Lewis v. Harper
Lewis v. Harper
Opinion of the Court
This case presents the point whether an instrument, drawn by G. Y. Hunter, defendant in execution, and delivered to Lewis & Minor for the payment of four hundred and fifty dollars, and payable to Hunter’s own order, and on its face showing that it was an advancement to make a crop, made by Lewis & Minor to Hunter, with a blank indorsement thereon, but said indorsement not signed by Hunter, will support a judgment and execution in favor of Lewis & Minor, founded on a declaration in the statutory form, in the name of Lewis & Minor, on said instrument. The court below, on a claim case to property levied on under the execution, held that it could not, title not having passed to them in the view of that court, and the
Nor does the decision made in 66 Ga., 735, necessarily conflict with Patillo vs. Mayer & Glauber and DeVaughn vs. Haugabook, the point there ruled being that the declaration could not be so amended as to change by parol evidence the instrument into a promissory note for past indebtedness, though the reasoning of the court in the opinion might lead a cursory reader to see conflict. The error alleged was that amendment, in the case in the 66th, and no stress was laid on the validity of the original suit, which was not passed upon directly by the judgment rendered. It is true that in DeVaughn vs. Haugabook, the indorsement had been signed, and of course that case differs from this in that essential particular; but in Patillo vs. Mayer & Glauber, there was no indorsement, and that case is cited and approved in the first named. There was no indorsement or acceptance in Patillo vs. Mayer & Glauber, but the name of the drawer was written across the face of the paper, and after him another party. The legal effect of that judgment, as well as its reasoning, would seem to make such a paper virtually a promissory note, or promise to pay the money to the merchants advancing supplies to make the crop of the drawer, and therefore that it might be sued directly by them.
Judgment reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Lewis & Minor v. Harper
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published