Murphey v. Harris
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Roberts v. Bank of Eufaula (Ga. Ct. App. 1917)
- Leonard v. State (Ga. 1909)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
J. Clay Murphey brought suit against E. B. Harris to enforce specific performance of an alleged contract for the sale of a lot and storehouse in Macon, Georgia. The petition set forth the contract sued upon, which is in writing and reads as follows:
“250.00 “Macon, Ga., Oct. 13, 1906.
“Received of J. Clay Murphey, Agent, two hundred fifty dollars ($250.00) part payment of purchase-price of property known as the E. B. Harris store in the City of Macon, located on the S. E. corner of Third and Cherry Sts. The same being the two-story brick building now occupied by me. It is understood that this is to be part of the purchase-price of said property, which is sold by me for the sum of thirty-six thousand dollars ($36,000.00). It is further understood that the title to the said property is to be examined and found perfect by purchaser before payment, examination to proceed at once, and payment made immediately upon acceptance.
“In witness whereof I hereunto set my hand and seal, this 13th day of October, 1906. [Signed] E. B. Harris.”
During the negotiations leading up to the payment of the $250 and the taking of the above receipt, Murphey, who is a real-estate agent, represented to Harris that he was acting for' a customer by the name of Henry, a traveling salesman for a New York house. About a month later Henry came to Macon, and on meeting Harris stated to him that he was unable to carry out the trade, having invested his money in New York, and asked Harris to release him from the contract. This Harris refused to do. Henry offered to pay $5,000 in cash and the balance in thirty days,-which Harris finally agreed to, but this agreement between them wa.s not reduced to writing. On leaving Macon Henry drew a check for $5,-000, which he left with Murphey. Murphey proceeded to have a bond for title drawn up and presented it to Harris to sign, tendering at the same, time $5,000. The obligee named in the bond for title was one Neel, Murphey informing Harris .at that time that Henry had sold his interest in the property through him to Neel. Harris declined to execute the bond for title. Murphej1, then ten
The facts above stated appear from the evidence introduced by plaintiff at the trial. No evidence was ■ offered by the defendant. Hpon motion of the defendant, the court awarded a nonsuit.
A decision of this case having been made and a rehearing granted, after reargument and reconsideration we have reached the same conclusion which we arrived at originally; but the original opinion filed by the court has been withdrawn, and the following has been substituted in lieu thereof.
It will be observed that the receipt was given in this case to “ J. Clay Murphey, Agent,” for $250, part purchase-price of certain real estate in Macon. It'stated that “It is understood that this is to be part of the purchase-price of said property, which is sold by me for the sum of thirty-six thousand dollars ($36,000.00). It is further understood that the title to the said property is to be examined and found perfect by purchaser before payment, examination to proceed at once and payment made immediately upon acceptance.” This was very vague and indefinite on its face. It did not in terms designate Murphey as the purchaser or distinctly agree to make title to him, or that he was the person to examine the title and pay the balance of the purchase-price upon satisfaction. The use of the word “Agent” after the name of Murphey, coupled with the omissions above indicated, and the use of the words, “to be examined and found perfect by purchaser before payment,” are not clear and explicit expressions to indicate a certain intention to sell the lot to Murphey and to have him satisfied with the title and thereupon pay the purchase-price and be entitled to have a conveyance made to him personally. If the contract should be held to have that effect, it would rather be by construction as a whole than because of direct and positive terms. How did the parties .concerned in the transaction deal with this trade, and whom did they treat as being the real contracting parties, bound on the one side, and entitled to enforce the contract on the other, as disclosed by the evidence introduced by the plaintiff ?. The writing did not on its face disclose the name of the principal, but throughout the negotiations Murphey purported to be acting, not for himself, hut as agent for another (Henry). He did not proceed with the examination of the title, or claim to be authorized to act except under
. And when Henry telegraphed us he said he would be delayed, and came here November 9th, and Harris was kept posted in regard to Henry’s delay.” When Henry reached Macon Murphey notified Harris, and the latter and Henry, together with one Marshall (a friend of Henry) and Murphey, met in Murphey’s office. Henry and Harris entered into a conversation in regard to the transaction, treating it not as Murphey’s trade but as Henry’s; and Murphey, though present, also acquiesced in this proceeding. Henry asked Harris to let him out of the trade, as he had made some investments and it would be inconvenient to get $36,000 in cash, and as he did, not get the telegram until after he had left New York. Harris said, “Well, I can not let you out of it. I am like you; I have made obligations; I have contracted some obligations for some timber interests, thinking about going into the business, and I can not let you out of the trade; otherwise I would be* glad to do so, because I think it is worth $40,000.” Henry replied, “I am sorry you take this view. I thought you would let me out. I can not pay you but $5,000 in cash- and give you $31,000 in thirty days.” Harris did not express assent to this at the time, but on the next' morning he and Henry again went to the office of Murphey and stated that Harris had agreed to accept the terms offered, and Henry also stated that he had agreed to let Harris stay in the corner store at a rent of $250 per month until the first of the following January, if Harris so desired. He also referred to what improvements he intended to make on the building, and Harris said he was not sure he would stay in the building. _ Henry wrote a check for $5,000, and left it in possession of Murphey. A bond for title was drawn by Murphey and West, an attorney. There was some discussion between Murphey and Harris as to in
Under the ruling above made, it becomes immaterial to discuss the questions raised on the pleadings. Had these rulings been made as the plaintiff contends they should have been, and had evidence been allowed in support of the rejected amendments, the result could not have been different.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.