Grand Lodge Indep. Order of Archery v. City of Live Oak

Supreme Court of Florida
Grand Lodge Indep. Order of Archery v. City of Live Oak, 177 So. 742 (Fla. 1937)
130 Fla. 395; 1937 Fla. LEXIS 865
Chapman, Buford, Whitfield, Brown, Ellis, Terrell

Grand Lodge Indep. Order of Archery v. City of Live Oak

Dissenting Opinion

Buford, J.,

dissents for reasons stated as to companion case of Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery of the State of Florida v. City of Live Oak.

Opinion of the Court

This cause is before the court on appeal from an order striking from the answer of the defendant certain pertinent and material allegations submitted as a defense as more fully appear in paragraphs eight and nine thereof and the Court finds that the suit is ruled by the case of Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery of the State of Florida v. City of Live Oak, reported in130 Fla. 386, 177 So. 738. The order appealed from is hereby reversed with directions for further proceedings not inconsistent with the authority, supra.

WHITFIELD, P.J., and BROWN, J., concur.

ELLIS, C.J., and TERRELL, J., concur in the opinion and judgment.

BUFORD, J., dissents for reasons stated as to companion case of Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery of the State of Florida v. City of Live Oak. *Page 396

Opinion of the Court

Chapman, J.

This cause is before the court on appeal from an order striking from the answer of the defendant certain pertinent and material allegations submitted as a defense as more fully appear in paragraphs eight and nine thereof and the Court finds that the suit is ruled by the case of Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery of the State of Florida v. City of Live Oak, reported in 130 Fla. 386, 177 So. 738. The order appealed from is hereby reversed with directions for further proceedings not inconsistent with the authority, supra.

Whitfield, P. J., and Brown, J., concur. Ellis, C. J., and Terrell, J., concur in the opinion and judgment.

Reference

Full Case Name
J. L. Hopps, J. L. Hopps, as Trustee for the Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery, and Grand Lodge Independent Order of Archery v. City of Live Oak
Status
Published