Brown v. Carvalho

Hawaii Supreme Court
Brown v. Carvalho, 9 Haw. 180 (Haw. 1893)
1893 Haw. LEXIS 66
Bickerton, Erear, Judd

Brown v. Carvalho

Opinion of the Court

Opinion, oe the Court, by

Judd, C.J.

In this- ease the defendants plead as a demurrer a misjoinder of a defendant, and on this plea being overruled by the court,, took an appeal to the Supreme Oourt.

Having* called in the respective counsel and heard their views and referring to the cases of the Provisional Government vs. W. G. Smith (page 178- ante), and Provisional Government vs. Ah Urn (pagp 164 ante), we now apply the- opinions expressed therein to. this case and hold that the ruling on the demurrer was not appealable, although available as a point of law on appeal if the district magistrate had made a decision in the case which disposed of it so far as- his court was concerned.

A decision in the- statute on appeals means' a final one so-far as that court is concerned. For instance, if the court had sustained the- demurrer and no amendment was asked for and obtained, by plaintiff, then the decision thereon would be final in that court.

We therefore- decline to entertain the case and send it back to- the district court- for further proceedings. Costs to abide the final event.

Reference

Full Case Name
FRANK BROWN v. JOSE J. CARVALHO, DOMINGO J. L. MATTOS and J. M. VIVAS
Cited By
4 cases
Status
Published