Portman v. Klemish
Cases that cite this one
10 later published cases cite this decision.
- Baldridge v. Evans (Iowa 1917)
- Merrill v. Comstock (Wis. 1913)
- Crawford v. Bergen (Iowa 1894)
- Thielen v. Schechinger (Iowa 1930)
- Elliott v. Des Moines National Bank (Iowa 1929)
- Harvey v. Mason City & Fort Dodge Railroad (Iowa 1906)
- Ellithorpe v. Reidessell (Iowa 1893)
- In re Estate of Wonn (Iowa 1890)
- Williams v. Brown (Iowa 1889)
- Crispin v. Winkleman (Iowa 1881)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
In all that the defendant did he appears to have acted honestly, and with no intention other than to assist the widow in the proper management and disposition of the estate. The notes appear to have been deposited by him with Kapler as a friend and neighbor, and because Kapler had a safe in which they could be kept. When this was done does not distinctly appear, but if it was done before the plaintiff’s appointment it could hardly be regarded as an interference with the estate. It was not, to be sure, the defendant’s right to use the money collected in payment of the debts of the estate, even though done by the widow’s consent and under her direction. Still there is no pretense that the debts were not due, and that the estate did not derive the whole benefit of the payments. In taking some of the notes from Kapler and delivering them to the widow the defendant may have been guilty of an interference, but it is not shown to us that the estate sustained any damage.
It appeal’s to us that the plaintiff’s claim has very small foundation. Possibly the plaintiff should have been allowed nominal damages, but we cannot reverse upon such ground. Watson v. Van Meter, 43 Iowa, 76.
Akfirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.