Lyon v. O'Kell
Lyon v. O'Kell
Opinion of the Court
This suit is upon certain promissory notes given by the defendant to plaintiff in consideration of the sale of several tracts of land. The plaintiff, when the notes were executed and delivered, gave to the defendant bonds for deeds to said lands sold, conditioned that the title should be made out and delivered upon the payment in full of the purchase money, time being made the essence of the contract. The defendant answered, setting up a failure of consideration, fraud, &c., and averred that the plaintiff, had no title to said lots and, therefore, no right to convey the same. The cause was continued, and at the succeeding term the defendant filed a plea puis darien continuance.
In the ruling of the court, in sustaining this demurrer, we think there was error. The plaintiff, by his demurrer, admits such matters in this special plea as are well pleaded. If it is admitted by the plaintiff that the property described in the bonds was so encumbered by judgments as to render it impossible for him to make a deed in accordance with the terms of the contract, he should not recover on the notes given by defendant, in consideration of the sale to him of said lands. We understand this to be the effect of the demurrer.
Reversed.
Reference
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published