Miller v. Poage
Cases that cite this one
11 later published cases cite this decision.
- Quinn v. Bane (Iowa 1917)
- State Bank v. Bilstad (Iowa 1912)
- First National Bank v. Buttery (N.D. 1908)
- Culbertson v. Nelson (Iowa 1895)
- Collins v. State Farm Ins. Co. (La. Ct. App. 2008)
- Cedar Rapids National Bank v. Weber (Iowa 1917)
- Farmer v. Bank of Graettinger (Iowa 1906)
- Sawyer v. Campbell (Iowa 1899)
- Hegeler v. Comstock (S.D. 1890)
- Charlton v. Reed (Iowa 1883)
- Woodbury v. Roberts (Iowa 1882)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Dissenting Opinion
disseibtvng. I cannot concur in the foregoing opinion. It cites no authority and is in conflict with Cotta v. Bucle, 7 Met., 588, to which it refers. In my opinion the instrument in question possesses all the elements of negotiability. The italicized portion does not render the note payable out of a particular fund, but simply provides a condition upon which the payment shall be extended one year. The note may be payable in one year. It is payable absolutely in two years. In my opinion the plaintiff should have recovered.
Opinion of the Court
We think the true construction is that the maker was the agent of the payee for the sale of something, and if he realized sufficient funds from such sales the amount specified was to be paid within one year. Payment during such time was to be made only on condition that the necessary funds were realized. . This clearly implies the instrument was to be paid out of a particular fund, and for this reason, and because payable only on the happening of a condition, it was not negotiable during the period aforesaid. It is true it is payable absolutely at the expiration of two years. But we think it must have been negotiable when executed, and continuously from that time, or not at all.
No adjudicated case to which our attention has been called is precisely like this. The nearest approach to it is Cotta v. Buck, 7 Met., 588. It is difficult to draw a sharp distinction between the two cases. We shall not, therefore, make the attempt, but determine the case at bar upon principle, as we deem right.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.