Alona v. Kupau
Opinion of the Court
Opinion of tbe Court by
This is an action of assumpsit for money had and received. It was tried before Mr. Justice Judd, the jury being waived, at the July Term, 1881, who decided that the plaintiff could not recover. To this decision the plaintiff duly excepted and brought his exceptions to the Court in Banco.
The facts are substantially as follows: On the 6th day of November, 1881, the plaintiff paid to defendant $850, as rent in advance for five years for a piece of land in Waialua, Oahu. The receipt passed at the time is put in evidence and also a lease from defendant to plaintiff, dated November 1, 1880, and recorded November 6; 1880, for the said land for fifteen years.
There is also in evidence the records of a suit in equity in
The plaintiff seeks in this action to recover back the rent ■advanced on the ground that the lease which he took from ■defendant has been ordered to be delivered up for cancellar hi on, and a lease to Aiau has been executed. Mr. Justice Judd in the Court below held that the plaintiff' could not re-cover. From this decision the plaintiff appeals to the Court in Banco.
W>e have .examined with great care the decision of the '-Court below in this case, and the evidence on which it was based, and we think the decision must be affirmed. That Alona and Kupau attempted to defraud Aiau out of his lease, there can be no doubt. That Kupau knew that he had heretofore leased to Aiau is unquestionable; that Alona also knew it, was found by the Court and is indisputable. Knowing this fact they combined to give and take the lease, and Alona paid and Kupau received the §850 sought to be recovered
“ The general rule is, that when an illegal contract has been made, neither a Court of -law nor of equity will interpose to grant relief to the parties thereto, if they have been equal partakers and promoters of the illegality, but it -will leave them as it finds them, according to the maxim: ‘In pari delicto potior est conditio defendeniis et possidentis.’ ”
See Story ©n Contracts, Section 489.
Doubtless, in such cases it has been held, since the early days, that the plaintiff cannot recover, with certain exceptions which will now be considered. See Parsons on Contracts, Vol. 2, p. 258-4.
Pepper vs. Haight, 20 Barb., 429-38.
If the fraudulent contract made is still executory, and the fraudulent purpose has not been consummated, any money paid may be recovered back before the fraudulent consummation.
See Morgan vs. Groff, 4 Barb., 527-8-9 and cases cited.
That is not this case, for the fraudulent purpose was consummated by the delivery and record of the lease to the plaintiff. It is also held by well considered authorities that a conveyance of either real or personal property in fraud of creditors, although voidable by them, is good between the parties even if the grantee shared in the fraudulent intent.
See Harvey vs. Varnum, 98 Mass., 118-20; also dissenting opinion of Chief Justice Nelson. Nellis vs. Clark, 20 Wend., 38-9-40.
If this be sound law, and we do not now question it, it does not help the plaintiff. An important and radical distinction is made between an action in affirmance of an illegal contract, and where the action proceeds in disaffirmance of such a
The action here seeks to avoid an executed contract which was malum in se ; no leading authority can be found to sustain a recovery in such a case.
See Morgan vs. Groff and cases cited, 4 Barb., p. 527.
There is also an undoubted distinction between contracts which are immorail and criminal, and those that are merely void. See Vischer vs. Yates, 11 John., 29. Nellis vs. Clark, 30 Wend., 38.
On void contracts recoveries have been allowed. White vs. Franklin Bank, 22 Pick., 181. Utica Insurance Company vs. Cadwell, 3 Wend., 296.
This is not a case of a merely void contract. It is immoral. None of the distinctions above referred to help the plaintiff in this case. *\%e have examined with care all the available authoi’ities cited by the plaintiff’s counsel, and think that all may be classed under the exceptions, allowing recovery above referred to. The cancellation of the lease ordered was of no
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.