Brown v. Kimbrough
Brown v. Kimbrough
Opinion of the Court
This was a bill filed by the complainant against the defendant, praying for a decree that certain described lands therein specified, might be turned over to her, and that the defendant account to her for the rents and profits thereof. On the trial of the case, the jury, under the charge of the court, found a verdict in favor of the defendant. The caséis brought here on a bill of exceptions to the rulings of the court below. The complainant claims title to the land in controversy under a deed made by William M. Brown, administrator of Shelton, to Jack Brown, trustee for complainant, Jack Brown being her husband. This deed is dated 2d November, 1858. It appears from the evidence in the record, that the complainant and her husband, Jack Brown, conveyed the land by deed, on the 7th of May, 1861, to Kimbrough, the defendant, for the consideration of $18,000 00. The court charged the jury, amongst other things, “If Jack Brown and his wife made and executed the deed in evidence purporting to be made by them to Kimbrough, such deed conveyed to Kimbrough all the interest which they or either of them had in the lands, and if such is the case, Kimbrough is not liable to account to the complainant.” The complainant’s counsel requested the court in writing to charge the jury that “A married woman cannot, by the ordinary deed of conveyance, dispose of her separate property, if the sale be real estate;, and if Mrs. Brown, being a married woman, made the deed set out in defendant’s answer, then Kimbrough got no title to the same, and no right by which he could hold the land in opposition to Mrs. Brown.” This request to charge the court refused. Whereupon the complainant excepted to the charge as given to the jury, and to the refusal to charge as requested.
But two questions were insisted on in the argument here. First, as to the right of a married woman to convey her separate estate in land by the ordinary deed of conveyance. Second, if she can do so, then the deed- must be executed as
Let the judgment of the court below be affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Sarah M. Brown, by next friend, in error v. Elizabeth Kimbrough, administratrix, in error
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published