Young v. State
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Edward Charles Tritt v. State (Ga. Ct. App. 2026)
- Hillsman v. the State (Ga. Ct. App. 2017)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
After a bench trial, Joshua Keith Young was convicted of hijacking a motor vehicle (OCGA § 16-5-44.1 (b)); armed robbery (OCGA § 16-8-41 (a)); two counts of aggravated assault (OCGA § 16-5-21 (b) (1), (2)); and three counts of possession of a firearm during the commission of a crime (OCGA § 16-11-106 (b)).
Young does not contest the sufficiency of the evidence sustaining his conviction. Construed in favor of the verdict, Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U. S. 307 (99 SCt 2781, 61 LE2d 560) (1979), the evidence shows that on August 19, 2011, the victim, Christopher Reyas, agreed to give Young and some other men, whom he did not know, a ride to someone’s house. When Reyas drove into the driveway, one of the men
At trial, before hearing testimony, the trial judge questioned Young about whether he wanted a bench trial or a jury trial. Young stated that he wanted a bench trial and that he understood the rights he was waiving. The trial judge explained the difference between a bench trial and a jury trial, emphasized that Young had the right to a jury trial if he wanted one, and discussed possible sentencing parameters. Young then discussed the waiver with his counsel and signed a statement waiving his right to a jury trial. The waiver was read for the record. As Young concedes in his appellate brief, “The Court questioned the Defendant at length during the trial of the case, with regard to the waiver of the jury trial. The Court provided adequate time and insisted the waiver be in writing. . . . The Court made sure that the waiver of Defendant’s right to a jury trial was a knowing waiver.”
Young contends that his counsel provided ineffective assistance.
was required to show both that his counsel’s performance was professionally deficient and that but for counsel’s unprofessional conduct, there is a reasonable probability [that] the outcome of the proceedings would have been different. . . .
The likelihood of a different result must be substantial, not just conceivable. . . . [W]e accept the trial court’s factual findings and credibility determinations unless clearly erroneous, but we independently apply the legal principles to the facts.
(Citations and punctuation omitted.) Hill v. State, 291 Ga. 160, 164 (4) (728 SE2d 225) (2012).
At the hearing on Young’s motion for new trial, his trial counsel testified that he explained the differences between a bench trial and a jury trial to his client, and that “Mr. Young had expressed to me that he did not want a Jury Trial, he wanted a Bench Trial. . . [because] he knows what his [criminal] record was and he didn’t want other people to hear[.]” Young’s trial counsel also said his client wanted a bench trial because he did not believe that the victim would come to court. “I told him at that point that... the alleged victim was in court, ready to go to court and did he still want to go with the [b]ench [t]rial or want to go with the [j]ury [t]rial. He still elected to go with the [b] ench [t]rial.” Trial counsel testified that he advised Young to choose a jury trial “based on the charges, your record and things like that[,]” and also considering what Young apparently knew or believed about the trial judge. Trial counsel testified that he did not coerce Young into having a bench trial, but, rather, reiterated his belief that Young should have a jury trial “based on ... the inconsistency in the alleged victim” about the event which could lead to an acquittal.
By contrast, Young testified at the motion for new trial hearing that his counsel told him he would get “an automatic not guilty verdict because [counsel] doesn’t believe that [the] victim was going to show up [.]” Young stated that his counsel’s theory was to “make the State believe that we wanted a jury trial, but when it came to it, to select a [b] ench [t] rial to get that not guilty verdict because he told me the victim was not in the courtroom.” Young testified that he did not know the victim was at court until the victim was called to testify.
“When considering a claim of ineffective assistance, the trial court, not this Court, is the judge of witness credibility, and a trial court’s denial of an [ineffective assistance of counsel] claim based on conflicting evidence is not clearly erroneous.” (Citation and punctuation omitted.) Wallin v. State, 285 Ga. App. 377, 381 (646 SE2d 484) (2007) . Here, the trial court “was authorized to believe trial counsel’s testimony over that of [Young].” (Citation omitted.) Thomas v. State, 297 Ga. App. 416, 418 (1) (677 SE2d 433) (2009) (trial court authorized to believe testimony of counsel over that of defendant and his mother as to whether counsel discussed or adequately discussed the differences between a bench trial and a jury trial with defendant). Further, the trial court did not err in denying Young’s motion for new trial, as Young failed to show deficient performance by counsel. See Defrancisco v. State, 289 Ga. App. 115, 119 (1) (e) (656 SE2d 238) (2008) (rejecting contention that trial counsel failed to advise defendant of consequences of jury trial waiver where counsel testified that
2. Young also argues that his trial counsel failed to investigate the case adequately because he did not call certain witnesses whose testimony could have changed the outcome of the trial.
