK VLPLODU TXDOLILFDWLRQV KDYH UHFHLYHG IURP IHHSD\LQJ FOLHQWV LQ

FRPSDUDEOHFDVHV´Eley )GDW see also Flood)6XSSGDW FRQFOXGLQJ

WKDWWKHGHFODUDWLRQVGLG³QRWGHPRQVWUDWHFRQFOXVLYHO\WKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHV´EXWXOWLPDWHO\

KROGLQJWKDWWKHSODLQWLIIPHWKHUEXUGHQE\SURYLGLQJWKHGHFODUDWLRQVLQDGGLWLRQWRHYLGHQFHRI

UHFHQWIHHVDZDUGHGE\RWKHUFRXUWVLQWKHVDPHMXULVGLFWLRQ 

)XUWKHUSODLQWLIIVVXSSOHPHQWWKLVHYLGHQFHE\SRLQWLQJWRUHFHQWIHHDZDUGVLQWKLVGLVWULFW

LQZKLFKSUHYDLOLQJ,'($FODLPDQWVZHUHUHLPEXUVHGDWIXOO86$2Laffey UDWHVSee 3OV¶0HP

DW±  FLWLQJFDVHV see e.g.Wimbish)6XSSGDW ±  FRQFOXGLQJWKDWWKHSODLQWLII

KDGPHWKHUEXUGHQWRVKRZWKDWWKH86$2Laffey UDWHVZHUHWKHSUHYDLOLQJUDWHVLQWKHFRPPXQLW\

E\SURYLGLQJDIILGDYLWVIURPRWKHUDWWRUQH\VDVZHOODVSRLQWLQJWRUHFHQWFDVHVWKDWKDGDZDUGHG

IXOOUDWHV Flood)6XSSGDW ³>$@UHYLHZRIUHFHQW,'($IHHDZDUGVLQGLFDWHVIDLUO\

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ee Merrick I  ) 6XSS G DW  Q ³7KH &RXUW QRWHV WKDW LQ Eley WKH &RXUW RI $SSHDOV VWDWHG WKDW µHYLGHQFHRIWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHFDQWDNHPDQ\IRUPV¶DQGVXJJHVWHGWKDWDPDUNHWVXUYH\ PLJKWDOVREHDSHUVXDVLYHIRUPRIHYLGHQFH%XWJLYHQWKHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHIHHVKLIWLQJVWDWXWHLQ FDVHVOLNHWKLVRQHDQGWKHUHODWLYHUDULW\RISD\LQJVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQFOLHQWVRQHFDQKDUGO\VD\ WKDW D µPDUNHW¶ H[LVWV IRU VHUYLFHV VLPLODU WR WKH VHUYLFHV RIIHUHG LQ WKLV FDVH  6R WKH H[HUFLVH FRQWHPSODWHGE\EleyZLOORIWHQSURGXFHDZNZDUGDQGOHVVWKDQLGHDOUHVXOWV7KHUHDUHJRLQJWR FRQWLQXHWREHFRXQWOHVVKRXUVZDVWHGE\SULYDWHFRXQVHO'&36DQGWKHEHQFKOLWLJDWLQJQRWRQO\ IHH SHWLWLRQV EXW DOVR IHHVRQIHHV SHWLWLRQV XQWLO WKH 'LVWULFW DQG WKH VSHFLDO HGXFDWLRQ EDU VLW GRZQLQJRRGIDLWK±ZLWKRUZLWKRXWWKHDVVLVWDQFHRIDQHXWUDOPHGLDWRU±DQGWU\WRKDPPHURXW DPXWXDOO\DFFHSWDEOHSUHVXPSWLYHIHHVFKHGXOHWKDWLVQRWDVSDUVLPRQLRXVDQGXQUHDOLVWLFDVWKH ODVWRQH´  LQWHUQDOFLWDWLRQRPLWWHG    EURDG VXSSRUW DPRQJ -XGJHV RQ WKLV &RXUW IRU UHLPEXUVHPHQW DW RU DERYH IXOO 86$2 Laffey

