Grace v. Territory of Hawaii

Hawaii Supreme Court
Grace v. Territory of Hawaii, 13 Haw. 465 (Haw. 1901)
1901 Haw. LEXIS 42
Frear, Galbraith, Perry

Grace v. Territory of Hawaii

Opinion of the Court

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

FREAR, C.J.

This is a submission without action on the following agreed facts:

In February, 1901, a policeman at Hilo, Hawaii, without authority, justification or extenuation by law, shot and wounded a private citizen. It immediately became necessary to extract the bullet from the wounded man. The Sheriff of Hawaii requested the plaintiff, who was a licensed physician and surgeon practicing in Hilo-, to perform the operation, promising him reasonable compensation for the service by the department of' the Attorney-General. The plaintiff performed the service im a skillful manner and rendered a bill therefor to the said department. The question is whether the Territory is liable.

In our opinion the Sheriff was without authority to bind the-Territory to pay for an operation upon a private citizen made-*466necessary by an unauthorized act of a policeman. Judgment for tbe defendant.

Tbe plaintiff in person. Attorney-Qmeral E. P. Dole for tbe defendant.

Reference

Full Case Name
JOHN J. GRACE v. THE TERRITORY OF HAWAII
Cited By
2 cases
Status
Published