Supreme Court of Georgia, 1875

Hill v. Bruce

Hill v. Bruce
Supreme Court of Georgia · Decided January 15, 1875 · McCay, Trippe, Warner
54 Ga. 332

Counsel

A. C. Perry, for plaintiff in error., J. J. Floyd, for defendant.

Hill v. Bruce

Opinion of the Court

Trippe, Judge.

1. If the title to land be in the wife, it is not sufficient to subject it to the payment of the husband’s debts because it appears that he and his wife live upon it, and he returns it and pays the taxes.

2, 3. The deed to this land was made in 1858 to A. T. Scott, the brother of Mrs. Hill, the claimant. He conveyed it to her father, and the father afterwards to her. Wauldrop» who executed the deed to A. T. Scott, testified that the father paid him for it, or rather that the father gave his notes for it, with Hill, the husband, as security, and that he transferred the notes to Good, who testified that the father paid the notes to him. It was in proof that Hill, the husband, said he placed the money in the father’s hands to pay for the land. This last item of testimony is really about all that appears in the record which can be relied on to condemn the land to pay this judgment. Is it sufficient? It does not'appeal’'when Hill, the husband, made such a statement. The first deed» to-wit: from Wauldrop to the brother, was made in 1858. That was for 'the benefit of the claimant, and she and her husband went shortly thereafter into possession of it. Nor did it appear when the notes were paid to Good. The judgment on which this execution was issued was obtained in November, 1865. That was over seven years after the purchase from Wauldrop. Suppose that the husband did in 1859 or 1860 or 1861 pay for the land, or give the money to his father-in-law to pay for it, that would not make it subject *336to a debt he contracted years afterwards. It was not shown that he was in debt at the time. Nothing appears that would make such a transaction a fraud upon his creditors. Perhaps there was more than is shown by the record. But by that we are bound. Besides all this, A. T. Scott testified that the land was bought for the claimant, that it was understood at the time that it was to be paid for from the proceeds of property she owned in South Carolina, where she then lived, and that it was so paid for. Under this want of evidence, taken in connection with the positive evidence in behalf of claimant, the court below should have granted a new trial.

Judgment reversed.

McCay, Judge, concurred.

Dissenting Opinion

Warner, Chief Justice,

dissenting.

This was a claim case, and it appears from the evidence in the record that the judgment on which the execution issued that was levied on the land as the property of Hill, was obtained against him in March, 1863; that Hill had lived on the land for several years; had given it in for taxes as his property; that Hill, the defendant, said he had placed the money in Archibald Scott’s hands to pay for the land. The claimant derived her title to the land under a deed made by Wauldrop to A. T. Scott in 1858, and a deed made by A. T. Scott to Archibald Scott in.March, 1865, and a deed made by Archibald Scott to the claimant, in February, 1866, neither of which deeds were recorded until the 14th of February, 1874. The claimant is the sister of A. T. Scott and daughter of Archibald Scott. A. T. Scott says he took the deed to the land in his own name to hold it for his sister, and the question for the jury, under the evidence, was, whose money was it that paid for the land? Was the claimant’s title, under the deeds which had not been recorded until after the judgment was obtained, good as against that judgment, or was it a family arrangement, made to defeat Hill’s creditors? Assuming that the money which paid for the land, as *337testified to by A. T. Scott, was the proceeds of land sold in South Carolina, given to her by her father, it does not appear that she had any separate estate in it, and as the law then ■stood, her husband’s marital rights attached to it, and the proceeds thereof became his money, especially when reduced to possession. The jury found the property subject to the execution, and the court refused to grant a new trial.

I-n my judgment, there was sufficient evidence in the record to sustain the verdict, and especially so in this class of cases. According to the repeated rulings of this court, the discretion of the court below in refusing to grant a new trial, on the statement of facts disclosed in this record, should not be interfered with or controlled.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.