UDWHV´ Copeland)6XSSGDW 7KHDIILGDYLWVDQGFDVHVWDNHQWRJHWKHUVXIILFLHQWO\

GHPRQVWUDWHWKDWSODLQWLIIVKDYHPHWWKHLUEXUGHQWRSURYHWKDWIXOO86$2Laffey UDWHVFRQVWLWXWH

WKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHVIRU,'($OLWLJDWLRQSUDFWLFHLQWKLVMXULVGLFWLRQ

%HFDXVHSODLQWLIIVKDYHPHWWKHLUEXUGHQWKH&RXUWPXVWSUHVXPHWKDWWKHKRXUO\UDWHVDUH

UHDVRQDEOHDQGWKHEXUGHQVKLIWVWRWKHGHIHQVHWRSURYLGH³VSHFLILFFRQWUDU\HYLGHQFHWHQGLQJWR

VKRZWKDWDORZHUUDWHZRXOGEHDSSURSULDWH´Covington)GDW ±FLWLQJNat’l Ass’n

of Concerned Veterans)GDW

'HIHQGDQW RIIHUV WKH GHFODUDWLRQ RI )OR\G +D\HV ZKR VHUYHV DV WKH )LQDQFLDO 3URJUDP

$QDO\VWLQWKH'&362IILFHRI*HQHUDO&RXQVHOWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH

86$2Laffey KRXUO\UDWHLVWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHIRUDWWRUQH\VSUDFWLFLQJ,'($OLWLJDWLRQDQG

WKDW WKH UDWH LV VXIILFLHQW WR DWWUDFW FRPSHWHQW FRXQVHO See 'HFO RI )OR\G +D\HV >'NW  @

  (YHQ UHFHQW IHH DZDUGV LQ WKH GLVWULFW PD\ XQGHUHVWLPDWH WKH SUHYDLOLQJ PDUNHW UDWH IRU ,'($ OLWLJDWLRQ  $V DQRWKHU FRXUW KDV SRLQWHG RXW PDQ\ ,'($ DWWRUQH\V PD\ UHTXHVW UHLPEXUVHPHQW EHORZ IXOO 86$2 Laffey UDWHV WR DYRLG SURORQJHG OLWLJDWLRQ DQG VHFXUH WLPHO\ UHLPEXUVHPHQWFlood)6XSSGDW   ,Q DGGLWLRQ SODLQWLIIV VXEPLWWHG D 'HSDUWPHQW RI -XVWLFH PDUNHW VXUYH\ FRQGXFWHG E\ HFRQRPLVW'U/DXUD$0DORZDQHDVZHOODVWKH1DWLRQDO/DZ-RXUQDOPDUNHWVXUYH\WR VXSSRUWWKHLUSRVLWLRQWKDWWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[LVWKHDSSURSULDWHLQGH[WRGHWHUPLQHDWWRUQH\V¶ IHHVSee 'HFORI'U/DXUD$0DORZDQH([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@ˆ ³,QP\RSLQLRQ WKHDWWRUQH\IHHPDWUL[LVVXHGDQGXSGDWHGE\WKH8QLWHG6WDWHV$WWRUQH\V¶2IILFHIRUWKH'LVWULFW RI&ROXPELDLVWKHDSSURSULDWHPDWUL[WRXVHIRUSXUSRVHVRIGHWHUPLQLQJSODLQWLII¶VDWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV´ ([WR3OV¶0HP>'NW@'HIHQGDQWLQVLVWVWKDWWKH&RXUWVKRXOGGLVUHJDUG/DXUD 0DORZDQH¶VGHFODUDWLRQEHFDXVHLWZDVSUHSDUHGIRUDQRWKHUFDVH'HI¶V2SSDW,WDOVRDUJXHV WKDWWKH1DWLRQDO/DZ-RXUQDOPDUNHWVXUYH\³SURYLGHVQRHYLGHQFHRIWKHUHDVRQDEOHPDUNHWUDWH´ EHFDXVHLWGRHVQRWLGHQWLI\DWWRUQH\\HDUVRIH[SHULHQFHLWLQFOXGHVDQXPEHURISUDFWLFHDUHDV VXFKDVZKLWHFROODUFULPHDQGWUDQVDFWLRQDODWWRUQH\VDQGLWGRHVQRWVSHFLI\LIWKHUDWHVDUHPHUHO\ FKDUJHGE\SUDFWLWLRQHUVRUDFWXDOO\UHFHLYHGIURPFOLHQWVId. DW%HFDXVHWKHRWKHUHYLGHQFH SODLQWLIIV SURYLGHG LV VXIILFLHQW IRU WKHP WR PHHW WKHLU EXUGHQ WKH &RXUW QHHG QRW HYDOXDWH WKH ZHLJKW RI WKLV DGGLWLRQDO HYLGHQFH  7KH &RXUW QRWHV KRZHYHU WKDW PDUNHW VXUYH\V KDYH EHHQ HQGRUVHGE\WKH&RXUWRI$SSHDOVDVDQRWKHUIRUPRIHYLGHQFHDSODLQWLIIPD\SURYLGHWRSURYHWKH SUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWHSee Eley )GDW     ³+D\HV'HFO´ 'HI¶V2SSDW±7KHGHFODUDWLRQLQFOXGHVVWDWLVWLFVUHJDUGLQJWKHQXPEHU

