American Indemnity Co. v. Southern Credit Acceptance, Inc.

Florida District Courts of Appeal
American Indemnity Co. v. Southern Credit Acceptance, Inc., 147 So. 2d 10 (1962)
Hendry, Horton, Pearson, Tillman

American Indemnity Co. v. Southern Credit Acceptance, Inc.

Opinion of the Court

PER CURIAM.

The plaintiff appeals an order dismissing its complaint for declaratory judgment. The defendant moved for the order upon the ground that the complaint did not state a cause of action for declaratory relief.

The complaint alleged that the plaintiff had issued to the defendant a “Comprehensive, Dishonesty, Disappearance and Destruction Policy” and that the plaintiff, insurance company, had been advised by defendant that claims under the policy might be made because of certain alleged activities of a person formerly employed as a manager of defendant’s business. The prayer was for a declaration by the Court that defendant was not entitled to recover under the policy and should be restrained *11from instituting action for recovery of any sums thereunder.

It has been held that the courts may not he required to answer a hypothetical question or one based upon events which may or may not occur. Anderson v. Dimick, Fla.1955, 77 So.2d 867; Harris v. Harris, Fla.App.1962, 138 So.2d 376. Doubt because of disputed questions of fact alone is not sufficient. Halpert v. Oleksy, Fla.1953, 65 So.2d 762.

Affirmed.

HENDRY, J., dissents.

Reference

Full Case Name
AMERICAN INDEMNITY COMPANY, a Texas corporation v. SOUTHERN CREDIT ACCEPTANCE, INC., a Florida corporation
Cited By
2 cases
Status
Published