Campbell v. Rybert
Campbell v. Rybert
Opinion of the Court
P. R. Campbell’sued T. P. Rybert for alleged purchase-money of described personal property which had been placed in the possession of the defendant as a lessee, with an alleged option in the plaintiff to sell the property to the defendant after the expiration of one year. The petition was held good against a general demurrer, in 44 Ga. App. 852 (163 S. E. 240). The plaintiff also hied a suit for injunction respecting the same property, and Rybert Printing Company intervened as a party defendant in each case. The two cases were thereafter consolidated and converted into one case, and upon the trial thereof the court directed a verdict in favor of the defendants. The plaintiff’s motion for a new trial was overruled, and he excepted.
The defendants in error have contended that the judgment should be affirmed for several distinct reasons. Being thoroughly satisfied that the judgment was right for at least one of the reasons stated, we will place our decision upon that ground, without reference to other questions. While it appeared from the allegations that the defendant Rybert was in possession of the property as a lessee at the time the original suit was filed, the evidence adduced upon the trial showed without dispute that pending the litigation the plaintiff, after reacquiring possession of the property, delivered it to another person under a lease contract renewable by the latter from year to year for the total period of ten years; and the defendants having pleaded these facts as a defense, the plaintiff was not entitled to recover upon his alleged claim for the purchase-money.
The plaintiff has not contended that he would be entitled to any of the equitable relief sought if the court was right in directing the verdict against him with respect to his demand for the purchase-money. There was no error in directing such verdict..
Judgment affirmed. Cross-bill of exceptions dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- CAMPBELL v. RYBERT et vice versa
- Status
- Published