RILQYRLFHVVXEPLWWHGWKHQXPEHURILQYRLFHVWKDWZHUHVHWWOHGDQGWKHDPRXQWRIDWWRUQH\V¶IHHV

WKDWZHUHUHTXHVWHGDQGSDLGIRUILVFDO\HDUVDQGSee +D\HV'HFOˆˆ±,Q

'&36VHWWOHGRIWKHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVLQYRLFHVVXEPLWWHG LQ'&36VHWWOHG

RIWKHLQYRLFHVVXEPLWWHG DQGLQ'&36VHWWOHGRIWKHLQYRLFHVVXEPLWWHGId.

$QGLQHDFK\HDUDOORIWKHLQYRLFHVWKDWZHUHVHWWOHGZHUHVHWWOHGDWVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH

86$2Laffey 0DWUL[UDWHId.

:KLOHWKLVHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDWVRPHODZ\HUVKDYHDJUHHGWRDFFHSWVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQW

RIWKH86$2Laffey UDWHVIRUWKHLUZRUNRQEHKDOIRI,'($SODLQWLIIVVHWWOHPHQWDZDUGVSUHVHQW

GUDZEDFNV DV HYLGHQFH VLQFH WKH\ OLNHO\ XQGHUVWDWH WKH SUHYDLOLQJ PDUNHW UDWHV IRU VSHFLDO

HGXFDWLRQ DWWRUQH\V  7KH &RXUW FDQQRW LJQRUH WKH IDFW WKDW VHWWOHPHQWV UHIOHFW FRPSURPLVHV

EHWZHHQWZRSDUWLHVWKDWKDYHIDFWRUHGLQWKHFRVWVDQGULVNVRIFRQWLQXHGOLWLJDWLRQ$VHWWOHPHQW

WKDWLQFOXGHVWKHSD\PHQWRIDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDWDVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQW86$2Laffey UDWHPD\EHDQ

LQGLFDWLRQRIDIDLUUDWHEXWLWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\PHDQWKDWWKHUDWHLVWKHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH

7KLVREVHUYDWLRQLVEROVWHUHGE\WKHDIILGDYLWVSODLQWLIIVSURYLGHGZKLFKDYHUWKDWUDWHVDW

VHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey 0DWUL[DUHWRRORZWRHQDEOH,'($DWWRUQH\VWRPDLQWDLQ

