Linder v. Benson & Co.
Linder v. Benson & Co.
Opinion of the Court
An act of the General Assembly, providing in what way garnishments may be dissolved, approved October 15, 1885 (acts, p. 96,) by its first section prescribes a bond with good security, payable to the plaintiff and conditioned for the payment of the judgment that shall be rendered on the garnishment, and authorizing the plaintiff to
The superior court affirmed these several rulings, upon certiorari sued out and prosecuted by the defendant and his surety and endorser. This judgment to which they except, we think, was erroneous and should be set aside; in fact, we are of opinion that the bond given to dissolve the garnishment was such an one as no judgment could be rendered on ; it was certainly not good as a statutory bond, for it did not comply with the requirements of the statute then of force, nor was it valid under the former act, for that had been repealed when it was executed. As a common law bond, if it can be regarded in that light, upon which we give no opinion, it would have to be enforced by a regular suit against the obligors, and such a suit would be open to the defence that the effects in the hands of the garnishee were exempt from the debts of the defendant, unless it could be shown that the homestead itself, or the income from it, was liable under some one of the exceptions specified in the constitution, which, we believe, is not insisted upon in this case. We therefore order and direct that the judgment dismissing the certiorari be set aside; that a judgment be entered sustaining the same; that the judgment rendered in the justice’s court against the obligors in the bond be vacated and annulled; that the garnishment proceeding be dismissed; that the garnishee be required to pay to the defendant, Smith, the amount he admits to be due, either in money or as rent in kind, or the value thereof, arising from his use and occupation of the homestead premises; and that the plaintiff in execution be required to pay the cost, not only of the certiorari, but all costs accruing in the justice court on account of the garnishment, as well as the costs incurred for bringing the case to this court, including those with which they stand chargeable in this court.
Judgment reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Linder v. Benson & Company
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published