Farris v. Ingraham, Kennedy & Day
Opinion of the Court
We do not understand appellant to claim that the notice was not in fact served in the manner stated in the return, nor that in this action the return may be impeached by showing its falsity. From appellant’s argument we extract the following: “ "We do not deem it necessary to inquire whether or not the judgment in question would have been upheld on,appeal, where no direct proof of the insufficiency of the service could have been given; .nor whether, if the sheriff’s return had stated every fact neces. sary to constitute a perfect service, we could impeach the same by direct evidence that it is false. Our claim is that
The specific objection urged is, that the return does not state that the notice was left at the house of defendant, or at any house which was his uusal place of residence. Rev., § 2817. This identical question was considered in the case of Neally v. Redman, 5 Iowa, 387, under the provisions of section 1723 of the Code, substantially in this regard the same as those of the Revision, and the return was held to be a. substantial compliance with the law. See, also, Davis v. Burt et al., 7 Iowa, 56.
The court did not err in dissolving the injunction.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.