DIXOOWLPHSUDFWLFHVHUYLQJDOPRVWH[FOXVLYHO\QRQSD\LQJ,'($FOLHQWVSee +HFKW'HFOˆ

³,I,FDQQRWJHWLaffey UDWHVLQDWLPHO\PDQQHUIRUWKHOHJDOZRUN,SHUIRUP,PD\QRWEHDEOHWR

FRQWLQXHVHUYLQJWKHLQGLJHQWSRSXODWLRQRQDFRQWLQJHQF\EDVLV´ 2VWUHP'HFOˆˆ±  VWDWLQJ

WKDWKH³IRXQGLWLPSRVVLEOHWRVXVWDLQ´DSUDFWLFHWKDWZDVFRPSOHWHO\IRFXVHGRQ,'($FDVHVIRU

LQGLJHQWSDUHQWVDQGVWXGHQWVEHFDXVHKH³FRXOGQRWDIIRUG´LW 7\UND'HFOˆ DYHUULQJWKDW³LW

KDVEHFRPHYHU\GLIILFXOWWRHDUQDUHDVRQDEOHLQFRPH´IURP,'($OLWLJDWLRQDQG³LPSRVVLEOHWR

PDLQWDLQDODZILUPWKDWUHOLHVXSRQWKDWZRUNIRUWKHPDMRULW\RILWVZRUN´ id. ˆ ³,EHOLHYH

  WKDWZLWKWKHVRPHWLPHDSSOLFDWLRQRIµ86$2UDWHV¶LWLVLPSRVVLEOHWRPDLQWDLQDSUDFWLFHLQ

ZKLFKDODUJHSRUWLRQRIWKHZRUNLV,'($ZRUNIRUQRQSD\LQJFOLHQWV´ 

7KHUHIRUHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQSURYLGHGE\WKH'LVWULFWLVLQVXIILFLHQWIRULWWRPHHWLWVEXUGHQ

WRSURYLGH³VSHFLILFFRQWUDU\HYLGHQFHWHQGLQJWRVKRZWKDWDORZHUUDWHZRXOGEHDSSURSULDWH´

Covington  )G DW  ± FLWLQJ Nat’l Ass’n of Concerned Veterans  )G DW 

$FFRUGLQJO\WKH&RXUWILQGVWKDWWKHUDWHVFKDUJHGE\0U1DERUVDQG0U0RUDQDUHUHDVRQDEOH

KRXUO\UDWHVIRUWKHOHJDOVHUYLFHVSURYLGHG

8WLOL]LQJWKH86$2Laffey UDWHVDQGDGMXVWLQJWKHKRXUVH[SHQGHGDVRXWOLQHGE\WKH&RXUW

DERYHWKH&RXUWZLOODZDUGSODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHOLQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQGLQFRVWV

,,, 3ODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHODUHHQWLWOHGWRDIHHVRQIHHVDZDUG

3ODLQWLIIV DOVR DVN WKH &RXUW WR ³RUGHU IHHVRQIHHV EDVHG RQ WKH 86$2 $WWRUQH\V )HH

0DWUL[´3OV¶0HPDW+RZHYHUSODLQWLIIVGLGQRWVXEPLWDILQDOLQYRLFHWRWKH&RXUWZLWK

WKHLU UHSO\ EULHI  UDWKHUGHIHQGDQW ZDV WKH SDUW\ WKDW DWWDFKHG D ³GUDIW´ RI SODLQWLIIV¶ FRXQVHOV¶

LQYRLFHIRUOLWLJDWLQJWKHIHHLVVXHLQWKLV&RXUWSee([WR'HI¶V2SS>'NW@ ³'UDIW

,QYRLFH´ %HFDXVHRIWKLVRPLVVLRQWKH&RXUWRUGHUHGSODLQWLIIVWRVXSSOHPHQWWKHLUPRWLRQIRU

DWWRUQH\V¶IHHVZLWKDILQDOLQYRLFHWKDWFRYHUHGWKHSHULRGWKURXJKWKHILOLQJRIWKHUHSO\EULHILQ

WKLVFDVH0LQ2UGHU -XQH 

2Q-XQH SODLQWLIIVVXEPLWWHGWKHILQDOLQYRLFHDQGDOVRDWWDFKHGGHFODUDWLRQVIURP

WZRDGGLWLRQDOODZILUPHPSOR\HHVZKRZRUNHGPLQLPDOO\RQWKHFDVH&KDUOHV6LEHUWDQG-RVHSK

*ROLQNHUSee 3OV¶6XSSO)LOLQJLQ5HVSWR&W¶V-XQH2UGHU>'NW@ 6WDWHPHQWRI

  'HIHQGDQWGLGQRWRSSRVHWKHUHTXHVWIRULQFRVWVSee 'HI¶V2SSDW ³&RVWV WRWDOIRUWKHXQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQ´    7KH'UDIW,QYRLFHLQFOXGHGFKDUJHVXSWKURXJK-DQXDU\See 'UDIW,QYRLFHDW $WWKDWSRLQWLQWLPHSODLQWLIIV¶FRXQVHOV¶IHHVKDGDPRXQWHGWR  Id.     $FFRXQW ,,  'HFO RI &KDUOHV $ 6LEHUW (VT >'NW  @ ³6LEHUW 'HFO´  'HFO RI -RVHSK

