Commercial Casualty Insurance v. Mathews
Cases that cite this one
4 later published cases cite this decision.
- World Mutual Health & Accident Insurance v. Thurmond (Ga. Ct. App. 1965)
- Atlanta Title & Trust Co. v. Allied Mortgage Co. (Ga. Ct. App. 1940)
- Sanders v. Aetna Life Insurance (Tex. 1947)
- Commercial Casualty Insurance Co. v. Mathews (Ga. Ct. App. 1940)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
There is no merit in the special assignments of error. The evidence supported the verdict. The court did not err in overruling the motion for new trial.
This court on March 10, 1938, affirmed the judgment of the superior court denying the writ (Commercial Casualty Ins. Co.
v. Mathews,
The insurance company, in the first action brought against it, denied any and all liability on the policy sued on. In NationalLife Ins. Co. v. Jackson,
During the pendency of the first action against the insurer on the policy now sued on, and until the judgment of this court became the judgment of the court below, there was a continuing denial of liability on the part of the defendant. The insurer having denied any and all liability it was a useless thing for it to require the insured to continue to furnish a report from the attending physician every thirty days. The policy contained the following provision: "If the insured is disabled by reason of such injury for more than thirty days, he or his representative must furnish to the company every thirty days, or as near thereto as may be reasonably possible, with a report in writing from his attending physician or surgeon, fully stating the condition of the insured, and the probable duration of his disability." Such denial of liability amounted to a waiver of the requirement calling for continued statements from the attending physician. Our Code, § 56-831, having provided that an absolute refusal to pay waives a compliance with preliminary notice and proofs of loss, it also provides that such refusal waives a continuation of the furnishing of such notices or reports.
The plaintiff in error says in its brief that it paid the judgment obtained in the first suit, and that the defendant in error (the plaintiff in the court below) then "requested payment for all additional months which had accrued since May 7, 1937, the date of the conclusion of the first six months sued for in the first suit." The company replied to this request and said that it did not consider that any liability had accrued under the policy in view of the fact that the claimant had failed to comply with the conditions precedent in the policy. During the pendency of the first suit and until the payment of the claim adjudged to be due, there was a continuing denial of any and all liability on the part of the insurer, and its continued refusal to pay was a continuing denial of such liability, although such denial was based on the fact that the insured had not, during the pendency of the former suit, continued *Page 361
to file monthly statements from his physician concerning the state of his injury. The petitions in the former suit and in the present action alleged a total permanent disability suffered by the insured. The insurer can not, by denial that the policy was ever in force, and also by claiming that the injury suffered did not constitute accidental means as insured against in the policy, after such issue has been determined adversely against it, defeat liability for the period covered by the present suit on the ground that the insured did not continue to furnish to it proofs of the continuation of a permanent injury every thirty days. This court, in South v. A., B. C. Railroad Benefit Asso.,
The former judgment may not be res judicata that the disability continued after the period sued for in the first action, but it is res judicata as to the validity of the policy and the liability of the insurer thereon, provided the disability thereunder continued. It having been judicially determined that there was a liability under the terms of this policy, that liability will continue as long as the hazard insured against continues, unless the insured omits to perform some duty or obligation fixed on him by the terms of the policy. The insurer contends that, during the time it was absolutely refusing to pay, the insured, in order to fix and continue its liability to him, should have continued to send in the reports every thirty days, and it bases its refusal to pay in this action on that ground alone, having failed to introduce any evidence controverting the insured's testimony in respect to the continuation of the alleged total disability. Its absolute refusal to pay waived its right to insist on the insured's furnishing to it every thirty days the doctor's certificate of his continued disability. Upon demand *Page 362 being made for such alleged continuing total disability sued for in the later action, the insurer refused to pay on the ground that the insured had failed to furnish the thirty-day reports as provided in the policy. Under the allegations in the present case, which are supported and not denied by the evidence, we think that the company had denied absolutely its liability under the policy, and had thereby waived its right to insist on an avoidance of payment on this ground. The uncontradicted evidence for the plaintiff demanded a finding that the total disability had continued up to the time of the trial of the second suit. The insured, as shown by his letters, had offered to submit to any examination required to show his continued total disability; and the defendant having made no issue on this question and having based its refusal to pay entirely on a proposition of law which under the facts is plainly adverse to it, and this being a second verdict for the plaintiff, we think the award of damages and attorney's fees should be upheld. The remaining assignments of error are without merit.
Judgment affirmed. Broyles, C. J., and MacIntyre, J.,concur.
The letters introduced in evidence in this case, written by the defendant, have never stated that it now admits, or then admitted, that the plaintiff had an injury which was protected by the terms of the policy it had issued to him, but merely stated that it would refuse to pay for the period of time accruing during the pendency of the former action because the plaintiff had not continued to give it the notice required under the policy. When sued thereon it again denied any liability on the policy, and denied the happening of the original injury as being one covered by the policy. So long as the defendant continues to deny liability under the policy the need for the service or furnishing of the thirty-day notices is suspended. It must admit the injury and its liability therefor, having heretofore continued to deny it, before it can again insist that the plaintiff comply with these terms of the policy. If any further liability occurs or the total disability continues, the insurer may for the future, by admitting that the policy is in effect and that it relies on the same, demand that the insured comply with its terms by furnishing the doctor's certificates as required therein. It can not continue its unconditional refusal to pay and at the same time insist upon the insured giving to it the notices provided for in the policy.
There is always available to the insurer the defense that the disability has ceased.
Motion for rehearing is denied. Broyles, C. J., andMacIntyre, J., concur. *Page 364
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.