Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Company v. Deborah Albury
Opinion
Third District Court of Appeal
State of Florida Opinion filed October 16, 2024.
Not final until disposition of timely filed motion for rehearing.
________________ No. 3D23-1890 Lower Tribunal No. 20-24242 ________________
Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance
Company,
Appellant, vs. Deborah Albury, Appellee.
An Appeal from the Circuit Court for Miami-Dade County, William Thomas, Judge.
Russo Appellate Firm, P.A. and Elizabeth K. Russo, for appellant. Alvarez, Feltman, Da Silva & Costa, PL, Paul B. Feltman, Quintana
Law, P.A., and Brittany Quintana Marti, for appellee.
Before LINDSEY, MILLER, and GORDO, JJ.
MILLER, J.
Appellant, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Company, the insurer, appeals from a final judgment rendered following a jury verdict in favor of appellee, Deborah Albury, the insured. On appeal, the insurer contends the insured’s counsel violated the “golden rule” in closing argument when he urged the jurors to use their common sense and recall the destruction caused by Hurricane Irma in considering the persuasiveness of the insurer’s expert testimony. While it is a longstanding tenet that arguments “suggest[ing] to jurors that they put themselves in the shoes of one of the parties” are improper because they encourage “the jurors to decide the case on the basis of personal interest and bias rather than on the evidence,” Metro. Dade Cnty. v. Zapata, 601 So. 2d 239, 241 (Fla. 3d DCA 1992), it is equally established that “calling upon the personal experience of the jurors . . . is not asking them to place themselves in the position of the [litigant],” Grushoff v. Denny’s, Inc., 693 So. 2d 1068, 1069 (Fla. 4th DCA 1997).1 Further, jurors are not “bound to accept the opinion of [one side]’s expert witness[], but ha[ve] a right to use their own common sense and experience and to draw all reasonable inferences from the physical facts and occurrences.” See Behm v. Div. of Admin., State Dep’t of Transp., 292 So. 2d 437, 440 (Fla. 4th DCA 1974) (quoting Seaboard Sur. Co. v. First Nat’l Bank of Montgomery, 263 F.2d 868, 871 (5th Cir. 1959)). 2 We therefore reject the assertion that the argument was so highly prejudicial and inflammatory that the trial court abused its discretion in denying the motion for mistrial and affirm the order under review.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.