*ROLQNHU>'NW@ ³*ROLQNHU'HFO´ 3ODLQWLIIVDUHVHHNLQJLQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHV

IRU  KRXUV RI ZRUN DQG   LQ FRVWV IRU SXUVXLQJ WKLV IHH OLWLJDWLRQ  See 6WDWHPHQW RI

$FFRXQW,,DW

³,'($OLWLJDQWVDUHHQWLWOHGWRUHFHLYHFRPSHQVDWLRQIRUWKHKRXUVH[SHQGHGSXUVXLQJDQ

LQLWLDOIHHDZDUGLQ'LVWULFW&RXUW´Reed)GDW7KH&RXUWRI$SSHDOV³KDV\HWWR

GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUDOODVSHFWVRIDQ,'($OLWLJDWLRQVKRXOGEHWUHDWHGDVDXQLILHGZKROHVXEMHFW

WRWKHVDPHSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH´Id.%XWLWKDVKHOGWKDWVXEVHTXHQWIHHOLWLJDWLRQVKRXOGEH

FRQVLGHUHGSDUWRIWKHVDPHDFWLRQDVWKHXQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJSeeJester v. Gov’t

of the District of Columbia  )G  ± '& &LU   KROGLQJ WKDW DQ ,'($

DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHHGLQJ DQG WKH VXEVHTXHQW MXGLFLDO SURFHHGLQJ FRQVWLWXWH ³RQH DFWLRQ´ 

Kaseman v. District of Columbia)G± '&&LU  FRQFOXGLQJWKDWIHHV

RQIHHVOLWLJDWLRQLVSDUWRIWKHVDPHDFWLRQDVWKH,'($DGPLQLVWUDWLYHKHDULQJ $QGWKH&RXUW

  &KDUOHV6LEHUWHDUQHGKLVODZGHJUHHIURP$PHULFDQ8QLYHUVLW\:DVKLQJWRQ&ROOHJHRI /DZLQ0D\DQGZDVDGPLWWHGWRSUDFWLFHODZLQ0LFKLJDQLQ-XQH6LEHUW'HFOˆ 6KRUWO\DIWHUKLVDGPLWWDQFHWRWKH0LFKLJDQEDUKHEHJDQSUDFWLFLQJODZLQ:DVKLQJWRQ'& XQGHUWKHVXSHUYLVLRQRI&KDUOHV0RUDQDQG6WHYLH1DERUVSXUVXDQWWR'&&RXUWRI$SSHDOV5XOH  F  Id. ˆ0U6LEHUWZDVDGPLWWHGWRWKH'&EDURQ)HEUXDU\Id.ˆ0U6LEHUW DYHUUHGWKDWKLVSUDFWLFHIRFXVHVRQVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQODZXQGHUWKH,'($DQGWKDWKLVELOOLQJUDWH LVSHUKRXUSXUVXDQWWRWKHFXUUHQW86$2Laffey 0DWUL[Id.ˆˆ±   -RVHSK*ROLQNHUHDUQHGKLVODZGHJUHHIURP$PHULFDQ8QLYHUVLW\:DVKLQJWRQ&ROOHJHRI /DZLQDQGKHLVDPHPEHURIWKH6WDWH%DURI1HZ0H[LFR*ROLQNHU'HFOˆˆ+H KDVILYH\HDUVRIFRPELQHGH[SHULHQFHLQVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQWHDFKLQJODZDQGDGYRFDF\DQGKH FXUUHQWO\ZRUNVDVDODZFOHUNDW0RUDQDQG$VVRFLDWHVId.ˆˆ 7KHILUP³FXVWRPDULO\ELOOV IRU>KLV@WLPHDWWKH86$2PDWUL[SDUDOHJDOUDWH´ZKLFKLVSHUKRXUId. ˆ see also 86$2Laffey 0DWUL[   3ODLQWLIIV¶'UDIW,QYRLFHRULJLQDOO\VRXJKW LQFRVWVDQGGHIHQGDQWGLGQRWRSSRVH WKDWUHTXHVWLQLWVEULHISee 'UDIW,QYRLFHDW 'HI¶V2SSDW ³&RVWVWRWDO LQFXUUHG IRUIHHVRQIHHV´ $OWKRXJKWKHDPRXQWQRZLQFOXGHVDQDGGLWLRQDOFKDUJHIRUSULQWLQJsee 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,,DWWKH&RXUWZLOOFRQWLQXHWRWUHDWWKHUHTXHVWIRUFRVWVDVXQRSSRVHG    RI$SSHDOVLQReed XSKHOGDGLVWULFWFRXUW¶VGHFLVLRQWRDZDUGIHHVRQIHHVDWWKHVDPHSUHYDLOLQJ

