Holliday v. Price
Cases that cite this one
4 later published cases cite this decision.
- Cheshire v. Keaton (Ga. 1937)
- Seymour v. Seymour (Ga. 1953)
- Owens v. Citizens & Southern National Bank (Ga. 1933)
- Almand v. Board of Education (Ga. 1926)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
P. J. Holliday and others brought suit against J. M. Price as executor of the last will and testament of T. A. Nash, in order to determine whether the devisees of a specific devise of land were- entitled to the rents and profits of the land from the date of the death of the testator. The plaintiffs sought to recover the value of 2500 lbs. of rent cotton collected by the executor. By agreement the case was heard by the trial judge, without the intervention of a jury, upon the following agreed statement of facts: “T. A. Nash died April 28, 1915, leaving a will. A certain tract of land was left to Holliday et al. This land had been rented, the previous fall, by testator to a tenant for a certain cotton rent. The executor, some four or five months after testator’s death, assented to the vesting of the legacy. The rent was 2500 lbs. of lint-cotton. and brought $250.00. The material portions of said will, relating to the case, are as follows: ‘Item 3. I give and bequeath to my grandson, Paul E. Williamson, the sum of four hundred .dollars in full of his share of my estate. Item 4. I give and bequeath to Mrs. Elizabeth Holliday all the real estate my wife, Alice Nash, had at the time of her marriage to me, consisting of 225
The trial judge evidently followed the decision in the ease Of Parker v. Chestnutt, 80 Ga. 12 (5 S. E. 289), where it was held that “Rents during the year in which testator died did not follow the land and belong to the devisees thereof, but formed a part of the residuum of the testator’s estate.” This is the only Georgia ease cited by the defendant in error in support of the decision of the trial judge. The Parker case is a full-bench decision. No authority is cited in support of the decision. It was rendered in 1887, while the Code of 1882 was of force.. Section 2459 of the •Code of 1882 provided that “The income, profits, or increase of ■specific legacies, as a general rule, go with the legacy, though the time of enjoyment or of vesting may be postponed.” This section of the Code of 1882, appearing in former codes, has been carried forward in all the codes subsequently published. It will be found in the Code of 1910 as section 3903, which is identical with the section of the Code of 1882 above auoted, except that the word “profits” is used in the singular number in the Code of 1910. The distinguished judge who wrote the opinion of the court in the Parker case (supra) said: “In the case of a life-tenant who dies
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.