Carswell v. Ware
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Croxton v. Barrow (Ga. Ct. App. 1937)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
delivering the opinion.
James Ware, the father of John M. Ware, the defendant in execution, called his children together one day in the latter part of the year 1854, and made an allotment of his negroes, for the purpose of division and distribution among them. In that appointment, the negroes levied on fell to the share of the defendant. The negroes do not appear to have been present at the time. After the allotment, James Ware, the father, said to John M. that he could send for the negroes whenever it was convenient; he also said at that time, and frequently before, that the part which fell to John M. he intended to settle on the wife and children, or the children of John M. This share, so ascertained, was worth more than an equal one, and he was required to pay in some money to make it equal, and he did, on that day, pay over to one of the other distributees something like $150 00; but whether he paid it out of his own money, or out of the proceeds of one of the negroes named Sam, that his father sold to Brenton Ware after the division, is not very clear. Most likely from his own money. He further retained the possession of all the negroes for a week or two after to finish gathering his crop. There was no other delivery or act done that might amount to one, than what I have stated. James Ware subsequently refused to deliver the possession to John M., but conveyed them by deed, and delivered the negroes to James M. Ware, in trust for the children of John M. These are all the facts, and the substance of all the testimony which it is necessary to notice. And upon them the question arises, whether the title to the negroes vested in John M. Ware, so as to subject them to the payment of his debts? That question depends entirely on the fact, whether the negroes were delivered to John M. in his own right, or whether the permission given to John M. to send for the negroes amounted to a delivery ? and that is the whole question in this case.
1. There is no doubt but that James Ware intended to give the negroes, but whether to John M. or to his children, is not equally clear ; the weight of testimony is, that he intended to give them to his children, and not to him, I might say almost overwhelmingly so ; but whether the one way or the other, it is not necessary to inquire, as we hold, that the gift was not good, as a gift to either, for want of delivery,
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.