Cape Fear Steamboat Co. v. Torrent
Opinion of the Court
1. It is only by considering the proceedings against steamboats under section 1969 of the Code, as proceedings in personam, and not strictly proceedings in rem, that the jurisdiction of the State Courts can be maintained for the enforcement of the liens provided for by the preceding section: 40 Qa., 177. If proceedings in personam, necessarily the judgment must be against the person of the debtor. Under the Act of 1870, amendatory of the 1969th section of the Code, the affidavit is the judgment. It follows that the affidavit must set out the names of the owners or lessees, as the case may be, who owe the debt, as well as comply in other respects with the statute. And where the affidavit avers that the demand was made upon the agent, it should state that he is the agent of the pei’sons owing the debt. It is said this is not in strict accordance with the grammatical construction of the section. That the Act says “there must be a demand on the owner or agent or lessee for payment,” etc., and that this can only mean the owner of the boat, the agent of the boat, etc. Doubtless this is true, but is it anything more than the common figure of speech known to rhetoricians as personification, in which the owners or lessees are represented through the property thus impersonated ? A boat is incapable of having an agent. We speak of the agent of a hotel, of a railroad, etc. Who is the principal in such a case ? True, in proceedings in rem in maritime Courts vessels may be said to have agents. But to take this view of it would be to oust the State Courts of jurisdiction, as already indicated. And unless it is very plain that the Legislature mean to give judgment against one without a hearing, Courts will not give that construction to any Act which may bring about such a result. To hold that a demand upon the agent of the boat, as distinguished from the owner or lessee, is sufficient to authorize this summary proceeding, would be to decide that, in some cases, such a judgment might be rendered — as, for instance, in case the
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.