PDUNHWUDWHDVWKHXQGHUO\LQJIHHDZDUGIRUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQReed)GDW

'HIHQGDQWDUJXHVWKDWWKHKRXUO\UDWHDZDUGHGIRUWKHWLPHVSHQWSUHSDULQJSODLQWLIIV¶IHH

SHWLWLRQVKRXOGEHILIW\SHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey0DWUL[UDWH'HI¶V2SSDW7RVXSSRUW

LWVSRVLWLRQWKHGHIHQVHSRLQWVWRDIHZFDVHVLQWKLVGLVWULFWWKDWKDYHRUGHUHGIHHVRQIHHVDZDUGV

DWILIW\SHUFHQWRIWKH86$2UDWHVSee 'HI¶V2SSDW FLWLQJFDVHV %XWDOORIWKRVHFDVHV

ZHUHGHFLGHGSULRUWRWKH&LUFXLW¶VGHFLVLRQLQReed)GDW$QGVLQFHWKHQFRXUWVLQ

WKLVGLVWULFWKDYHRUGHUHGIHHVRQIHHVDZDUGVDWWKHVDPHUDWHVDVWKRVHDZDUGHGWRWKHDWWRUQH\V

IRUWKHXQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQSee, e.g. Shaw v. District of Columbia)6XSSG

 ±  ''&   DZDUGLQJ IXOO 86$2 Laffey UDWHV IRU IHHVRQIHHV OLWLJDWLRQ DQG

DJUHHLQJZLWKRWKHUFRXUWV³WKDWDSODLQWLIIVHHNLQJIHHVRQIHHVQHHGQRWDJDLQGHPRQVWUDWHWKDW

WKHIHHUDWHVRXJKWLVUHDVRQDEOH´ McNeil v. District of Columbia)6XSSG±

''&  DZDUGLQJVHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRI86$2Laffey UDWHVLQERWKWKHXQGHUO\LQJIHH

DZDUGDQGWKHIHHVRQIHHVDZDUGDQGREVHUYLQJWKDWUHOLWLJDWLQJWKHIHHLVVXH³ZRXOGEHLOORJLFDO

JLYHQWKDWWKHLQLWLDOIHHSURFHHGLQJDQGWKLVSURFHHGLQJDUHSDUWVRIWKHVDPHDFWLRQ´ 

7KH'LVWULFWKDV³IDLOHGWRSURYLGHDQ\HYLGHQFHVXJJHVWLQJWKDWWKHµSUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH¶

IRUIHHVRQIHHVLVGLVWLQFWIURPWKHUDWHXVHGWRFDOFXODWHDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVIRUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYH

SURFHHGLQJV´Reed)GDW FRQFOXGLQJWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWDEXVHLWVGLVFUHWLRQ

LQDSSO\LQJWKHVDPHUDWHIRUIHHVIRUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJVDQGIHHVRQIHHVLQOLJKWRI

  'HIHQGDQW DOVR PDLQWDLQV WKDW WKH ILIW\ SHUFHQW UDWH VKRXOG EH DSSOLHG WR WKH HQWU\ RQ SODLQWLIIV¶LQYRLFH³UHODWHGWRWKHXQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQZKLFKELOOVWZRKRXUV¶WLPHIRU UHYLHZLQJDQGSUHSDULQJWKHLQYRLFH´'HI¶V2SSDW see 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,DW ³([LW DXGLWLQYRLFH´ %XWGHIHQGDQWJLYHVQROHJDOUHDVRQIRUZK\WKH&RXUWVKRXOGUHGXFHWKHUDWH DVVLJQHGWRWKDWHQWU\)XUWKHUWKH'LVWULFWDOUHDG\DVVHUWHGWKDWWKH³SUHYDLOLQJPDUNHWUDWH´LV VHYHQW\ILYHSHUFHQWRIWKH86$2Laffey UDWHDQGWKH&RXUWKDVDOUHDG\UHMHFWHGWKDWSRVLWLRQ    WKH ³IDLOXUH WR VXEPLW HYLGHQFH RI DQ\ PHDQLQJIXO GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ WK>H@ WZR W\SHV RI

