Southern Railway Co. v. Collins
Cases that cite this one
5 later published cases cite this decision.
- Furman v. Smith (Ga. Ct. App. 1962)
- Callier v. Trussell (Ga. Ct. App. 1946)
- Southern Railway Co. v. Grizzle (Ga. Ct. App. 1932)
- Georgia Southern & Florida Railway Co. v. Barfield (Ga. Ct. App. 1907)
- Fair v. Culpepper & Son (Ga. Ct. App. 1928)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Collins brought suit, in a justice’s court, against the Southern Railway Company, for damages. The summons issued by the justice of the peace was as follows:
“ Georgia, Pulaski county. To the Southern Railway Company.
“ You are hereby notified, on or about Jan. 3rd, 1902, you damaged the subscriber, E. P. Collins, to the amount of $50.00, by the train on the Southern Railway Company’s road at the crossing near the depot in the town of Cochran known as Landfair’s crossing, by recklessly running of the cars or locomotive on-said road, which ran over, broke, and tore up the wagon of E. P. Collins, to the damage of said E. P. Collins to the amount of ($50.00) fifty dollars; and*412 desiring that the amount be legally assessed, you are hereby required by agent or attorney or in person to appear at the justice court in the town of Cochran, 386th dist. G. M., by 10 o’clock a. m. on the 4th Wednesday in March, 1902, then and there to show cause, if any exist, why the damages should not be assessed according to law. This March 15th, 1902.
Geo. F. Hendricks, J. P.”
When the case was called for trial in the justice’s court, the defendant appeared, by its attorney at law, and made a written motion to dismiss it, upon the following grounds: “ 1st. Because no cause of action is set forth, the suit was not commenced with the cause of action annexed as required by law, and the justice of the peace has no jurisdiction to assess damages and proceed in the manner in which he is attempting to proceed. 2nd. Because Code sections 2253 to 2260, under which this proceeding was instituted, have been repealed, and there is no law to authorize the proceeding.” This motion was overruled by the magistrate, and he, over the objection of counsel for the defendant, proceeded with the trial of the case and rendered a judgment in favor of the plaintiff for $50.00 and costs of the suit. The defendant carried the case by certiorari to the superior court, alleging error in the ruling of the magistrate upon the motion to dismiss. The certiorari was overruled and the defendant excepted.
It will be seen that the motion, in the justice’s court, to dismiss the case rested upon two grounds: first, that no cause of action was set forth as required by law; and second, that the proceeding was instituted under certain sections of the code after those sections had been repealed, and hence there was no law to authorize it. We will consider these grounds in reverse order. Sections 2253 to 2260, inclusive, of the Civil Code were repealed by the act of December 7,1898 (Acts 1898, p. 50); consequently, if this were a proceeding under those sections, it would be open to the objection made in the second ground of the motion to dismiss. It is not to be presumed that an action instituted nearly four years after the repeal of a particular statute was based upon such statute, merely because it may, in some respects, resemble one for which such statute provided, if there is an existing law which will uphold and support the suit as instituted. And when the particular form of action which was authorized by a statute which has been repealed has not
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.