United Services Automobile Ass'n v. Noell

Florida District Courts of Appeal
United Services Automobile Ass'n v. Noell, 372 So. 2d 504 (1979)
1979 Fla. App. LEXIS 15367
Haverfield, Pearson, Schwartz

United Services Automobile Ass'n v. Noell

Opinion of the Court

PER CURIAM.

Defendants, United Services Automobile Association and its insureds, Herman and Laurie Graulich, appeal an order denying their motion to tax costs.

Barry Noell was injured in an automobile collision which resulted from the negligence of Herman Graulich. Noell filed suit against Graulich, his wife, Laurie, and their liability insurer, U.S.A.A. Thereafter, U.S. A.A. submitted an offer of judgment for $3,001.00 plus legally taxable costs. Noell refused the offer and the cause was tried by a jury which returned the following verdict:

“WE, THE JURY, find in favor of the Plaintiff, BARRY K. NOELL, and against the Defendants, HERMAN GRAULICH and LAURIE GRAULICH, and assess his damages at $7,680 -5.000 $2,680
“SO SAY WE ALL.
/s/ Armando J. Olivera ARMANDO J. OLIVERA, Foreman
“DATED: SEPTEMBER 29, 1978”

A final judgment for $2,680 was entered for Noell. Thereupon, U.S.A.A. filed a motion to tax costs against Noell pursuant to Fla. R.Civ.P. 1.442 on the ground that the offer of judgment was more than the judgment awarded to Noell. Noell also moved to tax costs against the Graulichs and U.S.A.A. The trial judge then heard the respective motions to tax costs and entered an order taxing costs against U.S.A.A. and the Grau-lichs on the ground that the unreduced jury verdict ($7,680) exceeded the $3,001 offer of judgment. U.S.A.A. and the Graulichs appeal therefrom. We reverse.

Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.442 clearly provides “if the judgment finally obtained by the adverse party is not more favorable than the offer, he must pay the costs incurred after the making of the offer.” [Emphasis supplied]. The final judgment obtained by Noell was $2,680. That amount being less than the unconditional offer of judgment of $3,001.00, it was error to tax costs against U.S.A.A. and the Graulichs. Pursuant to Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.442 Noell must pay the costs incurred after the making of the offer.

Reversed and remanded.

Reference

Full Case Name
UNITED SERVICES AUTOMOBILE ASSOCIATION, Herman Graulich and Laurie Graulich v. Barry K. NOELL
Cited By
1 case
Status
Published