Director General of Railroads v. Brandies
Director General of Railroads v. Brandies
Opinion of the Court
-A writ of error was taken to a judgment awarding to Brandies damages for personal injuries received by falling from a step-ladder he was using in working on top of a railroad car in the repair yard of the defendant below.
As the injury was not caused “by the running of the locomotives, or cars or other machinery of ” a railroad company, Sec. 4964, Rev. Gen. Stats. 1920, is not applicable. If the provisions of Chapter 6521, Acts of 1913, Section 4971 et seq. Rev. Gen. Stats, are applicable upon the theory that at the time of his injury the plaintiff was employed in “railroading,” it was not shown that the injury was ‘ ‘ caused by the negligence of ’ ’ the defendant in furnishing
By the terms of the statute and by the common law the plaintiff cannot recover damages for an injury that the evidence shows was solely ‘ ‘ caused by his own negligence. ’ ’ Long v. Pughsley, 80 Fla. 278, 85 South. Rep. 664; Perkins v. Morgan Lumber Co., 68 Fla. 503, 67 South. Rep. 126.
Reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Director General of Railroads, in Error v. James R. Brandies, in Error
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Neither at common law nor by statute can a recovery of damages for personal injuries be legally had where the injury was solely caused by the plaintiff’s own negligence.