Stoddard v. Thompson
Cases that cite this one
27 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Kuiken v. Garrett (Iowa 1952)
- In re Estate of Lyman (Iowa 1940)
- Leach v. First Nat. Bk. of Ft. Dodge (Iowa 1928)
- Hoskins v. Hotel Randolph Co. (Iowa 1927)
- King v. Farmers Grain Co. (Iowa 1922)
- Roche v. American Surety Co. (Iowa 1921)
- Koch v. City of Weston (Mo. Ct. App. 1920)
- Coleman v. Bosworth (Iowa 1917)
- In re Board of Education of the City of Perry (Okla. 1913)
- Canal Construction Co. v. Woodbury County (Iowa 1909)
- Elliott v. Morris (Tex. App. 1906)
- Montgomery v. Alden (Iowa 1906)
- Citizens' National Bank v. City National Bank (Iowa 1900)
- Bernard v. Merrill (Me. 1898)
- State ex rel. National Subway Co. v. St. Louis (Mo. 1898)
- State ex rel. Kane v. Johnson (Mo. 1894)
- Puterbaugh v. Puterbaugh (Ind. Ct. App. 1893)
- Baxter, Reed & Co. v. Myers (Iowa 1892)
- Roby v. Eggers (Ind. 1891)
- Bellows v. Litchfield (Iowa 1891)
- Millikan v. City of Lafayette (Ind. 1889)
- People ex rel. Clinton v. Lanins (Mich. 1889)
- Montgomery v. Vickery (Ind. 1887)
- Palmer v. Hayes (Ind. 1887)
- Henry v. Woods (Mo. 1883)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
— The petition alleges that defendant Thompson proposed to plaintiff that, in consideration of $3,000 in notes and- demands to be transferred by plaintiff to him,,he would provide for and maintain plaintiff and his wife during their lives and would maintain and educate a grand-daughter of the plaintiff, then a member of his family, until she arrived at the age of eighteen. This proposition was accepted , by plaintiff, and a contract was signed by defendant, to that effect, but was not executed by plaintiff and, in fact, was not completed and delivered, and was not intended to be until plaintiff and defendant could arrange their business affairs in a maimer to enable them so to do. Thompson never performed-nor offered to perform his agreement or to complete the contract, but that certain notes, held by plaintiff against others, coming into his possession, he claims them as his own under said contract. Upon one of these notes made by Wilson he brought suit and recovered judgment which he is about to collect, and the other note, unless restrained, he will proceed to collect. It is. alleged that Thompson is insolvent. Á temporary injunction, restraining him from the collection of the judgment and note, was allowed, which, upon the final hearing, was made perpetual, and by the decree the contract, which is alleged by Thompson to have been completed, and under which he claims the right to collect and appropriate the proceeds .of the note and judgment, is canceled and annulled and plaintiff authorized to collect them. The makers of the note and the judgment debtor are made defendants in this action. ,
There is a very considerable mass of testimony upon the issues of fact in this case. We will not be expected to give a statement of its substance, or enter into a discussion as to its effect. W§ are of the opinion that the alleged contract between the parties under which Thompson claims the note in question was never completed. The evidence as to the facts connected with the instrument is conflicting, but the weight of testimony supports the conclusion just stated.
■ It is shown by the evidence of Thompson, whose statements upon this branch of the case are not contradicted, that the plaintiff employed counsel to defend the action brought ■ upon the Wilson note whereon judgment was rendered; that he agreed with the maker of the note to pay the costs of defending the suit, and was a witness upon the trial. It appears from the record that the defense set up in that action was that plaintiff and not Thompson, was the owner of the note. The issue thus made was determined in favor of Thompson, and plaintiff, though not a party to the suit, is bound by the adjudication. One who, though not a party, defends or prosecutes an action by employing counsel, paying costs, and by doing those things which are usually done by a party, is bound by the judgment rendered therein. Davis v. Milburn, 4 Iowa, 246; McNamee v. Morelamd, 26 id. 97.
Under this rule plaintiff is bound by the judgment in the
The decree of the district court will be affirmed as to all matters involved in the suit except as to the judgment upon the Wilson note. The right of Thompson to collect that judgment will not be interfered with. A decree will be entered in- this court accordingly, or, at the option of plain-' tiff, the cause will be remanded to the district court for a like decree there. Plaintiff will pay the costs of this appeal.
Modified and
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.