Supreme Court of Iowa, 1862

Lewis v. Denton

Lewis v. Denton
Supreme Court of Iowa · Decided June 18, 1862 · Wright
13 Iowa 441

Lewis v. Denton

Opinion of the Court

Wright, J.

A set-off is not a defense to an action. It is the defendant’s action against plaintiff, and plaintiff’s right to recover upon his cause of action is in no manner affected by such set-off.

If, therefore, an action is brought upon a note, duly assigned, in the name of the assignee, the defendant cannot, while the action thus stands, ask to litigate a set-off against the assignor, by simply averring in his pleadings that such assignor is the real party in interest. He is not a party to the record, and no judgment could be taken against him on such set-off, and substantially defendant asks such judgment when he pleads his set-off.

The demurrer was properly sustained.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.