At the hearing on the motion for new trial, Young testified that he prepared a witness list at his attorney’s request and told him about it two weeks before trial, but that trial counsel never retrieved it. Young said he gave the list to counsel on the day of trial, and that counsel tried to call some of the witnesses at the break but said it was “too late.” However, Young also testified that trial counsel did not look at or take the witness list. At the motion for new trial hearing, his handwritten witness list was tendered into evidence. Young’s father testified that he “tried to give [trial counsel] some witnesses . . . but when I said something to him he just acted like he didn’t want them.” He testified that he had correct names and addresses for the witnesses, including a man named “Srilai,” but he did not offer any last name or bring that information to the motion for new trial hearing.
By contrast, Young’s trial counsel testified that the only witness list he received was from the district attorney’s office. He stated that he interviewed the victim and some of Young’s family members who were not witnesses. He also spoke with Young’s sister, Autumn Young, but only about the progress of the case. Trial counsel testified that he spoke with one of the individuals who was in the car with Young, but could not find a third person who was in the car. He did not identify either person.
At the motion for new trial hearing, Young called two people, including his sister, from the witness list that he said he had tried to give to his lawyer. He also called a man named Srilai Sripasert. Young testified that Sripasert was not on his list because he did not know that witness’s full name.
Autumn Young testified that she saw several people, none of whom she named, beat up the victim. She testified that her brother tried to help the victim and then drove the victim away from the scene in the victim’s car. Her brother later returned and told her that the victim “wanted out of the car, he wouldn’t let me help him.” She indicated that the victim had been left “on the side of the road[.]” She testified that she was on methamphetamine at the time she witnessed the incident. She offered no testimony as to whether her brother took the victim’s car with or without the victim’s permission.
Finally, Young called Sripasert. Sripasert testified that he saw the victim get beaten up, and that Young drove him and the victim away from the scene because the victim did not want to drive. He offered no testimony about whether the victim allowed Young to drive his car. He testified that Young and the victim were arguing and that Young stopped the car and told the victim to get out and drive, but that the victim got out and walked off, and Young drove away in the victim’s car. He testified that he did not see Young threaten the victim or pull a gun on him.
From the bench, the trial court stated that after hearing the testimony from Young’s witnesses, “none of the testimony presented today would have made a reasonable probability of a different outcome.” He also stated that Sripasert’s testimony was cumulative of Young’s.
As noted above, trial counsel testified that the only witness list he received was from the district attorney’s office, and that he tried to find one of the witnesses who was in the car with Young, but was unable to do so. Even where, as here, a defendant presents testimony from witnesses whom he alleges trial counsel should have called, in the context of counsel’s reason for not calling the witnesses, “the trial court was authorized to credit counsel’s testimony regarding . . . witnesses whose names he was given.” (Citation omitted.) Woods v. State, 275 Ga. 844, 847-848 (3) (a) (573 SE2d 394) (2002). Although Young’s testimony, and that of his father, conflicted with trial counsel’s testimony regarding the names of witnesses that were provided, “[i]t is within the trial court’s discretion to resolve conflicting testimony between trial counsel and a defendant at a hearing on motion for new trial.” (Citation and punctuation omitted.) Driggers v. State, 295 Ga. App. 711, 718-719 (4) (d) (673 SE2d 95) (2009) (even though witness, who was not called to testify at trial, offered potentially exculpatory testimony at motion for new trial hearing, where defendant’s testimony conflicted with counsel’s over whether counsel had been given the witness’s name, trial court was entitled to believe counsel and to find no ineffectiveness). Here, the trial court was authorized to resolve the conflicting testimony and find that trial counsel was not given any witness list other than the one from the district attorney’s office, and was unable to find one of the witnesses
Having determined that counsel’s performance was not deficient, we need not analyze the reasonable probability prong of the ineffective assistance test. Works v. State, 301 Ga. App. 108, 114 (7) (686 SE2d 863) (2009). Although the trial court found that counsel was not ineffective because there was no reasonable probability of a different outcome, a ruling right for any reason will be affirmed. Davis v. State, 287 Ga. 414, 415 (696 SE2d 644) (2010).
Judgment affirmed.
Young was found not guilty of battery (OCGA § 16-5-23.1 (a)).
Young’s appellate brief does not comply with Court of Appeals Rule 25 (c) (1), which requires that the sequence of arguments in the brief follow the order of the enumeration of errors and be numbered accordingly. This rule “is a requirement which this Court imposes to ensure that all enumerations of error are addressed and to facilitate review of each enumeration. By failing to comply with the rule, [Young has] hindered [this] Court’s review of [his] assertions].]” Brown v. Cooper, 237 Ga. App. 348, 348 (514 SE2d 857) (1999). Further, a party may not expand his enumerations through argument or citation in his brief, and matters not enumerated as error will not be considered on appeal. Brown v. State, 310 Ga. App. 835, 835, n. 1 (714 SE2d 395) (2011).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.