Stanley v. Stanley
Cases that cite this one
13 later published cases cite this decision.
- Community Loan & Investment Corp. v. Bowden (Ga. Ct. App. 1940)
- Trustees of Jesse Parker Williams Hospital v. Nisbet (Ga. 1941)
- Tingle v. Harvill (Ga. 1971)
- Rushing v. Bashlor (Ga. 1963)
- Ealy v. Tolbert (Ga. 1953)
- Scurry v. Cook (Ga. 1950)
- Thomas v. Dumas (Ga. 1950)
- Norwood v. Norwood (Ga. 1950)
- Stow v. Hargrove (Ga. 1948)
- Stow v. Hargrove (Ga. 1948)
- Georgia Power Company v. Roper (Ga. 1947)
- Sovereign Camp Woodmen of the World v. Ellis (Ga. Ct. App. 1939)
- Chestnut v. Weekes (Ga. 1935)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This was a suit by a widow and sole heir at law to canecí a deed made by the plaintiff’s husband to his nephew shortly before the husband’s death, the alleged grounds for cancellation being (1) mental incapacity of the grantor, and (2) fraud by the grantee. After a verdict for the plaintiff, the defendant moved for a new trial, which the court refused, and he excepted. Held:
1. In Dicken v. Johnson, 7 Ga. 484 (2), it was held that if insanity is proved to have existed previously to the execution of the deed, the pre
2. There being some evidence that the defendant grantee knew of the insanity of the grantor at the time the deed was executed, the plaintiff’s failure to make restitution did not require a verdict against her. Cheves-Green & Co. Inc. v. Horton, 177 Ga. 525 (2) (170 S. E. 491).
3. Under one phase of the evidence, the jury could have found that while the grantor was not wholly incapable of entering into such a contract, he was yet possessed of little or no will power, being afflicted both in body and in mind, and was greatly under the influence of the nephew to whom the deed was executed, and that the deed was “improvident or profuse.” In these circumstances, an inference of fraud could have been drawn by the jury, and the evidence for the defendant grantee not being such as to rebut the inference as a matter of law, the court was authorized to charge the jury upon the subject of fraud. Civil Code (1910), §§ 4626, 4630; Causey v. Wiley, 27 Ga. 444 (3); Woodruff v. Wilkinson, 73 Ga. 115 (3); Orton v. Madden, 75 Ga. 83; Frizzell v. Reed, 77 Ga. 724.
4. The court did not err in refusing a new trial.
Judgment affh-med.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.