Hammett v. Christie
Cases that cite this one
4 later published cases cite this decision.
- Brown v. Leggitt (Ga. Ct. App. 1970)
- Winn v. Armour & Co. (Ga. 1937)
- Odom v. Attaway (Ga. 1931)
- Register v. Southern States Phosphate & Fertilizer Co. (Ga. 1924)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
By the Court.
delivering the opinion.
McDonald, as assignee, occupies no better position than Hammett, for if he took the assignment bona fide, he took it subject to the equities between Christie and Hammett. Colquitt vs. Bonner, 2. Kelley's Rep. 155.
According to the bill then, Hammett, contrary to his agreement, and contrary to equity and conscience, went to trial, without notice to defendant, five years and six months after he had compromised the case and received his pay, and is now attempting to collect the money again. This is the bill.
The defendant Hammett, in his answer, admits that he wrote the letter to Isaac E. Bower, Esq., a copy of which is exhibited to complainant’s bill. In that letter, he says to Mr. Bower, that “in the case about the bond against Christie, we had several interviews, one time in March ’49. I agreed that if he, Christie, would pay me two hundred and fifty dollars and all costs, I received twenty-five dollars.” The letter, either by design or accident, is imperfect and in
. The bill alleges an assignment of the execution, by Hammett to McDonald, without consideration; Hammett’s answer admits it, and assigns as a reason why it was done, that McDonald lived near the complainant and in the same county, and is the defendant’s friend; that he himself resided at a great distance and was unable to attend to the collection of the money, and that he expects that McDonald will collect the money and account to him for it. He denies all fraudulent intent on his or McDonald’s part, in the transfer of the execution. He denies knowledge of any defence that complainant had to the judgment, as he set up none at common law. When it is remembered that the complainant’s case does not depend on a defence that he claimed to have against the bond, but on a compromise of the, suit pending on the bond; that Hammett had an attorney at law to attend to the collection of the money; that the execution was in the hands of the Sheriff for collection under his official responsibility 5 that the assignment of an execution is not the usual mode of constituting an agency in such cases, the assign
But the answer of Hammett admits that the legal interest in the^execution has passed by his, Hammett’s, own act to McDonald. This act of Hammett’s entitles the answer of McDonald to a consideration in the investigation before us, which it could not otherwise have. This answer imparjs a new feature to the case. The defendant, McDonald, seems to have known but little about the case, except what the proceedings in Court disclosed, until the assignment was made to him. The assignment is acknowledged and a copy is appended as an exhibit to his answer. It seems to have been on a separate paper, not attached to the execution. It is absolute in its terms. It would have required an instrument of no great length, to have directed the sheriff to obey the instructions of the assignee in collecting the money. The answer says that the execution was assigned to him, “ to secure the amount due to him and I. W. K. Gunn, to whom he was to account, the sum of five hundred and fifty or six hundred dollars, by John Williams, and it was agreed and understood, at the time the transfer was made, that the amount the judgment exceeded the debts above-mentioned, was to be refunded by defendant, when collected. The answers of Hammett and McDonald in respect to the assignment, cannot both be true — it is impossible. One says that it was without consideration; the other says it was for a consideration, and sets forth the consideration; one says, that he expected the assignee to account to him for the full amount of principal and interest when it was collected from complainant, the other says that the excess only, after paying Williams’ said debts, was to be refunded. A suspicion unavoidably arises on an examination of the entire case, that the debt of Christie, instead of being Hammett’s, was the debt of Williams. The suit it is true, is in Hammett’s name, and the bond was made by Christie to Hammett, as appears from an exhibit to the bill, but it appears from the
The answer of Hammett does not deny the. agreement, but varies its terms from those set forth in the bill, and the circumstances of the case as disclosed in both answers, require that the injunction should be retained for a hearing, and the judgment of “the Courtis therefore affirmed on both assignments.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.