Moore v. City of Atlanta
Cases that cite this one
56 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Department of Transportation v. Mixon (Ga. 2021)
- Department of Transportation v. Roberts (Ga. 1978)
- Woodside v. City of Atlanta (Ga. 1958)
- Athens Terminal Co. v. Athens Foundry & Machine Works (Ga. 1907)
- Evans v. Just Open Government (Ga. 1979)
- State Highway Department v. McClain (Ga. 1960)
- State Highway Department v. Strickland (Ga. 1958)
- Brown v. City of Atlanta (Ga. 1928)
- Lund v. Idaho & Washington Northern Railroad (Wash. 1908)
- Langley v. City Council (Ga. 1903)
- Downside Risk, Inc. v. Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority (Ga. Ct. App. 1980)
- Baranan v. Fulton County (Ga. 1974)
- City of Atlanta v. Kenny (Ga. Ct. App. 1951)
- Cannon v. City of Macon (Ga. Ct. App. 1950)
- Delta Air Corporation v. Kersey (Ga. 1942)
- Florida State Hospital for the Insane v. Durham Iron Co. (Ga. 1942)
- Anderson v. Lynch (Ga. 1939)
- Rodríguez Pérez v. Municipality of San Juan (Supreme Court of Puerto Rico 1938)
- Rodríguez Pérez v. Municipio de San Juan (Supreme Court of Puerto Rico 1938)
- State Ex Rel. State Road Commission v. District Court, Fourth Judicial Dist. (Utah 1937)
- County of Bibb v. Mortgage Bond Co. (Ga. 1936)
- Harbour v. City of Rome (Ga. Ct. App. 1936)
- Stansell & Rape Bros. v. City of McDonough (Ga. Ct. App. 1934)
- Felton v. State Highway Board (Ga. Ct. App. 1933)
- City of Atlanta v. Dinkins (Ga. Ct. App. 1932)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This bill was brought by the complainant against the city of Atlanta to enjoin the municipal authorities from grading a street in front of the residence of the complainant, on the ground that the grade had been fixed by the city some years ago ; that complainant had neglected to record it pursuant to law, but had acted upon it as fixed 5 had planted shade trees on the sidewalk, which had become of great value, and would be destroyed if the new grade proposed was carried out; that it was projected now
We have held up this case for some time, with a view to look closely into the bearing which the constitution of 1877, and the decision of this court thereunder in the case of The City of Atlanta vs. Green, made at the September term, 1881, and not yet reported,
In the case of The City of Atlanta vs. Green, supra, it
Weighed in these scales, how will the case at bar stand on the mere question of damage ? Will the complainant’s property be decreased in value, and if so, how much? .That much, little or large, he will be entitled to recover at law under the ruling in the case of Atlanta vs. Green, before cited.
We do not mean to say that in this case the march of improvement would be so stopped and at such injury to the city. But the principle would embrace all cases where the private property of any one citizen would be damaged by a contemplated grade of the streets by him. He could also arrest and enjoin the city, and the result would be disastrous. An injunction granted to one must, under like circumstances, be granted to all others, and the wheels of the municipal government, so far as improvement of streets is concerned, would be most effectually blocked.
Hence, the supreme court of Illinois, which was cited as authority in The City of Atlanta vs. Green, while it rules that, under a similar constitutional provision to ours, damages could be recovered also rules that an injunction ought not to be granted to stop the operations of the municipal government and clog its wheels. 75 Ill., 74.
It must be observed, too, that this is not in that class of cases where private property is taken possession of, and dominion over, for public use; but the city is grading its own sidewalks. It is upon its own soil, and the damage is only consequential. The distinction is broad, and is made in the case from the 75th Illinois, supra.
It distinguishes this case, also, from Chambers vs. The Cincinnati and Georgia Railroad Company, decided at the September term, 1882,
In this case, Mr. English, the then mayor of the city, and Mr. Rice, a contractor, are implicated by charges in the bill as urging this grade for individual profit and emolument; but they deny on affidavit all intimations of the sort. The chancellor could hardly do otherwise than accept this explicit denial, as there is no positive evidence to the contrary. The intimations in the bill stand alone and unsupported in the record. If the authorities of the city were using their official power in behalf of individual profit of their own, or of others in collusion with them, at the expense and to the damage of other citizens, the courts would soon find means to put a stop to all such conduct; but as the charge would involve a deep degree of moral turpitude, the proof should be correspondingly strong and certain.
On a careful consideration of the whole case, we see no course for this court, under the principles of equity applicable to the facts, but to affirm the denial of the writ of injunction.
Judgment affirmed.
67 Ga . 386.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.