Reynolds v. Nichols & Co.
Cases that cite this one
12 later published cases cite this decision.
- Staff Management and New Hampshire Insurance Company v. Pascuala Jimenez (Iowa 2013)
- Hamilton v. Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railway Co. (Iowa 1910)
- Iowa Electric Co. v. Incorporated Town of Winthrop (Iowa 1924)
- Dodson v. McCurnin (Iowa 1917)
- Barngrover v. Pettigrew (Iowa 1905)
- Lindt v. Uihlein (Iowa 1902)
- Smith v. Sherman (Iowa 1901)
- Gipps Brewing Co. v. De France (Iowa 1894)
- McIntosh v. Wilson (Iowa 1890)
- Dively v. City of Cedar Falls (Iowa 1869)
- Scheible v. Bacho (Ala. 1868)
- Dively v. City of Cedar Falls (Iowa 1866)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
As the injunction was made perpetual as to the collection of the entire sum secured by the trust deed, it is manifest that the bill was sustained upon the third or last ground, to-wit: the illegality of the consideration.
The deed was made to secure a loan in February, 1858. The consideration was, “Post notes of the Dubuque Harbor Co.;” made in Nov. 1857, issued by a corporation organized under the general incorporation laws of this State, transacting and having its sole place of business within this State; said notes being issued with the purpose and design of having them circulate as money.
The Constitution of 1846, art. 8, declares that no corporate body shall be created, with the privilege of making, issuing or putting in circulation any check, promissory note, certificate or other paper to circulate as money; and that the Genera] Assembly shall by law prohibit any person, association or corporation from exercising the privilege of banking or creating paper to circulate as money. Accordingly, by chap. 147 of the Code of 1851, it is provided, that if any person subscribe to or become a member of any such association or company, he shall be fined and imprisoned; that all notes and securities made or given to any such organization, or given to secure the payment of any money loaned or discounted by any such-company or its officers, are void; and that if any person or corporation shall issue any such bills to be loaned or circulated as money, or to be used as currency or circulating medium, they shall be fined not exceeding one thousand dollars. Our present constitution, which took effect September 3d, 1857, removes the prohibition contained in the former, and gives the legislature th© power to create a State Bank, and banks under a general banking law, with certain restrictions and limitations. In March, 1858, two laws upon these respective subjects were passed which took effect in July of the same year.
Under the Code of 1851, in the light of the provisions quoted, can this transaction be upheld ? It seems to us clearly not. Says Shaw, C. J., in White v. Bass, 3 Cush. 448: “ It is well settled by the authorities, that any promise, contract or undertaking, the performance of which would tend to promote, advance or carry into effect any object or purpose which is unlawful, is in itself void, and will not maintain an action. The law which prohibits the end, will not lend its aid in promoting the means designed to carry into effect, and in this respect, the law gives no
The statute expressly prohibited the issuing of this paper, and affixed a penalty for its violation. It was void, in its inception, void in the hands of any person. To allow a third person to recover, for it as a loan of money, would recognize that as right which the law has declared wrong. How more effectually could the courts of the State promote and advance an act "which is unlawful, (the putting these notes in circulation,) than to hold that third persons could enforce all contracts having for their consideration this illegal and spurious paper. It seems to us none.
This view renders an examination of the other points in the case unnecessary.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.