Robert H. McNair, Co-Executor of the Estate of W. O. McNair v. Richard "Richie" Harold McNair
Opinion
Court of Appeals of the State of Georgia
ATLANTA,____________________
March 07, 2017 The Court of Appeals hereby passes the following order:
A15A1627. ROBERT H. MCNAIR, CO-EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF W.
O. MCNAIR v. RICHARD “RICHIE” HAROLD MCNAIR et al.
This is an appeal filed by Robert H. McNair (“Appellant”), one of three co- executors of the estate of W. O. McNair, from the judgment on a jury verdict allowing the will of Hazel McNair (“H. McNair”) to be probated in solemn form. For the following reasons, we dismiss this appeal.
The pertinent facts are as follows: upon the death of H. McNair, her will, dated September 17, 2001, was filed for probate in solemn form in Turner County Probate Court in November 2011. Two co-executors were appointed under the will, Richard McNair (“R. McNair”) and Penny Thompson. H. McNair’s brother, W. O. McNair, filed a caveat to the probate of her will. An affidavit of the Appellant, contesting H. McNair’s will, was filed with the caveat. The Probate Court issued an order on June 12, 2013, denying the Petition to Probate the Will in Solemn Form. R. McNair and Thompson filed an appeal of the Probate Court’s order in Turner County Superior Court on June 21, 2013.
W. O. McNair passed away on July 27, 2013. His will appointed three co- executors, W. O. McNair, Jr., Thompson, and the Appellant (collectively, the “co- executors”).1 Prior to the trial on the caveat to H. McNair’s will, W. O. McNair, Jr., Thompson, and R. McNair filed a motion to substitute parties. The trial court, after a hearing, entered an order substituting the co-executors in place of W. O. McNair.
The challenge to H. McNair’s will was tried before a jury on September 15 and 16, 2014, and resulted in a jury verdict to probate the will in solemn form and a corresponding judgment entered by the trial court. The Appellant filed a Notice of Appeal on October 23, 2014, and this case was docketed in this Court on May 23, 2016.2
This Court has determined that we cannot reach the merits of this appeal, however, because it appears that the Notice of Appeal filed by the Appellant was legally insufficient to confer to us jurisdiction over this appeal.
Before issuing an appellate decision, this Court first has a duty to determine whether it has jurisdiction in the appeal[.] The solemn duty devolves upon this court to inquire into its jurisdiction to entertain each appeal and review the alleged errors of the trial court. The jurisdiction of an appellate court to consider an appeal depends upon whether the appeal is taken in substantial compliance with the rules of appellate procedure prescribing the conditions under which the judgment of the trial court may be considered appealable.3
A valid notice of appeal is a requirement for this Court to exercise its jurisdiction.4
Further, as a general rule, an action by or against an estate must be brought or defended by the legal representatives of the estate.5 And, under OCGA § 53-7-5 (a), personal representatives6 must act unanimously.7
In this case, it is undisputed that the Appellant is a co-executor of the estate of W. O. McNair, along with Thompson and W. O. McNair, Jr. Moreover, the judgment that is being challenged on appeal is against these co-executors, collectively. It follows that, under the plain language of OCGA § 53-7-5 (a), the Appellant was not authorized to file a Notice of Appeal from that judgment on his own, without the cooperation or written consent of his co-executors. Consequently, the Notice of Appeal is legally insufficient on its face to confer jurisdiction on this Court.8
Accordingly, we hereby DISMISS this appeal.
Court of Appeals of the State of Georgia
Clerk’s Office, Atlanta,____________________
03/07/2017 I certify that the above is a true extract from the minutes of the Court of Appeals of Georgia.
Witness my signature and the seal of said court hereto affixed the day and year last above written.
, Clerk. or settle debts or claims in favor of or against the estate.”); McCarley v. McCarley, 246 Ga. App. 171, 172 (539 SE2d 871) (2000).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.