Crew v. McClung
Crew v. McClung
Opinion of the Court
Opinion hy
This suit was commenced by attachment, against Thomas Crew and others, on three promissory notes. A demurrer to the petition, and a motion to dissolve the attachment, were overruled. Judgment was rendered in favor of plaintiff for the the full amount of the notes, although one of the three notes had not. matured, at the date of the judgment.
1. The appellants seek to reverse the judgment under, the assumption that the court erred in overruling the demurrer. As the causes assigned for demurrer are applicable only to that part of the petition which relates to the attachment branch of the case, that ruling should not disturb the judgment on the merits.
2. It is urged that the motion to dissolve the attachment, was erroneously overruled. The reasons assigned for this, motion, are applicable to that part of the petition which relates to attachments for debts not due, and on which nothing but time is wanting, to fix an absolute indebtedness. The petition stated this fact, as required by the. Code, and also stated “ that said defendants have disposed of their property, in part, with intent to defraud their
3. The defendant’s answer traversed those facts in the petition, upon which the attachment was issued, but admitted the execution of the notes. And thereupon the court rendered judgment upon all the notes, without deciding the issue. The averments in relation to the attachment were material. If those averments were not true, the plaintiff had no right to a continuance of the attachment lien, nor had he a right to his action upon the note that was not due. As those material facts were distinctly traversed by defendant’s answer, the issue should have been regularly tried and determined. But as those facts relate only to the attachment, and the note which had not matured, the judgment will be reversed only so far as they are concerned. ■
4. The only remaining question presented in this case is, can a judgment be properly rendered upon a note or debt before it is due ? "Where nothing but time is wanted to fix an absolute indebtedness, an attachment may be issued to secure such indebtedness, under the provisions of the Code, § 1852; but it does not follow that a judgment may
The attachment is dissolved, and so far as it relates to the note that was not due, the judgment is reversed.
Judgment reversed.
Reference
- Status
- Published