f\) NO. 2W lN THE SUPREME COURT CF THE STATE OF HAWAl‘I STATE OF HAWAIT, by its attorney General, _M ReSpondent/Plaintiff/Ccunterclaim Defendant/CroSS§Clai .

Defendant-Appellant, v§¢ @M

vS. 1 “A' jj

EARTHJUSTlCE, _t; Petitioner/Defendant/Counterclaimant-Appellee,v ‘I and EARTHJUSTICE LEGAL DEFENSE FUND and DAVID L. HENKIN, ReSpondente/DefendantS-Appellees, and PILAYX 400, LLC and PFLUEGER PROPERTlES, ReSpondentS/PlaintiffS-IntervenorS/CroSS~ClaimantS-AppelleeS.

CERTIORARI TO THE INTERMEDlATE COURT OF APPEALS (CIV. NO. 03-l-l203) ORDER REJECTlNG APPLICATlON FOR WRIT OF CERTlORARl (By: Nakayama, J., for the courtW Petitioner'S application for writ of certiorari filed on November 30, 2009, is hereby rejected.

DATED: Honolulu, Hawafi, January l2, 20lO.

FOR THE COURT: ;%A»»4u.C1Y7\0hMQL¢7@;n19»§ ASSociate Justice 3

Paul H. Achitoff and Koalani L. Kaulukukui of EarthjuStice for petitioners on the application lConSidered by: Moon, C.J., Nakayama, Acoba, and Duffy, JJ., and Circuit Judge Alm, in place of Recktenwald, J., recuSed.