OLWLJDWLRQ´ 7KHUHIRUHWKH&RXUWZLOODZDUGSODLQWLIIV¶DWWRUQH\VIHHVIRUWKHLQVWDQWIHHOLWLJDWLRQ

DWWKHIXOO86$2Laffey 0DWUL[UDWH

%XWWKDWGRHVQRWHQGWKHLQTXLU\$QDWWRUQH\V¶IHHDZDUGLVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKH³QXPEHU

RIKRXUVUHDVRQDEO\H[SHQGHGRQWKHOLWLJDWLRQPXOWLSOLHGE\DUHDVRQDEOHKRXUO\UDWH´Hensley

 86 DW   7KXV WKH &RXUW PXVW DOVR GHWHUPLQH LI WKH  KRXUV RI WLPH VSHQW VHHNLQJ

FRPSHQVDWLRQIRUWKH KRXUVGHYRWHGWRWKHFOLHQWZDVUHDVRQDEOHSee generally 6WDWHPHQWRI

$FFRXQW ,,  ,Q PDNLQJ WKH IHH FDOFXODWLRQ WKH FRXUW ³VKRXOG H[FOXGH    KRXUV WKDW ZHUH QRW

µUHDVRQDEO\H[SHQGHG¶´VXFKDVIRUZRUNWKDWLV³H[FHVVLYHUHGXQGDQWRURWKHUZLVHXQQHFHVVDU\´

Hensley86DW LQWHUQDOFLWDWLRQRPLWWHG  )XUWKHUWKHFRXUWPD\FRQVLGHUDYDULHW\RI

IDFWRUVWRGHWHUPLQHLIWKHRYHUDOOIHHDZDUGVKRXOGEHDGMXVWHG³XSZDUGRUGRZQZDUGLQFOXGLQJ

WKHLPSRUWDQWIDFWRURIWKHUHVXOWVREWDLQHG¶´Id. LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG ³7KHUHLVQR

SUHFLVHUXOHRUIRUPXODIRUPDNLQJWKHVHGHWHUPLQDWLRQV7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWPD\DWWHPSWWRLGHQWLI\

VSHFLILF KRXUV WKDWVKRXOG EH HOLPLQDWHG RU LWPD\ VLPSO\ UHGXFH WKHDZDUG WR DFFRXQW IRUWKH

OLPLWHGVXFFHVV7KHFRXUWQHFHVVDULO\KDVGLVFUHWLRQLQPDNLQJWKLVHTXLWDEOHMXGJPHQW´Id. DW

±

$IWHU SODLQWLIIV IDLOHG WR ILOH D ILQDO LQYRLFH ZLWK WKHLU UHSO\ EULHI WKH &RXUW LQVWUXFWHG

SODLQWLIIVWRVXEPLW³DILQDOLQYRLFHWKDWFRYHUVWKHSHULRGthrough the filing of the reply brief LQ

WKLVFDVH´0LQ2UGHU -XQH  HPSKDVLVDGGHG :KLOHSODLQWLIIVUHVSRQGHGWRWKHRUGHU

WKH\ VXEPLWWHG D ILQDO LQYRLFH WKDW LQFOXGHG ELOODEOH WLPH DIWHU WKH ILOLQJ RI WKH UHSO\ EULHI RQ

)HEUXDU\See 6WDWHPHQWRI$FFRXQW,,DW ELOOLQJKRXUVIRU³>U@HDG>LQJ@WKH&RXUW¶V

PLQXWHRUGHU´DQGKRXUVIRUDXGLWLQJWKHLQYRLFHZKLFKLQFOXGHGDUHYLHZWR³YHULI\GDWHV

RISOHDGLQJVHFIQRWLFHVDQGHPDLOFRPPXQLFDWLRQV´ 7KH&RXUWILQGVWKDWLQFOXGLQJDQ\WLPH

FRXQVHOFKRVHWRGHYRWHWRWKHPDWWHUDIWHU)HEUXDU\ZRXOGEHXQUHDVRQDEOHDQGWKDW   FRXQVHOVKRXOGQRWEHFRPSHQVDWHGIRULW7KHUHIRUHWKHLQYRLFHZLOOEHUHGXFHGE\WKHKRXUV

