Clayton v. State
Clayton v. State
Opinion of the Court
1. It being in dispute whether the accused used a weapon, it was error, requiring a new trial, for the court to charge the jury as follows: “If the jury find that the instrument the accused used was a weapon likely to produce death, in the manner in which you find it was used, then, if the accused was not justified under some rule of law, about which I have instructed you, in using the weapon, in the manner and at the time he used it, the accused would be guilty of murder, or of voluntary manslaughter, according to whether the jury find that the blow was struck from malice, express or implied, or as a result of
2. The assignments of error other than that dealt with above need not be passed upon, as the alleged errors assigned therein probably will not arise on the next trial of the case. Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.