Tarver v. New England Mortgage Security Co.
Opinion of the Court
The record iioav before us is exceedingly voluminous; but as the case is absolutely controlled by the principles which were formulated when our judgment was announced, it is entirely unnecessary to enter upon a discussion of the various irrelevant matters brought to our attention.
Unless the wife and children of W. B. Tarver are to be treated as parties to the application for a homestead made by him as the head of a family, and also parties to the appeal entered by creditors from the judgment thereon rendered by the ordinary, there was not a single party to the homestead case who Avas also a party to the proceeding for setting aside the judgment against the homestead right, rendered in the superior court. Regarding Mrs. Tarver and her children as mere privies of the applicant, or beneficiaries for whom the homestead was sought, we could safely rest the case here, without further discussion; for if anything in procedure is settled, it is that persons not parties to a case in which a judgment Avas rendered cannot, by any sort of a proceeding among themselves alone, set that judgment aside so as to affect or bind any other person in the known world.
But how will the case stand if the wife and children áre to be regarded as actual parties to the homestead case, including the proceedings on appeal? In our judgment, the result must be exactly the same. The motion filed by the next friend of the minor children, to set aside the judgment disposing of the case on appeal, was virtually the commencement of a new case — a sort of informal, irregular and very incomplete substitute for an equitable petition. Hoav could any judgment rendered on that motion in any manner whatever affect
Moreover, it would seem that the applicant for the homestead, having conveyed the premises absolutely to his wife pending the appeal, thereby abandoned his application for a homestead. This was the same, so far as he was concerned, as if he had himself dismissed the application when his conveyance was made. This abandonment stands good up to the present time, for he neither procured the judgment on appeal to be set aside, .nor was ever heard at all in the proceedings by which
The lien of the mortgage being, in our opinion, for aught disclosed by the present record, absolutely perfect as to the mortgaged premises (which include the homestead), the purchaser at a sale had upon the foreclosure of the mortgage obtained a good title as against Mrs. Tarver and her children; and the court did not err in denying the prayer for injunction and receiver.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.