Kirk v. Jefferson Loan Society
Kirk v. Jefferson Loan Society
Opinion of the Court
The petitioner in certiorari, as plaintiff, brought in the municipal court of Atlanta an action in trover for the recovery of a diamond ring, pledged to the defendant as a pawnbroker as security for a loan of $100, and alleged that he had tendered to the defendant the full principal and interest due and demanded the property, but that the demand was refused. The finding and judgment of the judge of the municipal court who tried the case was in favor of the defendant, and the plaintiff made an oral motion for a new trial, upon two grounds, which, subse
“If the plaintiff in certiorari sues out the writ to the decision made by the trial judge [in the municipal court of Atlanta], he can have the question as to whether the finding is contrary to evidence and contrary to law passed upon; but if, instead of suing out the writ of certiorari then, he takes an appeal to the appellate division, inasmuch as the act eliminates these two general questions on such appeal, he cannot have them reviewed by certiorari taken from a decision made by such division.” Johnston v. Brenau College, 146 Ga. 182 (5b), 187 (91 S. E. 85); Gresham, v. Lee, 152 Ga. 829, 835 (111 S. E. 404); Ga. L. 1913, p. 168. While the petition for certiorari recites, by way of history of the case, that the municipal-court judge overruled the plaintiff’s demurrer to paragraph 4 of the answer, “wherein defendant seeks to enforce by way of charges three per cent, per month on a loan of one hundred dollars,” there is no exception to this order. The two contentions of the plaintiff in the motion for new trial and as grounds of appeal to the appellate division, including the attack on the three per cent, a month interest charge, are made only in an attack upon the finding and judgment itself in favor of the defendant. The exceptions, being thus necessarily limited to the correctness of the finding and judgment as being contrary to law, under the evidence, fall within the ruling in the Brenau College case, and
Judgment affirmed on the main hill of exceptions; cross-till dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- KIRK v. JEFFERSON LOAN SOCIETY and vice versa
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published