A. J. Williams & Co. v. Terrell
Cases that cite this one
12 later published cases cite this decision.
- American Loan & Trust Co. v. Atlanta Electric Ry. Co. (U.S. Circuit Court for the Northern District of Georgia 1899)
- Simmerson v. Herringdine (Ga. 1928)
- DeLay v. Latimer (Ga. 1923)
- Roberts v. Atlanta Cemetery Ass'n (Ga. 1917)
- Brooke v. Lowry National Bank (Ga. 1914)
- Hinesley v. Stewaet (Ga. 1912)
- Washington Exchange Bank v. Holland & Co. (Ga. 1904)
- Osborne v. Rice (Ga. 1899)
- Merritt v. Merritt (Ga. 1881)
- Lilienthal v. Champion (Ga. 1877)
- Stokes v. Maxwell (Ga. 1877)
- Frost v. Borders (Ga. 1877)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This case turns upon the sole question as to whether the judgment of foreclosure against the mortgagee concludes the claimant. Under our Code, a mortgage may be foreclosed either by personal service on the mortgagor or by publication. It is expressly provided (section 3965,) that if neither the mortgagor, nor his special agent or attorney, sets up any defense, it shall not be competent for any third person to do so. It follows, therefore, that this claimant, not only was not a party to the proceeding to foreclose, but that it was not competent for him, on his own motion, to have appeared and defended. Can it be possible that it was the intent of- the law that one not a party, should'be absolutely bound by a judgment against a third person, declaring this land to be subject to the mortgage, fixing the amount of it, declaring it still to be subsisting, etc., and that, too, when at the date of the proceedings the mortgagor had parted with all interest? It must be admitted that the decisions of this court leave the subject in some doubt; in other words, they cannot be reconciled. In 3 Kelly, 174, the court, in pretty plain language, declares that one occupying the position of the claimant could be heard when it was attempted to enforce the judgment of foreclosure against him, whilst in 18 Georgia, 476, it is expressly decided that the judgment is conclusive that the purchaser bought the land subject to the judgment the mortgagee might afterwards obtain against the mortgagor on foreclosure. .In 19 Georgia, 14, it is plainly and distinctly decided the other way, to-wit: that the purchaser might go behind the judgment and attack the validity of the original mortgage. It is true, only two judges sat in this case, though one of
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.