Town of Toledo v. Edens
Cases that cite this one
7 later published cases cite this decision.
- Hopkins v. Metropolitan District (Conn. 1932)
- Peterson v. Tacoma Railway & Power Co. (Wash. 1910)
- People v. Detroit United Railway (Mich. 1910)
- Seattle Lighting Co. v. City of Seattle (Wash. 1909)
- Deneen v. Houghton County Street-Railway Co. (Mich. 1907)
- Indiana Railway Co. v. Hoffman (Ind. 1904)
- Inhabitants of Bloomfield v. Mayor of Glen Ridge (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1896)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
I. In February, 1878, the town passed an ordinance providing “that no person shall sell within the limits of said town, or of any territory over which the town
On the 3d day of September, 1878, the defendant sold beer outside of, but within one mile of, the corporate limits of the town, and without any license to make such sale.
Chapter 119 of the acts of 1878 became a law on the 4th day of July of that year, and it contains the following among other provisions:
“Seo. 9. The power and jurisdiction of every municipal corporation, whether acting under general or special charter, to regulate, prohibit and license the sale of ale, wine and beer, and of the courts and officers thereof to enforce said regulations, is hereby extended two miles beyond the city limits of-said corporation, * * * * . ”
The question to be determined is, did the ordinance in question operate to prohibit unlicensed sales within two miles of the city limits? ¥e think it did. The section above quoted is an absolute extension of the jurisdiction of the city to all points within the two miles limit, and an absolute extension of the jurisdiction and power of the courts and officers of the city two miles beyond the city limits. If an ordinance be enacted and afterward the city limits be extended by adding thereto adjacent territory, no one would contend that a new ordinance must be passed in order to be operative in the newly acquired territory.
We can see no difference between that case and this. By this law the extension of the power and jurisdiction is absolute. It does not depend on any act or ordinance of the city specially adopting or invoking the power. If the.ordinance had been passed after the law went into force it would not have been necessary that it should specify that its operation extended two miles beyond the city limits. It is so extended by the express provision of the law.
II. It is urged that the law in question is unconstitutional.
III. The ordinance provided as a penalty for its violation a fine of not less than $50 nor more than $100. The court assessed a fine of $50, which is claimed to be excessive. As we hold the prosecution was properly commenced, and carried on under the ordinance, the fine could not have been in a less amount than that fixed by the court.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.