RIWLPHELOOHGE\0U0RUDQDQGWKHKRXUVELOOHGE\0U1DERUVIRUDUHGXFWLRQRI

7KHRQO\FKDOOHQJHGHIHQGDQWPDNHVWRWKHKRXUVH[SHQGHGRQWKHIHHVRQIHHVOLWLJDWLRQ

LVWRDWLPHHQWU\RQ-DQXDU\'HI¶V2SSDW2QWKDWGDWH0U0RUDQELOOHG KRXUV

RI WLPH IRU ³>U@HYLHZ>LQJ@ SULRU +2' DQG FRPSOHWH FOLHQW ILOH DQG FRPSDU>LQJ@ WR FXUUHQW

SURFHGXUDO SRVWXUH´  6WDWHPHQW RI $FFRXQW ,, DW   'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW WKH &RXUW VKRXOG

GLVFRXQWWKHLQYRLFHE\ KRXUVEHFDXVH³>Q@RFOHDULQIHUHQFHOLHVVXSSRUWLQJWKHUHODWLRQRIWKLV

HQWU\WRWKHLUFXUUHQWPRWLRQRUDUJXPHQW´'HI¶V2SSDW%HFDXVHSODLQWLIIVGRQRWUHVSRQG

WRWKLVDUJXPHQWLQWKHLUUHSO\EULHIsee generally 3OV¶5HSO\DQGWKH&RXUWFDQQRWGHWHUPLQHWKH

SXUSRVHRIWKLVZRUN±RUZK\LWWRRNQHDUO\WZRKRXUVWRFRPSOHWH±WKH&RXUWZLOODOVRUHGXFH

WKHIHHVRQIHHVDZDUGE\WKHELOOHGIRUWKLVWLPHHQWU\

7KHVHGHGXFWLRQVZRXOGUHVXOWLQDQDZDUGRI  LQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQG LQ

FRVWVIRUWKHIHHOLWLJDWLRQRUDIHHVRQIHHVDZDUGHTXDOWRDSSUR[LPDWHO\ILIW\WKUHHSHUFHQWRIWKH

IHH IRU OLWLJDWLQJ WKH PDWWHU DW WKH IXOO 86$2 Laffey 0DWUL[ UDWH  7KH &RXUW ILQGV WKLV WR EH

VRPHZKDW GLVSURSRUWLRQDWH DQG H[FHVVLYH VLQFH WKH KRXUV WR EH VSHQW RQ WKH IHH SHWLWLRQ ZHUH

ODUJHO\ ZLWKLQ FRXQVHO¶V FRQWURO DQG LQ LWV GLVFUHWLRQ LW ZLOO UHGXFH WKH IHHV RQ IHHV DZDUG WR

RUDSSUR[LPDWHO\RQHWKLUGRIWKHIHHIRUOLWLJDWLQJWKHPDWWHU













   &21&/86,21

)RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVWKH&RXUWZLOOJUDQWSODLQWLIIV¶PRWLRQIRUDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVLQSDUW

DQG LW ZLOO DZDUG SODLQWLIIV¶ FRXQVHO  LQ DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV DQG  LQ FRVWV IRU WKH

XQGHUO\LQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHSURFHHGLQJDQGLQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQG LQFRVWVIRU

OLWLJDWLQJWKHIHHSHWLWLRQLQWKLV&RXUW-XGJPHQWZLOOEHHQWHUHGIRUSODLQWLIIVLQWKHDPRXQWRI

  LQDWWRUQH\V¶IHHVDQGFRVWV

$VHSDUDWHRUGHUZLOOLVVXH

      $0<%(50$1-$&.621 8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW-XGJH  '$7( -XO\