Wilcox v. Hartman
Wilcox v. Hartman
Opinion of the Court
OPINION OF THE COURT BY
This is an action for the rent of a furnished house of two rooms at the rate of $25 a month. At the close of the plaintiff’s evidence, which consisted of the brief testimony of the plaintiff alone, the magistrate granted a nonsuit upon the motion of the defendant, and the question is whether he erred in doing so.
The argument in support of the nonsuit is substantially that the declaration is upon an express promise by the defendant to pay at the rate mentioned while the proof is of a similar promise on the part of the defendant’s wife. The plaintiff contends that the husband is legally liable for necessaries furnished to the wife. The defendant does not dispute this or that the husband might be liable for the use and occupation of the premises by himself on an implied contract irrespective of his obligation to support his wife, but contends that in either case he would be liable only for the reasonable value of the use of the house and not upon an express promise m&de by the wife for a definite rental.
It will be unnecessary to consider the legal obligation of the husband to support the wife, which is sometimes said, though inappropriately, to constitute her his agent for the procurement of necessaries for herself. The wife may be made the actual agent of the husband either expressly or by implication just as any other person may be, and within certain limits or for certain purposes less is required to show an authorization or ratification of a promise made by the wife than is required in cases of other persons, for it is natural and customary and indeed to a large extent necessary that certain matters should be left to and looked after by the wife.
In this case the minutes of the testimony may be imperfect owing to condensation and it may be that the testimony as act
The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- MRS. W. L. WILCOX v. E. E. HARTMAN
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published