Puett & Co. v. McCall Co.
Puett & Co. v. McCall Co.
Opinion of the Court
Suit upon an account was brought in a' justice’s court, and the magistrate found in favor of the plaintiff. On the fifth day after the rendition of this judgment the defendants entered an appeal to a jury in the justice’s court. Upon the trial the magistrate overruled a motion to dismiss the appeal as having been entered too late, and the jury found in favor of the plaintiff. The defendants thereupon sued out a writ of certiorari. On the hearing in the superior court the judge of that court dismissed the certiorari on the ground that the appeal was a nullity because not entered in time, and held that the original judgment of the magistrate was still binding. The defendants (plaintiffs in certiorari) excepted. Our Civil Code provides (§§4138,4140) that an appeal to a jury in a justice’s court may be entered within four days, exclusive of Sundays,'after the rendition of the judgment of the magistrate. Where an appeal is entered after the expiration of the time prescribed, it amounts "to nothing. In the present case the record showed that the appeal was entered on the fifth day after the rendition of the' judgment, but there was nothing from which it could be determined whether or not one of the intervening days.had been Sunday. The record, therefore, did not show affirmatively either that the appeal had been in time or that it had been too late. It was or was not in time according to whether or not a Sunday came within four days after the rendi
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.