Lawton v. Branch
Lawton v. Branch
Opinion of the Court
The question made by this record is, whether a garnishee who fails to make answer to a summons of garnishment requiring him to answer not only in respect to indebtedness when served with the summons and when he answered it, •but intermediate those dates, when he fails to answer touching the latter point of inquiry, and judgment is awarded . against him regularly for such failure, can relieve himself from his negligence on a motion to set aside the judgment at a subsequent term on the ground of accident and mistake ?
He got the clerk to write his answer for him. He told •the clerk to write it in full, embracing the intermediate time. The clerk thinking it unnecessary, left that part out. The garnishee swore to and signed what the clerk wrote without ¡reading it over. Judgment was rendered against him for ■this insufficient answer by the court at the second term ■according to law ; and at the next, he made the motion to set it aside.
~We would be glad to relieve the garnishee if it could be done according to 'law, for the case seems a hard one. But •it is his own negligence. He did not even read over his answer after the clerk wrote it. According to his deposition, he knew what ought to be written and instructed the clerk what to write ; but the clerk intentionally omitted the fatal part. There was no mistake, therefore, by the clerk, and if any by the garnishee, it arose from his neglect to read "before he swore. A court of law, on a motion to set aside ■a judgment, will hardly grant relief when a court of equity would refuse it.
In the case of Stroup vs. Sullivan & Black, 2 Kelly, 275,
See, also, cited for defendants in error, Code, §3304; 32 Ga., 115; 60 Ib., 554; acts of 1856, p. 29, §15; Code, §§3483, 3556, 3549; 51 Ga., 326; 32 Ib., 119; 56 Ib., 510;, 45 Ib., 144-146; Code, §§4252, 4958; 58 Ga., 263; 57 Ib., 27; 38 Ib., 297, 602; Code, §§3588, 3121, 3117, 3592, 3595, 3129; 38 Ga., 138; 4 Ib., 175; 33 Ib., 12.
For plaintiff in error: 40 Ga., 506; 50 Ib., 575; 55 Ib., 153; 57 Ib., 25; 58 Ib., 262; 18 Ib., 650-657; 22 Ib., 52-55; 45 Ib., 369.
! Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Lawton v. Branch & Cooper
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published