Savannah, Florida & Western Railway Co. v. Waller
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Haywood v. Atlantic Coast Line R. (United States District Court for the Southern District of Georgia 1919)
- Savannah, Florida & Western Railway Co. v. Waller (Ga. 1898)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The nature of this case may be gathered from the recitals in the head-notes, there being no substantial conflict, in so far as they relate to the facts, between the one announced by a majority of the court and those in which Justice Atkinson expresses his dissent to the judgment rendered. We differed, however, in applying the law to the facts.
Unless the railway company was negligent relatively to the child who was injured, he was not entitled to recover. It was not, as to him, negligent unless it violated some duty which it owed to him with reference to the particular act by which the injury was occasioned. It cannot be denied that a railway company has an undoubted right to shift and move freight-cars at its pleasure upon the tracks in its yard; nor that under ordinary circumstances, it would be
It is insisted, however, that as the plaintiff was one of a large number of children who were permitted by the company to enter its yard for the purpose of carrying meals to their fathers, who were employees in the service of the ■company; and that as it was known to the company these ■children were likely to be in the yard at, or about, the dinner hour, and would probably go under standing cars, it ■owed to them a duty of seeing to it that such cars were not .suddenly put in motion so as to endanger their lives or limbs. We do not think that the mere permission by the company for these children to enter its yard for the purpose stated, carried with it, under all conceivable circum•stances, a duty so sweeping as this, there being a perfectly safe way for the children to pass and repass while in the yard, without going upon the tracks where cars were standing, and no occasion for their going under the cars at all. Certainly the invitation by the company to the children, if the above mentioned permission or license may properly be so termed, did not contemplate that they should go under, or so near to, these cars as to become in danger. But it is said the company might have foreseen that, because of their indiscretion and want of judgment arising from their tender years, these children were liable to exceed the license they actually had, and that the company ought, accordingly, to have taken the proper precautions to insure their safety in case they should do so. Granting that this would be true, if the injury to the plaintiff had happened' while things were going on in the usual and ordinary way in the company’s yard, we feel constrained to hold that this particular injury was, at last, the result of a mere casualty. Conceding, for the sake of the argument; the ■company was under a duty, in the usual course of its busi
We have given this case much thought and deliberation, and our conclusion is that, under the evidence, the verdict cannot be supported upon legal principles, and ought to he set aside. Judyment reversed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting.
Aside from the facts stated in the official report, it is only necessary to refer to what in the treatment of the questions made in this cause, both by the majority and
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.