Hayes v. Frohock
Hayes v. Frohock
Opinion of the Court
The appellant, James H. Hayes, brought a suit in equity in the Circuit Court for Dade County to enjoin the sheriff from making a sale of real estate situated in Dade county under an execution issued from the Oircuit Court for Dade county upon a judgment obtained by the Doty & Stowe Company against Hayes in the County Court for Dhval county. The bill of complaint alleges that the judgment of the county court for Duval county upon which the execution issued, is void because the court had no jurisdiction of the subject-matter and the parties. An injunction bond appears in the transcript indicating- that an injunction was issued' as prayed. The defendants by answer aver that the
Equity will not enjoin the sale of real estate under an execution where the legality of the execution has been adjudicated in proceedings at law taken for that purpose by the defendant in execution, and no independent equity is shown. The statute provides that the court before which an execution is returnable, may upon stated proceedings and for good cause, direct a stay of the same, and the suspension of proceedings thereon. Section 1624 Gen. Stats.; Houston v. Bradford, 35 Fla. 490, 17 South. Rep. 664. The proceeding upon affidavit! of illegality being statutory and at law may be reviewed by writ of error. Clinton v. Colclough. 54 Fla. 520, 44 South. Rep. 878. See also the remedy afforded by section 1625 Gen. Stats.; Barnett v. Hickson, 52 Fla. 457, 41 South. Rep. 606.
It appears that the legality of the execution was determined under the statutory proceedings and no writ of
The decree is 'affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- James H. Hayes v. John Frohock, Sheriff, and Doty & Stowe Company, a Corporation
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. A court of equity will not enjoin the sale of real estate under an execution that has been adjudged to be valid in proceedings at law taken for that purpose by the defendant in execution, where no independent equity is shown. 2. Where the legality of an execution has been determined under Statutory proceedings, the matter is res adjudicata and will in general not be reviewed by a. court of equity.