Supreme Court of Iowa, 1873

Pollock v. Landis

Pollock v. Landis
Supreme Court of Iowa · Decided June 19, 1873 · Day
36 Iowa 651
Pollock v. Landis

Cases that cite this one

5 later published cases cite this decision.

This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

Opinion of the Court

Day, J.

— There are two classes of persons who are entertained by innkeepersffor reward, guests and boarders.

Upon the goods of the former the innkeeper has a lien, but upon those of the latter he has not. 2 Parsons (5th ed.), 150, and cases cited.

It is not pertinent to this case to consider under what circumstances a person falls within the one or the other of these classes. The only question now presented is: Does the answer show that plaintiff remained with defendant in the character of a boarder, and not in the capacity of a guest %

The allegation of the answer is that the plaintiff hoarded with defendant. Boarded is the imperfect tense of the verb board, which means, to receive food as a lodger, or without lodgings, for a compensation. A lodger is one who lives at board, or in a hired room, or who has a bed in another’s house for a night. Webster’s Dictionary. The allegation that plaintiff boarded with defendant- is merely an averment that he received food from defendant for a compensation. The answer does not state whether he received this food as a boarder or as a guest. Under the allegations of the answer he may have received it in either capacity. And the answer being thus uncertain, might have been vulnerable to a motion for a more specific statement.

But as it does not appear upon the face of the answer that plaintiff was entertained as a boarder, the answer does not state facts which avoid the cause of action, and the demurrer was properly overruled.

The answer also alleges that plaintiff boarded with defendant “ for the space of about eight weeks.” But mere duration of time does not determine one’s character as a guest or a boarder. See 2 Parsons on Contracts (5th ed.), pages 150-152, and cases cited. Shoecraft v. Bailey, 25 Iowa, 553.

Affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.