Lewis v. Meginniss
Lewis v. Meginniss
Opinion of the Court
Appellee moves to strike the bill of ex - ceptions from the transcript of the record, because it shows upon its face that it was tendered to and signed by the Circuit Judge after the term at which the judgment was rendered, and after the time allowed by the order for making up and tendering the same. An order made by the Circuit Judge April 25, 1889, refusing a motion for a new trial, concludes thus: “ To the overruling of which motion defendant, by his attorney, excepts, which exception is noted ; and defendant allowed thirty days in which to make up his bill of exceptions and perfect his appeal.”
The language of the Circuit Court Rule 97, in so far as a pplicable to this controversy, is as follows: “ The bill of
It may perhaps be well to remark that the practice of incorporating into orders of this kind language which implies the grant of additional time for taking or perfecting an appeal may lead to injurious consequences. The statutes fix the time within which an appeal must be taken, and it is not within the power of the court to extend this time. Should more than thirty days from the adjournment of a term be allowed for settling a bill of exceptions, this would not extend, nor is it in the power of the court to extend, the limitation prescribed by the statute for taking appeals, viz : during the session of the court at which the judgment has been rendered or within thirty days thereafter. Thompson’s Digest, sections !, 2 and 3, p. 446; acts of
The motion is denied.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- George Lewis, of the Last Will and Testament of James D. Westcott v. Daniel B. Meginniss, Jr.
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Circuit Court Rule 97 provides that the bill of exceptions shall be made up and signed during the term of the court unless by special order further time is allowed. The time allowed by an order will be held to mean time in addition to the remainder of the term of the court, unless there is something in the order or record evidencing a contrary intent. 2. An order of the Circuit Court allowing an appellant thirty days in which to make up his bill of exceptions, means thirty days subsequent to the adjournment of the term.