McIntosh v. Lee
Cases that cite this one
13 later published cases cite this decision.
- Canafax v. Bank of Commerce of McLoud (Okla. 1919)
- Tate v. Gaines (Okla. 1909)
- Johnson v. Cook (Wash. 1901)
- Rogers v. Hill (Court Of Appeals Of Indian Territory 1901)
- Bradtfeldt v. Cooke (Or. 1895)
- Witmer v. Fitzgerald (Iowa 1930)
- Sanders v. Sutlive Bros. & Co. (Iowa 1919)
- Gooch v. Gooch (Iowa 1916)
- Van Sickle v. Staub (Iowa 1912)
- Bristow v. Carriger (Okla. 1909)
- Byrne v. Independent School District of Struble (Iowa 1908)
- First National Bank v. Kingsley (Me. 1891)
- Wilson v. VanLeer (Pa. 1889)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
If the plaintiff had alleged that the lease, although bearing the date of March 10th, 1878, was not in fact executed upon that day, it might have been competent to prove upon what da}*- the lease was executed. But under a petition alleging that it was executed on the day it bears date, it was not competent to prove that it was executed upon a different date.
The allegation, therefore, that the plaintiff is damaged sixty dollars on account of a failure to do the breaking, and five hundred dollars on account of the abandonment of the premises, is not admitted by a failure to deny it.
The plaintiff introduced no proof of the amount of his damages, and was, therefore, at the most, entitled to a judgment for but nominal damages.
We have held that we will not reverse a case and order a new trial for a failure to assess mere nominal damages. Watson v. Van Meter, 43 Iowa, 76.
The judgment is
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.