Chamberlain & Bancroft v. Stone
Chamberlain & Bancroft v. Stone
Opinion of the Court
By the Court. delivering the opinion.
What is contained in the first paragraph of the charge, is right.
What is thus said of this part of the charge, disposes also, of the first and second requests to charge.
The second paragraph of the charge, is certainly good as far as it goes.
The third paragraph of the charge, seems to us to be erroneous.
The decisions that support these positions arenowtoo numerous, and of too long standing, to be resisted, although they are it must be admitted, in the very teeth of the great common law maxim, that a contract without consideration, is not binding.
What is thus said of this part of the charge disposes aIso? of the third fourth and fifth requests.
There ought to be a new trial.
Judgment reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Chamberlain & Bancroft, in error v. O. M. Stone, in error
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published